4 ms·
And this is precisely the reason why this is utopia. You see, power and money are related to each other pretty much like matter and energy: they are two forms
by BerislavLopac 16y ago
And this is precisely the reason why this is utopia.
You see, power and money are related to each other pretty much like matter and energy: they are two forms of the same thing, interchangeable from one into the other, and behaving in mostly the same ways.
As long as there is some power to accumulate you will find some people who are better ad doing it than the others, and you're getting a power imbalance which is easily abused. So there is no guarantee that any nicely engineered utopia won't become warped after a while -- if anything, human history pretty much guarantees that it will.
Human society can't be engineered, it's a living mechanism, and in the past millennia we've been through pretty much all we could (although that heavily depends on technological advances, such as communications and the like). So far, we can safely say that there are two extreme forms of society when it comes to laws: a totalitarian state, where a small group of people keep the rest in control, and a total anarchy, where there are no set laws and rules. At each point in time, any society is at some point between those two extremes, and the larger the society it's more probable that different rules apply to various subdivisions within it.
So no, it is not possible to set up an ideal society (of any form, libertarian or socialist or whatever) and keep it such for a long time -- unless perhaps for very small, heavily regulated and closed groups, isolated from the rest of society which tolerates them (as is often the case with religious cults and small but wealthy totalitarian countries).
- tgflynn 16y agoit is not possible to set up an ideal society (of any form, libertarian or socialist or whatever) and keep it such for a long time Human society is probably the most complex system in the known universe. How can you understand it well enough to claim that no better configurations exists ? Of course your use of the word "ideal" gives you an out since that is an absolute asymptotic concept, similar to that of "God", which bears no relation to any observable reality. For my part I believe that solutions exist to the organization of human society which are undeniably better than the tiny set that has so far been tried in the short history of human civilization.
- BerislavLopac 16y ago"Better" is a most relative concept, grasshopper.
- gojomo 16y agoSure, there are tradeoffs and frictions in the practicalities. But the potential solution space isn't dictated by a few simple axes of decentralization vs. concentration, or totalitarianism vs. anarchy. It's massively dimensional, and we already know governance variation can make a massive difference in quality of life: consider West vs. East Germany, or Hong Kong vs. pre-liberalization China, or South vs. North Korea. What if there are other configurations as much better than the current best, as the current best is better than the current worst? Or put more concretely, compared to North Korea, South Korea is already a 'utopia'. Maybe there's another solution as much better again, which makes South Korea look like a retro prison state, and would to its vurrent residents be a comparative utopia. (Of course, this utopia's residents, once inured to it, would still find plenty to gripe about. C'est la treadmill hédonique.) Most existing states have strong incentives to send the message: "Current tradeoffs are as good as it gets; this is already the best of all possible worlds — so get back to your station." They're lying.
- danenania 16y ago"Human society can't be engineered, it's a living mechanism" These aren't exclusive. Certainly there are limits, but human society is engineered every day on many scales and the effects are all around you. Just look at the the differences in culture between a new tech startup and IBM. Aren't these human societies? For a larger scale, compare North Korea and Iceland. "...in the past millennia we've been through pretty much all we could" No, we've been through all that we've been through. Before democracy, there was no such thing and your reasoning would have deemed it impossible to live under any system but autocratic despotism. Even though we have a long way to go, humanity has created political innovation for its entire existence, and the rate of this innovation has continually accelerated. Why would this change? I believe it comes down to culture. If the members of a society are instilled strongly enough with the right values, it isn't necessary for a central body to enforce these values. It would actually be counterproductive. For companies, these values relate to ingenuity, productivity, cooperation, ethics. For countries, the same apply, but replacing a central legal authority also requires strong judicial values. These already exist to an extent. Try punching an old lady on a crowded city street and see what happens to you--it won't matter whether there are police around. Compassion and charity are also necessary. Luckily, in spite of the bad news we see constantly, these values are also quite pervasive in the world. Pervasive enough? I'm not sure. But I certainly wouldn't rule out the possibility that humanity could make great strides in improving its political systems, and perhaps reach a point that would look utopian to our present day, even if it takes a hell of a long time to get there.
- BerislavLopac 16y agoI meant that we've been through most varieties we could considering the environment so far. Of course new forms of societies will appear as the environments (technological, sociological, environmental, biological etc) change. My whole point was that it's impossible to create a "frozen", immutable form of society. There is no ideal form, it's always a compromise of some sort, and it always changes.
- danenania 16y agoFair enough.