5 ms·
My knowledge is a decade or so out of date, but encrypted transmissions have been allowed in the past, so long as the key for decrypting the payloads was availa
by falcolas 7y ago
My knowledge is a decade or so out of date, but encrypted transmissions have been allowed in the past, so long as the key for decrypting the payloads was available on request (much like how GNU says source code must be available).
For example, you can transmit video over amateur bands, even though the signal could be considered to be encrypted if you don't have the standard for decoding the signal.
- kyberias 7y agoLet's not confuse encryption with encoding.
- geofft 7y agoBut encoding is relevant here too. If people cannot make sense of the messages, whether or not they're cryptographically secure, the messages aren't fulfilling the pedagogical purpose of the amateur service.
- steve19 7y agoThe average English speaking American probably won't be able to make sense of someone speaking Haitian, nobody says everyone must be able to understand you. But you can record the Hiatian speakers message and get it translated. With sufficient encryption, recorded messages cannot ever be decoded unless the key was broadcast, which it never would be.
- falcolas 7y ago> But you can record the Hiatian speakers message and get it translated. However, this exact form of encoding was used as a form of encryption while the US was at war; the Navajo Code Talkers. Somewhat off topic, of course, but a great example of how encryption and encoding can have identical end results.
- Retra 7y agoYou can record an encrypted message and get it decrypted by anyone who demonstrates knowledge of the key. The process is identical to finding someone who demonstrates knowledge of Haitian. Encryption is nothing more than an uncommon encoding.
- jpindar 7y agoAnalog video signals are pretty distinctive, anyone with an oscilloscope could recognize them.