3 ms·
I really really really want AV1 to be successful, since I would prefer if all my infrastructure were unencumbered by patents, but until we can get a reasonably
by tombert 7y ago
I really really really want AV1 to be successful, since I would prefer if all my infrastructure were unencumbered by patents, but until we can get a reasonably fast encoder working in FFMPEG, I'm basically blocked on using it. My current encoding infrastructure for blu-ray backups is a simple script I wrote that uses ffmpeg to convert rips into h264 and flac, and stream with Emby.
Keep in mind, that for me, it doesn't have to be fast...I'd put up with an encoder that performs around 5-10fps on an ODroid board. As it stands though, with libaom, I'm getting around 0.25fps, which is too slow.
I really wish I knew more about the guts of video encoding...I would really love to help get AV1 off the ground for the average consumer. Does anyone here know a way that I could help?
- clouddrover 7y ago> Does anyone here know a way that I could help? You could test Intel's SVT-AV1 encoder and report any issues to them. SVT-AV1 will scale to as many cores as you can give it. It's still quite fragile and buggy, but in fairness it's only at version 0.6: https://github.com/OpenVisualCloud/SVT-AV1 https://github.com/OpenVisualCloud/SVT-AV1
- tombert 7y agoThat's a great idea, actually. I'll play with that tonight and see if I can contribute.
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoThat particular niche probably won't be conquered until hardware encoders come to GPU. In the meantime you might be able to get hardware accelerated VP9 encoding on some devices if patents are important. It's a slightly unfortunate situation that VP9 got overshadowed by AV1. If Apple had got on board with it at the time we'd already have a royalty free codec utopia. But no point crying over spilt milk, hopefully they follow through on AV1 as they are rumored/expected to.
- tombert 7y agoI actually tried VP9; while the hardware encoders might be great, the software encoders were literally an order of magnitude slower than libx264 on an ARM SBC; libx264 gets around 8fps in software mode on there, while VP9 was getting around .5-.9fps. I typically prefer software encoders since they tend to give you more configuration options, and AFAIK the ODroid XU4 series doesn't have any hardware support for VP9 anyway, which limits my options. I definitely agree that it's a pitty that VP9 kind of got lost in the mix; it's a great codec, and typically offers a bit better compression than h.264.
- ksec 7y ago> were unencumbered by patents You do realize AV1 is only Royalty free and not patents free?
- tombert 7y agoI did not realize that, actually; still, royalty-free with good OSS encoders is better than nothing.
- ksec 7y agoThat was the whole thing that really irradiate me, they started the whole campaign, purposefully or not market / misled many as the other side are patents ridden, and they are patents free. I believe even their marketing team did not realise it until 2018. And just to be clear, both AVC and HEVC do have OSS Encoder. So it really boils down to royalty issues.