3 ms·
Curious why the TDP is the same for the 8, 12, and 16 core. I assume it's binned parts, but the switched off cores still consume power? Or some other reason?
by tyingq 7y ago
Curious why the TDP is the same for the 8, 12, and 16 core. I assume it's binned parts, but the switched off cores still consume power? Or some other reason?
- omni 7y agoTDP is based on the base frequency, which decreases on those models as the core count increases. May not explain it fully but probably contributes to constant TDP.
- chupasaurus 7y agoAMD measures TDP at boost, IIRC.
- qzw 7y agoFrequency differences can explain a (small) part of it, but I think a larger part comes down to market positioning and signaling vs competing Intel chips. The TDP is sort of an indicator of the overall "beefiness" of the chip. Edit: I understand some would disagree with what I said, but I can't see what else would explain why the 3800X with one CPU chiplet at 3.9GHz base freq would be the same 105W as the 3900X with two chiplets at 3.8GHz. And by "beefiness" I mean the overall performance potential, including possible overclocking headroom.
- penagwin 7y agoI wonder if since it's the same "chip" they have the same TDP listed, even though some of the cores are turned off.
- AdrianB1 7y agoThe reported TDP is the designed TDP for the motherboard power delivery, not the measured consumption of each processor. To keep the number of TDP values low and to allow motherboard makers design a small number of variants, TDP values are rounded up to 65W, 95W and 105W. That means everything that goes above 65W in real life will be classified as 95W, even if the real consumption is 70 or 75W.
- rasz 7y agoNot really. Intel made TDP numbers meaningless long time ago, AMD finally joined Intel with Zen2. While Zen1 180W TDP Threadrippers actually did consume 180W from the power supply, Zen2 take x1.5 the rated power similar to intel counterparts like "95W" 9900K consuming 150-200W.
- makomk 7y agoActual power cap for Zen2 seems to be 1.35x TDP, but the speculation about them choosing a small number of TDP categories and sticking all their processors into them sounds right aside from that.
- nottorp 7y agoActually I think the anandtech page says that the 65W part consumes 90W at full load? Or so I read their graphs on the power consumption part...
- frio 7y agoI believe that's correct. There's an 8 core with 65w TDP which has a confirmed single chiplet; my guess is the 8 core with 105w TDP is two chiplets with several cores disabled.
- gameswithgo 7y agoI am wondering about that. the 105W TDP 8 core TDP though doesn't have an L3 size that would reflect being two chiplets