3 ms·
Simply picking an arbitrary period of time over which crime rates happen to have declined, and claiming with no evidence that there's a causal factor that happe
by _delirium 16y ago
Simply picking an arbitrary period of time over which crime rates happen to have declined, and claiming with no evidence that there's a causal factor that happens to nicely match some preconceived notions about "bad cultures", misframes the entire issue imo.
If you look at actual studies on the subject, there is little to no scientific evidence that tougher incarceration policies reduce crime. There is about as much evidence that they actually increase crime, in fact, depending on the conditions of incarceration and gang ties that that fosters.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's not exactly "arbitrary", since it corresponds to a number of anti-crime measures specifically aimed at incarcerating criminals for longer periods of time. For instance, 23 states, covering a majority of the American population, passed "three strikes" laws in the 1990's. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_strikes_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_strikes_law For clarification on my thoughts about cultural heterogenity, please look at this comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2036933 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2036933
- _delirium 16y agoThere wasn't a particularly big increase in incarceration rates starting in the 1990s, though. The first big uptick was 1973-1983 or so, and then the pace accelerated in the mid-1980s, actually stabilizing by the late 1990s: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Incarceration_rate_of_inmates_incarcerated_under_state_and_federal_jurisdiction_per_100,000_population_1925-2008.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Incarceration_rate_of_inma... Why would the big increase in incarceration rates starting in the 1970s cause a decrease in crime only in the 1990s?
- philwelch 16y agoIt's an interesting and complicated question. If you look at the graph, the derivative of the incarceration rate actually peaks around 1990, which is still pre-three-strikes. And in retrospect, three-strikes laws wouldn't have increased the incarceration rate very much because someone convicted of three felonies is presumably someone who would have a high frequency of imprisonment anyway, and rounding that frequency to 1 wouldn't have as great an effect. (If you're in and out of prison frequently enough, enough that you're in prison 80% of the time, sentencing you to life only increases the prison population by 0.2 of a person by aggregate.) Although, come to think of it, that might be the answer--a lot of the criminals we first imprisoned in the 70's ended up being recidivists, and cracking down on recidivism in the 90's through longer sentences and three strikes laws decreased crime when the recidivists ended up staying in prison, rather than leaving prison to commit more crimes every few years. The sad part is, this might even apply to people who were unjustly imprisoned for drugs. Someone in prison on drug charges is going to be more likely to get involved in gangs while in prison, and hence become a more dangerous criminal when let out.