5 ms·
Recently someone put forward the theory that now that globalism is dead, there would instead be multiple competing factions with which countries would align. Th
by jedberg 7y ago
Recently someone put forward the theory that now that globalism is dead, there would instead be multiple competing factions with which countries would align. They proposed that the factions would be: The USA, the EU, and China.
Looks like we may now need to add the AU to the list.
- barberousse 7y agoChina has a lot of power in a few African countries
- joyjoyjoy 7y ago"Looks like we may now need to add the AU to the list. " Honestly, I doubt it. The more interesting question is: Who is Russia going to align with? No country can rule the world that does not rule Russia, the heartland. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geographical_Pivot_of_History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geographical_Pivot_of_Hist... PS: Thanks for downvoting. Please show that you are not familiar with major concepts that shaped many of the last conflicts we have seen. Take this as a start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Grand_Chessboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Grand_Chessboard
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe idea that the geopolitics of the world in 1904 are the same as that of 2019 is silly. It's quite clear that the US is no longer an "outlying island" on the world stage.
- joyjoyjoy 7y agoRight. So why the obsession with Russia? In this book? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Grand_Chessboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Grand_Chessboard Do you know who Zbigniew Brzezinski is? You comment proves a total lack of any knowledge in geo politics.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> Right. So why the obsession with Russia? In this book? Because the author's a Polish-American, writing not long after the collapse of the Soviet Union, and whose job responsibilities dealt a lot with said Soviet Union? The book doesn't say dominating Europe means you dominate the world. The book says the US ignores Europe at its peril, as a challenger could easily arise there. In the years since 1997, the EU has largely proven to be an ally, not a challenger. The world's not the same place it was in 1997, just like it's not the same as 1904.
- joyjoyjoy 7y agoTHe book is mainly about Russia, not the EU. The guy is a major figure in US policy. "and whose job responsibilities dealt a lot with said Soviet Union?" That says is kindly. This guy was a major part of the collapse of the soviet union. http://transmissionsmedia.com/zbigniew-brzezinski-how-jimmy-carter-and-i-started-the-mujahideen/ http://transmissionsmedia.com/zbigniew-brzezinski-how-jimmy-...
- Chyzwar 7y agoRussia is irreverent. No strong economy, little innovation and corrupted political system mentally in soviet era. Whole heartland theory is silly, population centres are moving to coastal, technology and innovation is more important than total land area and most importantly there is nothing interesting in Siberia.
- joyjoyjoy 7y agoYes. Just the biggest country in the world, connecting two major blocks - China and EU and possible India. Feel free to ignore. I am not Russian by the way.
- Chyzwar 7y agoAs I was saying, size is not most important. If anything Russia enormous size is a liability. Infrastructure costs are enormous. For example GDP of Italy is larger than Russia.
- Havoc 7y agoI don't think US/EU has anywhere near the influence in Africa as China. They seem to be playing by entirely different rules - specifically their brand of money up front with cost later is hugely alluring to poor African states
- whatshisface 7y ago>money up front with cost later If you're a thieving dictator, that's money up front with costs never.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI'm pretty sure by that whole 2063 thing, China will pretty much imply the AU. I'm fair certain China figures prominently in the AU's strategy for getting to 2063. In truth, so does the EU. It's just that China is thought to be the less risky long term partner.
- pm90 7y agoThis will all change when loan repayments are due and China insists on no-forgiveness and asks for more control of the actual infrastructure, and ultimately ownership. That kind of thing is frowned upon by Western governments because it is eerily similar to the colonialism playbook but China is unfettered by that past and can thus move ahead. Also, China is a totalitarian state so even if the State committed atrocities abroad there would be little to no domestic repercussions anyways.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>This will all change when loan repayments are due and China insists on no-forgiveness and asks for more control of the actual infrastructure... Only they won't. When I was at Halliburton you could see the insidious brilliance of the Chinese strategy in Africa. Sure, there is support for rail everywhere. Support for roads everywhere. Factories everywhere. Resource extraction. Etc. But ask yourself this, where does it all go? Follow the map of their rails and roads and you'll see that a lot of them just go to ports. I mean, you can't even complain about it, because, of course, where else would it go? But I have a final question for you, will Africans own the freighters? My boss at Halliburton was a brilliant strategic thinker. Was basically 100% sure that by 2100 there'd be so much freight traffic that you'd be able to walk from East African ports, to Shanghai, via the Indian Ocean, without getting your feet wet. So the Chinese are effectively giving the Africans loans and whatnot in name only. Really it's a trap. Only the trap is not monetary, it's a physical logistics trap. They don't care if you pay for the roads or not, they only care that the roads go to the port. That's the evil of it, if the roads go to the port, you've probably already paid for them.
- NortySpock 7y ago
- pm90 7y ago> now that globalism is dead Its very much alive. Except in case of actual WW3 (in which case all bets are off), globalism and the integration of the global economy is proceeding at an unprecedented pace. There is a reason why tariffs are only temporary and there is no legislation to enshrine them into law. The biggest economic winners in the past 70 years or so have been economies which have integrated their supply chains with the global one in some way or the other. Its the golden goose that keeps giving (although what the countries end up doing with that wealth, whether they distribute it well, is another question). The goal of the AU is to build better efficiencies within the African continent to the benefit of African economies. This may e.g. make African manufactured goods more competitive than the ones imported from abroad. It allows for easier building of supply chains within the continent itself. As the article points out though, the main roadblocks are > Poor roads and railway lines, violence-hit areas, strict border controls and rampant corruption are some of the obstacles to an effective continental free-trade zone. These are all very serious (but not insurmountable) problems. The best outcome I can imagine is that as the AU supply chains are built and bring economic efficiencies, they can tap into the global supply chain to really supercharge them, make other AU countries realize free trade makes economic sense and encourage it. But I am being wayy too optimistic, seeing the history of the continent... Consider for e.g. the ancient silk roads. The owners of the territory over which the trade route ran realized its economic importance and invested a lot in making it a conflict-free and protected zone.
- jorblumesea 7y ago> These are all very serious (but not insurmountable) problems. Africa faces far bigger challenges than simply infrastructure and corruption. 1) There's massive cultural, ethnic, and economic diversity. The continent spans countries which are middle income to the lowest in the world. Unity and cohesiveness are difficult regionally, less across the entire continent. Looking at Europe's issues as a proxy, it's hard to see anyone agreeing on much. 2) Manufacturing, traditionally the ladder that countries climb to prosperity is being automated at an unprecedented rate. It's uncertain how Africa will pull itself up without this.
- wrong_variable 7y ago
- ptah 7y agothere will always be vestiges just as we still have nation-states held over from nationalism