3 ms·
Can there be a way to combat this, short of curation? The name could be changed, the binary modified, the images and descriptions trivially tweaked... the clos
by Groxx 16y ago
Can there be a way to combat this, short of curation?
The name could be changed, the binary modified, the images and descriptions trivially tweaked... the closest you could do is block the developers, at which point they just create new accounts. About the only method I can think of is to require a bank / card number, and block that internally - and they can always get new ones.
- guelo 16y agoAs someone suggested in the comments, a $10 per app charge would probably fix this.
- Groxx 16y agoNot if they make more than $10 per round. There are a lot of marks in the world, as evidenced by 175+ submissions. This went unnoticed for how long? Made them how much money? $10/app would just cut into their profits, it wouldn't stop it.
- megablast 16y agoApple went through a similar problem, and the same solution was suggested. Rather than adopting this, Apple went for better scruitinsing the apps it approves, but I imagine a few still get through. Although, the exact same problem could not happen on the iPhone app store, something similar can happen.
- aquarin 16y agoThis is why Apple requires you to fax you CC number and name for additional verification if you live in some countries. I still wait for verification.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoThe most obvious webspam is made more difficult by the fact that newly-created webpages are heavily penalized in Google's web search engine. Weighting for accounts and applications, and letting comments from earlier versions carry over ("here's what people thought of earlier versions of myapp:") would help. Probably.
- Groxx 16y agoI don't think it would help here, though; by changing that one number, they're releasing a new application, not a new version. That way it appears back up on top in the new app list. Comments wouldn't / shouldn't carry over. Persistent developer comments / ratings could be useful, though of course they'd suffer from the same ills that befall individual application reviews. I sort of wonder why I haven't seen any system which shows the overall developer rating alongside all their applications...
- JoachimSchipper 16y ago[I don't think you'll be seeing this, but in any case...] I thought about penalizing new apps for that reason - sure, you can rename your app to get rid of the reviews, but you'll have a harder time making it to the top of the lists.
- Groxx 16y agoI read through older comments for reasons just like this :) I wonder if a week-delay would solve it. A new submission is penalized, it slowly rises up the "new apps" list, and after a week it pops up at the top, similar to how most systems handle "new" entries. At worst, people who don't read will be annoyed that their released-on-xmas doesn't appear until just before new-year's. At best, you've just made app-spamming far slower (minimum 7x).