4 ms·
Criminals are created by (a) laws, (b) their transgression, and (c) their enforcement. You seem to think that the whole issue is in (b) - that there's something
by barrkel 16y ago
Criminals are created by (a) laws, (b) their transgression, and (c) their enforcement. You seem to think that the whole issue is in (b) - that there's something about the US that causes more people to act unlawfully, to transgress. Have you considered other possibilities, such as unjust laws, or unequal application of laws?
Besides that, there's social issues, whereby subgroups are disadvantaged and have fewer opportunities for lawful profit in life. It could be that these social issues are the same in the US as elsewhere, but the US invests in prisons rather than welfare, for self-defeating political reasons.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt's certainly the case that (b) is a major role. Forget about convictions - lets just look at crimes. The US murder rate is 5/100,000 people, Britain, Denmark and similar countries have about 1/100,000 people. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentiona... The reason why we are different from much of Europe isn't a secret, it's just taboo to discuss. Most of our crime is confined to a small subset of our population and this subset is mostly absent from Europe. http://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/offenses/expanded_information/data/shrtable_03.html http://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/offenses/expanded_informati... (I'm focusing on murder because while things like drugs might be counted differently between the US and Britain, dead bodies with knife holes probably aren't.)
- foldr 16y ago> The US murder rate is 5/100,000 people, Britain, Denmark and similar countries have about 1/100,000 people. Depends which crimes you look at. Britain, for example, has a higher overall rate of violent crime than the US.
- mattmcknight 16y agoUK murder rate is 1.4/100000 http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murde...
- foldr 16y agoViolent crime is a broader category than murder. Although the UK has a lower murder rate than the US, it has a higher overall rate of violent crime.
- d0mine 16y agoWhat subset are you talking? The link you provided to fbi.gov doesn't indicate it.
- evilduck 16y agoIt's murder rate by race. Black people account for 15%-20% of the US population, while white people account for about 60%, yet their tallies are nearly the same. It's not really taboo if rationally discussed in a small group (like a college classroom) since there's a long and complicated history surrounding the contributing factors which have been fairly unique to the Americas, but in an open forum on the internet it's practically impossible without moderators.
- sedachv 16y ago"Most of our crime is confined to a small subset of our population and this subset is mostly absent from Europe." According to those figures, the most effective way to lower the homicide rate is to get rid of men.
- pygy_ 16y ago> [Murder conviction is proportionately much higher in Black people] What happens when you control for income? In Europe, race appears to play a major role in criminality, unless you take wealth into account. Models controlling for social factors don't reveal any significant race effect. Poverty is the real culprit. I wouldn't be surprised if this transfered to the US.
- uniclaude 16y agoIf the subset you're talking about is blacks and maybe other racial minorities, I have to disagree with you. This subset is far from being "mostly absent" from Spain, UK, Portugal, Italy, France, Netherlands, and Germany for example.
- philwelch 16y agoWell, let's consider (a) and (c). We're comparing statistics to other Western countries, and other Western countries have largely the same criminal laws the US does. Some of them legalize prostitution more than the US does, but everything else (violent crimes, property crimes, drug crimes) that's illegal in the US is illegal in the countries we're comparing the US with. So that rules out (a) for the purpose of this discussion. (c) doesn't create criminals so much as it creates prisoners. (c) is bounded by (b) in one respect, but in another respect, you can unjustly change aspects of (c) through longer sentences. There is evidence of this, if you look at some of the differences in sentencing between crack and powder cocaine. The social issues you cite are probably a big part of (b), though. It's easier for these disadvantaged subgroups to arise when you have cultural heterogeneity (since the society has to have some way of distinguishing a subgroup in order to disadvantage it) but there's definitely room to say the US has answered those challenges poorly throughout history.
- ugh 16y agoWhile criminal laws are similar, punishment might be more severe in the USA. The same crime which leads to several years in prison in the US might result in a fine in the Netherlands. I have no statistics to back this up so I can’t tell you whether that‘s actually the case but I think it’s important to note that the mere existence of the same crimes in the criminal law of different countries is not sufficient to decide the question.
- jules 16y ago> Some of them legalize prostitution more than the US does, but everything else (violent crimes, property crimes, drug crimes) that's illegal in the US is illegal in the countries we're comparing the US with. So that rules out (a) for the purpose of this discussion. I'm not so sure about that. You'll not go to jail for possession of small quantities of drugs in Denmark, but you might in the US?
- sofuture 16y agoAbsolutely! I'm not going to throw around a figure I'm not sure of, but there are a stunning amount of people in American prisons for non-violent possession charges. What a horrendous farce!