3 ms·
It sounds weird to me to claim the Wayland ecosystem is less modular than the X ecosystem. With X, you're depending on one huge monolithic display server implem
by mort96 7y ago
It sounds weird to me to claim the Wayland ecosystem is less modular than the X ecosystem. With X, you're depending on one huge monolithic display server implementation; with Wayland, you can switch display server at will and they all conform to a common protocol.
I get the concern that most of the functionality which used to be in separate programs is now bundled with the Wayland compositor, and I used to share it, but after getting more involved with Wayland stuff, I don't think it's really that big of a deal. The wlroots people have been really good at introducing new common protocols for stuff people actually need. The Wayland ecosystem, at least outside of Gnome, is actually really nice and improving.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoWayland is more modular in other ways, too. We went from IPC-based modularity with separate processes towards modularity via relegating different tasks to different libraries. Like being able to use libinput and libdrm and EGL and libwayland all separately makes for a much more modular stack than putting it all in X.
- bitwize 7y agoWith X, you can switch your display server as well (and there were proprietary X server offerings available as late as the late 90s/early 2000s). It's just that Xorg, being internally more modular than XFree86, sapped the value add of redoing the entire X server and effectively "won". In fact, with X you can switch out your display server and keep your window manager. Can't do that with Wayland -- by design. Now who's huge and monolithic?
- PlutoIsAPlanet 7y agoStill Xorg.
- majewsky 7y ago> In fact, with X you can switch out your display server and keep your window manager. No, that's not a fact, that's a theory. In practice, there is only one display server that supports modern devices, Xorg. No modularity is lost by replacing a single display server implementation by a single libwayland implementation.