4 ms·
> As far as voltage is concerned, there's a very good reason why most of the world uses about 240 volts for "normal" outlets. If North America would ever decid
by throw0101a 7y ago
> As far as voltage is concerned, there's a very good reason why most of the world uses about 240 volts for "normal" outlets.
If North America would ever decide to start using 240V for appliances (through a transition period), what style of plug should be used? UK-style (Type G)? Europlug? Other?
* https://www.worldstandards.eu/electricity/plugs-and-sockets/ https://www.worldstandards.eu/electricity/plugs-and-sockets/
- zokier 7y agoSchuko is pretty solid choice, and conveniently already being used by large part of Europe. If polarization is must for some reason and schuko feels too bulky then I guess IEC 60906-1 is as good choice as any.
- throw0101a 7y agoWhy not have polarization if you can get it?
- zokier 7y agoHaving non-polarized sockets forces devices to be polarization agnostic, which could be safer... Not that I actually know anything about electric safety engineering. And of course there is the ergonomic aspect that allows you to insert the plug in any orientation, compare to usb-c
- gwbas1c 7y agoSchuko is unnecessarily large. I've always wanted an international standard with notches that indicate the voltage and frequency. A device that accepts all voltages and frequencies will accept any notch, a more selective device would block a notch for the frequency / voltage it can't handle. (And the plug would need to fully cover the pins once they have current. That's the big problem with the NEMA and Europlugs, the pins are still exposed when they're live.)
- zokier 7y ago> Europlugs, the pins are still exposed when they're live Europlugs are specifically designed so that no live parts are ever exposed. That is why they have only conductive tips on insulated shafts.
- swebs 7y agoI hate Schuko plugs. They're circular, but there's only two correct orientations you can plug them in, which results in a lot of finagling if you don't have a good visual lock on the outlet. I wish they were rectagular.
- rini17 7y agoI'd like to see IEC 60320 C13/C14 which is already common with computers, it is small, easy to use and properly covers the pins. But perhaps it isn't as mechanically robust when connected and disconnected often?
- gwbas1c 7y agoWe already have standard 240 volt plugs: https://www.stayonline.com/product-resources/nema-straight-blade-reference-chart.asp https://www.stayonline.com/product-resources/nema-straight-b... Assuming you read the article, the difference is that they have two hot prongs instead of a single hot pong. The 4-prong outlets, like a standard dryer outlet, allow a device to use both 120v and 240v. Sometimes appliances take advantage of this by using a 240v heating coil and a 120v motor. Adopting EU-style plugs is more problematic. There's the two hot prong problem, instead of one hot and one neutral. The other problem is frequency, as we use 60hz instead of 50hz.
- rini17 7y agoEU-plugs don't treat hot and neutral side differently at all, it's just a convention and in practice it doesn't matter when they are reversed, it does happen often. Only the earth must be always correctly connected. It would work fine with two hot prongs too.
- DanTheManPR 7y agoIn my experience, the Italian/Chilean Type L has by far the most convenient geometry of these plugs, with a very compact design as well as modern safety features. Main downside is that it is not polarized. https://www.worldstandards.eu/electricity/plugs-and-sockets/l/ https://www.worldstandards.eu/electricity/plugs-and-sockets/...
- LeoPanthera 7y agoMost houses in the US already receive 240 volts, though a biphase system, so that you can tap just one of the phases and get 120 volts. But you can easily connect to both phases and get 240 volts, and this is quite common for appliances such as ovens, clothes dryers, and now EV chargers. NEMA already provides a selection of connectors for high volt/amp connections: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NEMA_simplified_pins.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NEMA_simplified_pins.svg Although slowly the US does seem to be coalescing around the NEMA 14-50 socket.
- azalemeth 7y agoI'm a great proponent of the UK (Type G) plug. It's wonderfully over-engineered for safety. The plug is an asymmetric triangle shape, with a well-defined orientation that is "forever" polarised. The earth pin (at the top) makes contact first, as it is longer and physically larger. In the process of doing so, it opens two shutters on live ("hot") and neutral within the socket. The live and neutral pins themselves are insulated from the base of the plug to a distance slightly more than the extent by which the earth pin sticks out. Therefore, it's impossible to make contact with a live exposed pin, even if you drop a pin in the gap between the plug and the socket. Each plug is individually fused, with an amount that varies by each device. Cable strain relief is integral, and the wire lengths are designed such that if someone pulled the cable out incredibly hard, live breaks first, followed by neutral, followed by earth. The plastic is designed to char and not melt if burnt, and a standard 13 A (240 V) plug can take around 50 A at 240 VAC or instantaneous kV before coming a-cropper. The contact forces on the pins are far higher than a US plug. This means that a plug is very unlikely to arc in its socket, leading to less wear and tear and longer lasting plugs and sockets. I like the fact that each socket is individually switched, which further ameliorates the above. Because of the higher voltage, the maximum commonly used residential current, 13 A, delivers ~3 kW of power as opposed to the US maximum of ~1.6 kW, so you don't need a further set of incompatible plugs. Still hurts like hell if you tread on one barefoot though.
- stephen_g 7y agoI think the Australian plug is great, with the only caveat that it would be basically perfect if the pins were just slightly thicker (they're just a little bit too easy to bend). It's fairly compact, sockets always have ground, you can't plug it in upside down and swap live/neuteral with the two pin version (used for double insulated equipment), and it has a sensible scheme for 10, 15 and 20 amp sockets (the ground pin is bigger for 15 amps and all the pins bigger for 20 (I think) so you can plug a 10 amp plug into anything but can't put a 15 amp plug in a 10 amp socket or a 20 amp in a 15 amp socket).