3 ms·
I wish the article spent more time on the preferred types of trees other than the Sitka. The Sitka was chosen for its environmental (sucks up lots of carbon, gr
by prepend 7y ago
I wish the article spent more time on the preferred types of trees other than the Sitka. The Sitka was chosen for its environmental (sucks up lots of carbon, grows well in Ireland) and economical (quickly produces renewable lumber jobs and products).
But if there are preferred trees, I would like to know more about their differences from Sitka. Do they grow 10% more slowly? Or product 10% less lumber? Or require 10% more maintenance?
I recently visited Ireland and walked through some awesome woods. But the local houndsmaster explained that almost all of the trees are non-native. And that wasn’t a problem.
I don’t think non-native is a self-sustaining reason by itself. I’m sure the Leitrim group has more info on what are better trees for Ireland and I would like to see the climate trade off analysis they did to show how other trees should be used.
- Brakenshire 7y agoIt’s foolish to consider such marginal issues for woodland in countries like Ireland. Between modern agriculture and human settlement there is an extremely limited amount of space to maintain ecosystems, and the last thing you want to do is apply the same logic of high intensity agriculture to growing carbon over huge swathes of land. I would not take a 25% greater carbon impact and certainly not a 25% lower maintenance cost if the consequence is creating a green desert for wildlife. This is one reason why we need to act now on the climate, the Paris deal only achieves its relatively gradual 2050 targets by assuming enormous carbon sequestration from the 2040’s onwards, which unless there is a breakthrough will require us to cover an absurdly large amount of land in these kind of dead plantations. To halt the current mass extinction we’ll need to keep climate change within reasonable bounds, but also set aside enough land for ecosystems to be able to support themselves. The earlier we act, the less collateral damage we’ll be forced into to keep temperatures below reasonable levels. A few sensible policies on zero carbon heating or transportation now can mean the space to create national parks rather than massive dead plantations in 15 years.
- pvaldes 7y agoIs not a secret at all Oak, linden, beech or chesnut. Start burning much slower than any resinous, support a high biodiversity of insects and feed mammals and birds If you want something that grows faster: poplar, maple, ash, birches and most willows. Willows are bee lifesavers in early spring. If you really want a pine, use a native species at least. I'm not systematically against using a few Spruce, Cedrus or Sequioa here and there, but if you invest strongly in a monoculture of Spruce you have a high risk to lose all the money of your investors by Cytospora cancer or fire. As I said before, none of this is a secret. There are many solutions more simple and obvious.
- dctoedt 7y agoIreland of all places should have an ancestral memory of the dangers of monocultures, having lost millions of people to starvation and emigration [EDIT: in part] as a result of a blight that clobbered the monoculture potato crops [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)
- rusk 7y agoYou’re probably experiencing some downvotes because you’ve made a common mistake. The failure of the potatoes was the proximal cause but there was plenty of food in Ireland that was being expropriated by the English and exported. Its a common mistake, if you read down through the wikipedia article you linked youll find out more about what went on.
- dctoedt 7y agoOne of my grandmothers was first-generation Irish-American; IIRC, her grandparents survived the Famine, and her parents emigrated to America. I heard all about the Famine growing up. It's an interesting reason to be downvoted. I was writing a quick comment about one of the causes of the Famine that's relevant to this discussion, i.e., monocultures. It wasn't intended to be a treatise exploring all the various other causes of the catastrophe. But I know the rule about not complaining about downvotes.
- rusk 7y ago150 years later it’s still a very sensitive topic, particularly when the victims are seemingly blamed.
- slartibardfast0 7y ago"Policy Failure"