4 ms·
Seems to be 1/3 price of Fastmail on comparable plans too, anyone used both? Fastmail doesn't support on the fly 'reply from' addresses which is annoying. e.g
by OJFord 7y ago
Seems to be 1/3 price of Fastmail on comparable plans too, anyone used both?
Fastmail doesn't support on the fly 'reply from' addresses which is annoying.
e.g. if I send a pattern of (incoming) To addresses to a folder, I can reply from any address I've configured beforehand, and I can set a default for the folder, but I can't reply from the same address as I received the email at, without going into settings to set it up (annoying for one-off).
Sometimes causes problems with support ticketing systems too.
- podd 7y agoTutanota unfortunately has the same drawback in that you have to go to the settings and register a new email alias before you can reply from that adress.
- OJFord 7y agoDamn, thanks though. Presumably it's a client support thing, as in if you use a third-party client with Fastmail/Tutanova that does support it, they won't mangle the headers? I'll get around to testing it I suppose, just not something I thought of or realised I'd lose when I switched away from Gmail.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoFastmail and Tutanota arguably serve different desires: Tutanota goes for absolute end-to-end encryption, potentially at the cost of convenience and features. FastMail provides a much more Gmail-like experience without ads or privacy violations, with pretty good support (that can look at your email if you ask them to).
- anfogoat 7y ago> Seems to be 1/3 price of Fastmail on comparable plans too, anyone used both? I use nine domains on my Fastmail account, have around 60 aliases, currently use about 7GB of storage and pay 5 USD monthly. Assuming I'm reading Tutanota's pricing page correctly, this would cost me well over 8 EUR were I to switch. The encryption is enticing enough to make me contemplate switching but seeing the 5 alias limit snaps me right out of it. I've never run a large scale email service so I might not have a good understanding of the overhead, but pricing 100 aliases at 4.8 EUR (four times the base plan) seems ridiculous. My guess is they just copied ProtonMail, whose plans are equally crippled.
- lorenzhs 7y agoFastMail supports on the fly reply from if you have a catch-all alias on your domain. It defaults to replying from the same address. If you want to change the from address to something else, just select the "*@domain.tld" entry in the sender list. This turns "from:" into a text input. See https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/alias-catchall.html https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/alias-catchall.html
- justusthane 7y agoTIL! That's awesome, thanks!
- OJFord 7y agoOh. Thanks! How does that work for composing new mail, can you write something arbitrary? Or you also specify a few aliases that you'll choose from when they're not the delivered-to address for a reply?
- lorenzhs 7y agoYou can enter something arbitrary (both for new mail and for replies). You can also configure sender identities you need repeatedly so you don't need to type them out. It's pretty neat.
- newscracker 7y agoIf price is a concern, then Migadu or Mxroute would be the cheapest for those who need multiple mailboxes (not aliases). I’m not sure if either of these provide what you’re asking for. Migadu does have a forever free plan with a plain text ad for it in outgoing mails. That can be used to try it out. Mxroute does not have any trials or free tiers.
- OJFord 7y agoI'm a Fastmail customer, I was just intrigued to see Tutanova come in so much cheaper. (Though also not, depending on use, as pointed out by sibling comments to yours.)