3 ms·
Great observation, I cannot recall where I read it at the moment, but I remember reading someone arguing precisely a difference in the individuals relationship
by voidhorse 7y ago
Great observation, I cannot recall where I read it at the moment, but I remember reading someone arguing precisely a difference in the individuals relationship to the state is why Athenian democracy seemed to succeed in areas that modern democracy seems to fail. From what I understand, to be an Athenian participating in statecraft meant you’d be willing to go so far as to more or less die for the polis and would always put the needs of the polis before your own. There are a couple of anecdotes about prominent Athenians sacrificing their own gain for the sake of the betterment of Athens. Contrarily, our times are so staunchly individualist I expect that the majority of politicians are not willing to sacrifice much and see their role as little more than a professional occupation—not as an existential gamble for the sake of their constituents.
- kwevieenoloiden 7y agoDemocracy in Athens failed because the polis votes to much for themselves. The politicians kept in power by pleasing their constituencies with free stuff. And neglected to maintain an army and navy.