3 ms·
Democracy fails, like any other system of government, with the centralization of power. If you centralize power then people inherently have to fight over it bec
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
Democracy fails, like any other system of government, with the centralization of power. If you centralize power then people inherently have to fight over it because it's the only way to have any. If people in California want free public colleges and people in Wyoming want lower taxes, it's possible for them to both have what they want, but not if they can't make different choices from each other. If the same choice has to be made for everyone then you require everyone to fight over which one to make. If you allow different communities to make different choices, and then allow citizens to move freely to the community they want to live in, that's really about the best we can do.
The inherent difficulty is that you need something strong enough to prevent someone else from accumulating centralized power, without that entity itself becoming corrupted and used to impose the will of whoever controls it uniformly on everyone else.
We tried that in the US and failed. The federal government was supposed to be small. "Promote the general welfare" was meant as a restriction on the use of government revenue for private use, not an enumerated power to spend money on anything alleged to be of public benefit. "Interstate commerce" was never intended to be equivalent to all commerce.
But the words on paper failed to resist the combination of a depression and a strongman promising to fix it if only it weren't for all these silly restrictions on centralized power. And they never give the power back even after the crisis is over.
It remains to be seen whether a lock can be forged strong enough to keep central power contained, but the first step today has to be to get it back into its cage to begin with.