6 ms·
With the threat of a US company like Facebook coming in and taking over their economy, I can see why.
by judge2020 7y ago
With the threat of a US company like Facebook coming in and taking over their economy, I can see why.
- bilbo0s 7y agoYeah, I'd bet on that whole FB thing to come to a screeching halt pretty soon. The Africans have been smitten by the allure of the Chinese protectionist model. One of the biggest mistakes I saw when I was in energy was how we were not providing Africa with a sufficiently attractive alternative model. All the Africans were about was, basically, "Money talks and BS walks." And the Chinese system just looks so attractive because of all the money, and how many poor people they've lifted, and yada yada yada. Ever try to compete with a dream? And it's good for people to have dreams. Don't misunderstand me. I think we in the West need to offer Africa an equally attractive dream. Because right now all we've been slogging the past 60 or 70 years has been "democracy will make your life better". We shouldn't be too surprised that they are starting to run off the reservation.
- jackfoxy 7y agoHow about offering them the dream of the rule of law? Arbitrary enforcement of capricious legal codes is the biggest hurdle keeping the people, and hence the economies, of these countries down.
- bilbo0s 7y agoRule of law is another one though that no one really has. The best you can say is that there is a spectrum. And on that spectrum you have a place like, say, Norway, where only a very few people will get preferential treatment. And on the other end you have places like EG, where arbitrary treatment is essentially enshrined in law in the personage of the head élite. You could argue we don't even have rule of law in the US ourselves, since we definitely live in a place where laws will be enforced against some but not others. At least we have the democracy we've been trying to sell them on. So in the case of slinging democracy, regardless of what you think of the health of our own democracy, we're able to give a message consistent with deed.
- markdown 7y agoChina just sent its police force into Vanuatu to extract 6 people (mostly Vanuatu citizens) who they claim broke Chinese law. These people were deported without trial. This comes after they did the same last year in Fiji, when they kidnapped and flew out 77 people without trial. African nations had better be careful. Their sovereignty is at risk. https://asiapacificreport.nz/2019/07/08/secrecy-veil-over-deportation-of-six-chinese-nationals-raise-key-questions/ https://asiapacificreport.nz/2019/07/08/secrecy-veil-over-de... https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/336583/77-fraud-suspects-flown-from-fiji-to-china https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/336583/77-fraud-suspects-...
- tepidandroid 7y ago> China just sent its police force into Vanuatu to extract 6 people (mostly Vanuatu citizens) who they claim broke Chinese law. The title for one of your sources says that they were Chinese nationals: > Secrecy veil over deportation of six Chinese nationals raises key questions
- squiggleblaz 7y agoAs if that's the significant point. You don't get to just kidnap your own citizens no matter what they've done. (In this case, the local cops participated. That still doesn't make it right. Extradition and deportation should go through the courts.)
- newsgremlin 7y agoIsn't that basically the Patriot act they have in the US?
- tepidandroid 7y agoI've responded above.
- markdown 7y agoI'm not sure what your point is. Are you unfamiliar with the concept of dual citizenship? Their nationality outside of the State of Vanuatu is irrelevant. They are Vanuatu citizens, had not been charged with a crime in Vanuatu. Countries don't just deport their own citizens.
- JetSpiegel 7y agoTFA mentions the big problem with "enforcing" this agreement is that the infrastructure is so poor, it's physically hard to just trade the good directly. There's a hierarchy of needs, and only China is contributing (not without return) on the bottom parts.
- bluGill 7y agoFree trade helps to build the roads and infrastructure needed. The cost of building roads needs to be paid for, if it isn't worth transporting things from point A to point B the road is pointless. As the cost of trade goes down it self-reinforces by making people willing to contribute to better infrastructure. Of course when the road doesn't exist at all sometimes the investment to make the road is too high for people to realize that it is worth it. China contributing is potentially a good thing (or potentially bad for reasons others have debated). This trade zone doesn't need their contribution to be successful, but it helps.
- powerapple 7y agoThe rule of law comes when people try to protect their properties. It is hard to apply when you have nothing to lose. If you want to apply it from the top, you will need a dictator to do that. Take Chinese IP issue as an example, there are more and more laws to protect IP (of course, still not as good as western standard), the reason is that Chinese companies start to develop their own IP, and they need to protect them. The same for private properties, there was no law before 90s I believe, now people own things, their properties will be protected.
- sprafa 7y agoThe Chinese model fundamentally works. The globalisation model is probably horrible for these countries, what do they have to offer ?
- ben_w 7y agoEven cheaper labour than China. For now.
- dvtrn 7y agoI upvoted this comment and it went back to grey immediately, and I wonder how the people voting this comment down are want to explain themselves, what counter-arguments they care to offer and what their motivations are because the Facebook currency question and its relationship to economics in Africa are not mutually inflammatory topics of discussion--it absolutely needs to be talked about and highlighted. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48882301 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-48882301
- mr_toad 7y ago> counter-arguments There wasn’t an argument to counter, it was a throw-away piece of hyperbole. It didn’t vote either way, but I can see people down-voting simply because it looks like trolling. If you want to make a proper argument about Facebook taking over African economics, go ahead. But so far the main ‘argument’ seems to be that it must be evil, because Facebook.
- dvtrn 7y agoThe original comment I replied to, when I replied to it seems like it was edited by the poster and--as written, was asking what the Facebook currency could portend for emerging economies in Africa. I found it odd that the question would get pushed so far down into almost invisible greyness. As it's written now a lot of that focus and nuance is gone, which is a shame because it was a very good question IMO.
- petre 7y agoYou realize that many people in Africa still live in huts without electricity? Facebook currency being widely used in Africa is no more absurd than asking all Indian citizens to receive all their income via a bank account.
- rexarex 7y agoDon’t need electricity to get cell service mate. Most people have mobile phones even if they live in a hut.
- yarg 7y agoI'd be more worried about China - https://www.google.com/search?q=china+buying+africa https://www.google.com/search?q=china+buying+africa. I think that Facebook's less of a threat than it would like to be.
- powerapple 7y agoActually China is the reason I believe Africa has a real chance of success in the future. China knows how to develop, and it needs a market, and a strong African economy to continue fuel China's growth. You can be all hippie about how to make the world better, but in the end, it is just sweat and tears. And China knows it.
- yarg 7y agoChina will devour all that Africa has to offer, leaving nothing in its wake but authoritarianism and decay into perpetual poverty.
- powerapple 7y agoAfrica can offer to be a great economy and help the world growing. History will tell. When British went around and loot the world, no one would think they would represent human rights standard now, right?
- yarg 7y agoI don't believe that they do represent a human rights standard. They've spent decades eroding their education system, they're increasingly moving towards the privatisation of state assets and services and their media largely consists of a great propaganda machine.
- newsgremlin 7y agoNo non-African country can claim they will bring Africa into the modern world without vested interests. The best result for Africa is if they can achieve some general stability across the continent without puppet governments backed by foreign governments that will sell themselves short. Saying choose your master doesn't resonate well with the freedoms we cherish.
- im3w1l 7y agoThings like this take time to organize. Surely it must have predated the libra thing?
- henvic 7y agoFacebook as a threat to Africa? What the hell? Maybe it is a threat to the African states. Not to the people, though. Africa is poor thanks to statism. Not due to some "evil american corporates".
- darkpuma 7y ago> "Africa is poor thanks to statism. Not due to some "evil american corporates" That can be rectified. It could very easily be poor thanks to both.
- shakyshakyshaky 7y agovery reductive to say that africa is poor due to statism and not centuries of imperialism, both actual and economic
- darkpuma 7y agoThe point, that I pray you aren't missing by being deliberately obtuse, is that for as bad as things may be today it's possible for things to become worse. And giving American corporations free reign to run social experiments in Africa, like creating their own currency, is a quick path to discovering ways to make it worse.