4 ms·
Many of those crimes are drug crimes, which are only a crime because we've chosen to make them so. It's not all that hard to change a law to make a certain gro
by nostrademons 16y ago
Many of those crimes are drug crimes, which are only a crime because we've chosen to make them so. It's not all that hard to change a law to make a certain group of people whose habits you dislike criminals.
- shin_lao 16y agoAll crimes are crimes because we decided to make them so.
- derefr 16y agoDepends on your definition of "decide." Some things are crimes because it is in human nature to revile them, and to enforce social mores against them.
- bugsy 16y agoWhat things exactly? Killing people? That is widely supported through ongoing wars, trade embargoes, abortion, and the death penalty. Rape? What we call rape in many states in the USA, an 18 yr old having consensual sex with a 16 yr old, is accepted in other parts of the world. Or let's take Sweden's definition, having consensual sex without a condom. That's not against the law in most places. Pedophilia? Anthropologists claim found that it is common and accepted in Polynesia and other cultures. Cannibalism? Again, supposedly many cultures practice it and consider it an acceptable and beneficial practice. What exactly is universally reviled by human nature? Copraphilia? That's not illegal though.
- derefr 16y agoThe most obvious case is property theft. Everyone feels some sort of base emotional sting when something that they have grown attached to is forcefully taken away from them. This can be generalized to conceptual belongings: pride, control, honor, dignity, etc. can also be "stolen" in various ways. The more serious immoral acts, however, of the kind that leave their subjects unable to emote (whether because they are dead, in a coma, "brainwashed", or whatever else) have to be analyzed from an in-group vs. out-group perspective. Given a "tribal unit", murder by outsiders of the tribe, to insiders in the tribe is universally reviled by tribe members. As we all (except sociopaths) mentally assign ourselves one or more tribes, this is generalizable back to all of humanity.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bugsy 16y agoPeople support taxes and welfare though. Taxation is theft plain and simple. So again, although some are opposed to the theft of taxation, not all are, and so it's not true there is universal revulsion for property theft. Also theft of even people's houses and land via eminent domain seizures, or of cars through police confiscations against the innocent are supported by some and not by others.
- philwelch 16y agoThere are definitely elements of this involved; I just challenge the idea that this is the whole story. If you're comparing the US to a country where drugs are legal, of course the US crime and incarceration rates are going to be higher on account of that fact. That's not the comparison being offered, though.
- forensic 16y agoYou don't realize how lax drug sentences are in other countries. In canada, people caught with kilos of coke get house arrest. There was a guy caught with 500kg of MDMA in his backyard kitchen and he got house arrest. People don't go to jail for drug crimes - they usually get community service or house arrest. Certainly for possession NO ONE goes to jail in Canada, but I've read that in the US people with a gram of weed have been sent to jail. WTF? Or for that matter, two hits of crack, and you get like 10 years or something ridiculous. In canada it's almost impossible to actually serve jailtime for a possession charge, and even trafficking charges are often not met with incarceration but rather conditions.
- swombat 16y agoDrugs are not legal in Denmark.
- philwelch 16y agoYes, that was roughly my point. If drugs were legal in Denmark, we'd be able to say "of course the US crime and imprisonment rates are higher than Denmark's because the US considers drug use to be a crime and Denmark doesn't". But, since drugs are illegal in Denmark, Danish drug dealers contribute to the Danish crime rate (and imprisonment rate, when caught) just as American drug dealers contribute to the American crime rate (and imprisonment rate, when caught).
- iwwr 16y agoNot only drug crimes, but drug-related violence as well.