4 ms·
I see this most clearly in people who will not trade in a board game like Monopoly unless the deal is extremely slanted in their favor. They simply can't unders
by pessimizer 7y ago
I see this most clearly in people who will not trade in a board game like Monopoly unless the deal is extremely slanted in their favor. They simply can't understand that people who trade will always beat people who don't, and the easiest way to trade is to trade fairly.
If four people are playing a game of Monopoly, and two trade with each other but the other two refuse, now two people are playing Monopoly and the other two are begging for it to end.
(Please don't reply by criticizing Monopoly, I know that many people don't like it, I suspect this is a major reason why.)
- 11thEarlOfMar 7y agoIt's one of my all-time favorites. My favorite 'house rule' was invented by my nephew: He negotiated a % of rent I collected utilizing properties he traded to me.
- pessimizer 7y agoFunny corollaries because Monopoly is a zero-sum game (at the end there will be a ordering of players by relative wealth, and their absolute wealth ceases to matter): players should be trying to 1) trade as much as possible, even if some trades are slightly slanted against them, 2) spread their trades evenly amongst the other players, and 3) to actively discourage trades between other players. You might as well give both players who trade a trade point, and award the victory to the player who has the most at the end.
- Iv 7y agoYes, Monopoly more or less is (there are ways to gain and lose money without taking the other players' money, but they almost do not depend on players' choices). I think the parent's point is that trade in monopoly, however, is not. By making an exchange that allows both traders to complete a color set, they end up both much richer than before the trade.
- pessimizer 7y agoI understand the parent's point because I am the parent.
- AznHisoka 7y ago"I'll trade you this missing piece, but get 10% of all the rent you collect when someone lands on them AND I don't need to pay you rent if I land in them... AND if you land on free parking the next 2 times, that cash goes to me"
- conanbatt 7y agoDerivatives trading in monopoly is pretty evil.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoThere's such an advantage to having a full color set, it's hard to imagine folks that don't want to trade to get one.
- pessimizer 7y agoI've come to discover that a lot of people just wait to randomly get one, one person eventually does, and the others just wait to land on that person's property and lose. After 6 hours of play and maybe one elimination they call the game off and vow never to play again.
- conanbatt 7y agoThis is my life-long frustration on monopoly and Catan. There isn't a better case for free trade than playing those games in my opinion, but people really are reluctant to understand that trades make their possition better at the expense of everyone else. Allow me to boast about my single most fantastic monopoly play where nobody wanted to trade at all, so I initiated a series of trades where I gave each opponent a monopoly without getting myself one, except for the very last trade of all with a player that had all the cash in the game and no properties and I gave him a small monopoly and got a huge one + all the cash to build on it. They key is that each trade I made increased the opponents chances to win enormously, but the last one basically gave me the game in exchange for a small chance to someone that had none at all.
- pessimizer 7y agoSounds masterful. I've always explained Monopoly as a trading game unlike any other out there in that you spend the entire first 3/4 of the game building up to one big trade. It may be a complex multi-part trade, involving other trades in preparation, but it's all you were working towards. After that trade, you're just a passenger seeing how your valuations played out. Sometimes, like what you did here, you can just structure everything so well that every trade is a better deal for the other player than it is for you, but the sum total of the trades makes you unstoppable. As I mentioned before, this is almost inevitable when you spread your trades between all of the players, and they don't trade with each other. So if you specifically target their needs (like you did), they might not even be able to come up with productive trades with each other...
- conanbatt 7y agoAbsolutely correct!
- mrrrgn 7y agoMonopoly is a zero sum game. So perceiving it as such shouldn't be the bias that leads to poor strategy. (edit: it seems that it may be possible to play monopoly in a way that generates infinite money and with no win condition)
- conanbatt 7y agoIt technically isn't, because if everyone forgives each other's expenses they can be infinitely rich as the bank never run out of money.
- mrrrgn 7y agoWell I'll be. I'd thought that the rules were more strict. It appears that even if the bank does run out of bills more can be created by writing on pieces of paper.
- username90 7y agoMoney in monopoly doesn't matter except as a means to increase your probability of winning. The probability of winning is zero sum.
- conanbatt 7y agoThats not the use of zero-sum used in economics or in (some applications of) game theory: any game with a discrete victor is a zero-sum probability of winning. What is not zero-sum is the amount of money/points floating in monopoly. If you played a monopoly tournament where players can resign, and at the end of the game you sum up all the money as points for a final ranking you would see monopoly is truly non-zero-sum.
- pessimizer 7y agoTrading in Monopoly is not zero-sum, the outcome is.