3 ms·
Sure, there are tradeoffs and frictions in the practicalities. But the potential solution space isn't dictated by a few simple axes of decentralization vs. conc
by gojomo 16y ago
Sure, there are tradeoffs and frictions in the practicalities. But the potential solution space isn't dictated by a few simple axes of decentralization vs. concentration, or totalitarianism vs. anarchy. It's massively dimensional, and we already know governance variation can make a massive difference in quality of life: consider West vs. East Germany, or Hong Kong vs. pre-liberalization China, or South vs. North Korea.
What if there are other configurations as much better than the current best, as the current best is better than the current worst? Or put more concretely, compared to North Korea, South Korea is already a 'utopia'. Maybe there's another solution as much better again, which makes South Korea look like a retro prison state, and would to its vurrent residents be a comparative utopia. (Of course, this utopia's residents, once inured to it, would still find plenty to gripe about. C'est la treadmill hédonique.)
Most existing states have strong incentives to send the message: "Current tradeoffs are as good as it gets; this is already the best of all possible worlds — so get back to your station." They're lying.