14 ms·
Imagine a hypothetical private company with a radio system that is used 5% of the time for important messages in major emergencies, and 95% of the time for bill
by michaelt 7y ago
Imagine a hypothetical private company with a radio system that is used 5% of the time for important messages in major emergencies, and 95% of the time for billionaires' yachts.
In a genuine emergency where many lives were at stake, one might give them great leeway to break the law, just like fire trucks can speed and run red lights.
But when there's no emergency, should such rulebreaking be allowed for the billionaires' yachts?
Obviously, the e-mail-by-radio system at the heart of this argument isn't all about billionaires' yachts - but still, there's no reason loosened rules for emergencies should be extended to non-emergency use.
- tyingq 7y agoIf you kill the incentive for private citizens to "be there", though, it evaporates.
- duckqlz 7y agoSeems hyperbolic. Considering the transfer speeds and relatively low cost of sat internet I sincerely doubt that "billionaires" are using winlink to a point that is interrupting the global ham radio band. [1] http://www.groundcontrol.com/MCD-4800_BGAN_Terminal.htm http://www.groundcontrol.com/MCD-4800_BGAN_Terminal.htm [2] https://www.winlink.org/sites/default/files/download/wl2k_faq_0.pdf https://www.winlink.org/sites/default/files/download/wl2k_fa... (see A170)
- kayfox 7y agoTheres a decent number of people who use Winlink as a substitute for Sailmail and thusly are in violation of 97.113(a)5.
- ineedasername 7y agoWhy do they do it? Is it a cost or convenience issue (or both)?