9 ms·
Public Highly Critical of State of Political Discourse in the U.S.
- cmurf 7y agoI see self-censorship in public political discourse, and that gives too much room for charlatan entertainers to suck up all the oxygen in the room. The negative discourse is not what the general public is engaging in. Fully 40 years ago I remember more public debate about politics than today. I'd characterize that as having been semi-productive. The newsertainment pundits today just try to rile people up. It's anger for-profit. Getting pissed off is a product you buy by watching or following a professional agitator. And that is not public discourse, in my view.
- daenz 7y ago>Majorities in both parties say it is very important that elected officials treat their opponents with respect. But while most Democrats (78%) say it is very important for Republican elected officials to treat Democratic officials with respect, only about half (47%) say it is very important for officials from their party to treat Republican politicians with respect. There is similar divide in the opinions of Republicans; 75% say Democrats should be respectful of GOP officials, while only 49% say the same about Republicans’ treatment of Democratic officials. If there's one thing that unites us all, it is intense and hypocritical tribalism.
- umvi 7y ago> If there's one thing that unites us all, it is intense and hypocritical tribalism. "You need to be tolerant of my beliefs, but I don't need to be tolerant of yours"
- chillwaves 7y agoDoes the content of the beliefs matter? Is it easier to be tolerant of multiculturalism than Nazism?
- threezero 7y agoAh yes, the old “anyone who opposes immigration is a Nazi” argument.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- antidesitter 7y agoTo give you an idea of what your comment sounds like: Does the content of the beliefs matter? Is it easier to be tolerant of free speech than Communism?
- happytoexplain 7y agoI think this is a somewhat false equivalency. The number and extremity of alignment with catastrophic far-right ideology, while relatively small, is significantly larger than the same metrics for similarly catastrophic far-left ideologies in the US (in my opinion). While there are a lot of people who too-broadly level accusations of Naziism against conservatives, and vice versa for things like Communism, there is in fact a real issue at hand around the topic of far-left vs far-right ideologies, and I don't think it requires blind tribalism to have the opinion that one is much more rampant or destructive than the other. In my experience, most criticisms that are based around simply inverting the political sidedness of the claim at hand tend to unjustly ignore this.
- antidesitter 7y ago> The number and extremity of alignment with catastrophic far-right ideology, while relatively small, is significantly larger than the same metrics for similarly catastrophic far-left ideologies in the US What makes you think that? > one is much more rampant or destructive than the other You’re right about that. Communists killed far more people than Nazis ever did, destructive as the latter were.
- blitmap 7y agoSome beliefs cannot be accommodated. One party wants to consider executing women who terminate pregnancies for their own safety. The other party can't get anything considered.
- antidesitter 7y ago> One party wants to consider executing women who terminate pregnancies for their own safety. Source?
- antidesitter 7y agoSo no sources, just a downvote. As expected.
- dang 7y agoWould you please stop posting dismissive, hostile, and/or unsubstantive comments to HN? You've been doing it a lot, and it goes against the site guidelines. So does complaining about downvotes. If you would please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and practice the spirit of this site more earnestly, we'd appreciate it. I know it isn't easy, but it isn't easy for any of us—and we've had to ask you this multiple times before.
- antidesitter 7y agoDon’t be ridiculous, dang. Requesting sources for an incredible and unsubstantiated claim is in no way “dismissive, hostile, and/or unsubstantive”. > You've been doing it a lot I don’t think so. Did you have some particular examples in mind?
- dang 7y agoI'm talking about your comments as a whole, which contain many examples of dismissiveness, hostility, and unsubstantiveness. Your first comment upthread was obviously unsubstantive, and the later one was unsubstantive, hostile, and broke the site guideline against going on about downvotes. >> we've had to ask you this multiple times before > Really? Name them. Here are some cases: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20067517 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20067517 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18580940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18580940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18581017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18581017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17832784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17832784
- bcgraham 7y agoI can tolerate anything except the outgroup.
- mffnbs 7y agoNot all opinions are equal and there's no reason to treat them as such.
- kolbe 7y agoTrue, but for some reason in the US we’ve decided that all/most people are equal sources of viable opinions when it comes to electing representatives. Whether or not you treat their opinions with respect matters little compared to their ability to vote their opinions into office.
- rjf72 7y agoYour interpretation of his comment quite succinctly sums up the problems with society today. Being tolerant of something is not the same as treating it identically to other views. Imagine my neighbor is completely and absolutely convinced that 2+2=5. I'd be somewhat curious why somebody would believe such a peculiar thing. If we had the time I'd certainly be happy to indulge him and of course I'd also try to correct him. If, at the end of the day, we couldn't agree? That's fine. Of course I'm probably not going to be convinced that 2+2=5 and won't make a secret of it, but agreeing to disagree is okay. In practice this distinction of tolerance vs "all opinions are equal" is even more critical because many of the topics people love to get into heated arguments about have compelling, entirely factual, arguments supporting mutually exclusive conclusions. Life's fun that way. On these sort of topics - guns, migration, economic systems, etc - there are of course some completely unsupportable views, but there are no right answers. In fact they probably literally do not exist since even with omniscience, the answer would still be contingent on the state of a society and people at any given point in time and place. We all believe the things we believe because we, tautologically, think they're what we ought believe - what is most right, or most supported, or whatever our personal value system tells us is correct. The problem we face today is when we then start assuming that because our value system tells us this belief must be the most valid, that we start to treat other completely supportable views as invalid.
- kolbe 7y agoI think deep down, most people agree with you. But it's not very practical to have a level-headed approach to political discourse, since most political topics of the day are not rooted in morality, but instead are economic agendas shrouded in morality. For example, no one really knows the systems effect of forgiving student loan debt, but politicians advocating for it are quite confident that that policy helps them win. So, being uncertain or open to discussion along the lines of whether or not that policy is good for the US isn't really the point. It's already known to be good for other, more palpable reasons, and any effort to shift the discussion into uncertainty about the effects of the US is only bad for the politician who already knows about the policy's effect on them personally.
- save_ferris 7y agoThis feels like the prisoners dilemma scenario, where cooperation with the other side is riskier than ratting them out. Neither side is particularly incentivized to cooperate, so what’s to give?
- smt88 7y agoBeing respectful of elected officials is totally different from being respectful of their supporters. For example, I can directly blame a senator for her votes. If her vote was for something I think is indefensible (like the Iraq War), showing disrespect is acceptable and deserved, as long as it's non-violent. However, not all of her voters might have expected or condoned that vote. Even if they did, their responsibility for the vote is a small fraction of the senator's. Joe Biden gave us a great example of this recently when he praised himself for getting along with segregationist colleagues. Treating them with respect was unwarranted because they didn't treat tens of millions of black Americans with respect.
- happytoexplain 7y agoThis can't be overstated. I think the tendency to treat politics like sports and develop a strong emotional connection with a political figure that you will never have any personal knowledge of is a huge part of what leads us to the inability to stop feeling attacked by each other (and, in reaction, attacking each other). E.g. if I am making some broad criticism, I make it clear I'm talking about politicians, not constituents. I don't talk shit about "Republicans" in the abstract. The difference may seem small, but the point is that just because I think Trump is a stupid asshole doesn't mean I think people who voted for Trump are.
- Proven 7y ago> Broad agreement on the dangers of “heated or aggressive” rhetoric by political leaders. Why be concerned about free speech that doesn't incite violence? I haven't noticed as much concern about the aggressive behavior of Antifa.
- iron0013 7y agoBest to click through to the content, which is very good. “Reactions to Trump’s rhetoric: Concern, confusion, embarrassment”
- tracer4201 7y ago>Large majorities say the tone and nature of political debate in the United States has become more negative in recent years – as well as less respectful, less fact-based and less substantive. My in laws are Republican voters. I can’t leave my daughter at their home anymore. A few months ago, they had some Christian channel on where this guy was going on and on about how Donald Trump was sent by God himself to lead America and that working against Donald Trump is to work against God himself. Fact based or substance based debate - LOL. I mean, yeah I don’t want my child being brainwashed into believing that Mr. Cheat on my pregnant wife with a pornstar is a messiah figure sent by God. Thankfully my husband was equally disturbed. I’m leaving out some details, but my in-laws had no issues whatsoever with what they were having my child watch. They believe this garbage. We no longer leave my daughter with my in-laws, no matter how much they plead. If you have to convince people you were sent by God and going against you is undermining God - I mean that’s some Taliban level crap there.
- xlog 7y agoUS needs a third major political party ASAP.
- smt88 7y agoIt has several parties outside the major two. What the US needs is instant runoff (via ranked choice) voting. Short of that, people with your mindset need to volunteer, fundraise, and vote. Otherwise those parties will never match the scope of the current duopoly.
- rjf72 7y agoInstant runoff only really resolves the spoiler effect. I think it's extremely unlikely we'd see a third party come even close, including with instant runoff, to taking power. I'd look at the problem numerically. Imagine a state has 100 representatives sent to congress. And we know this state is let's say 30% republican, 30% democratic, 20% libertarian, 20% green. What would you say their representation should look like? Everybody's going to say the exact same thing: 30 republicans, 30 democrats, 20 libertarians, 20 greens. The only problem is that you only get that distribution with proportional representation, which as a nice side effect also would do away with gerrymandering since you don't need to carve a state up into representative districts anymore. The downside here is that proportional voting doesn't stand a bat's chance in hell of ever getting enacted because it really would lead to a major upheaval in DC. And the very people that would be 'losing their jobs' are the ones that'd need to work to pass it, which would be a tremendous undertaking. You'd need a 2/3rds majority in both the house and senate to start the process, and then you'd need 38 of the 50 states to ratify the change. And at the end of this process the two major political parties, who are in control of every single major political body in the United States, would have just ceded a tremendous amount of power.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThen approximately 2/3 of of the population will be wrong instead of just 1/2.
- pixl97 7y ago
- atdt 7y agoAnd New Yorkers prefer the sound of ocean waves to the sounds of car traffic and jet engines. So what? What the public prefers is irrelevant. The content of public discourse is dictated by the acoustics of the media environment. We are trapped inside a terrible, gigantic conch, which resonates with the frequency of scandals and sound-bytes and dampens the sounds of thoughtful debate.