4 ms·
The way that Bradley Manning is being treated doesn't surprise me too much. He is suspected of "leaking classified information," so it would make sense to keep
by pyre 16y ago
The way that Bradley Manning is being treated doesn't surprise me too much. He is suspected of "leaking classified information," so it would make sense to keep him in solitary confinement from a government/military bureaucrat's point of view. If they don't segregate him, he might leak more secrets to other people.
The other stuff (no mattress or pillow) just seems like pettiness on the part of the people in power that were embarrassed.
- jrockway 16y agoAnyone can be suspected of anything. Let's have a trial, a real trial, and then worry about punishment after he's guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. (And by real trial, I mean a jury of Americans, not some bullshit military tribunal. Yeah, yeah, he signed some papers that said he can't have a real trial. Fuck that. This is America, not Saudi Arabia.)
- pyre 16y agoAs philwelch stated, you give up a bunch of rights to join the military. "Fuck that. This is America." is a 'bunch of bullshit' on your part. Even the Constitution itself states that you give up rights when you join the military. Don't invoke the Founding Fathers only when it's convenient.
- philwelch 16y agoManning is a soldier charged with violating the UCMJ, and should be court-martialed like any other soldier charged with violation of military law. (This is distinct from the "military tribunals" established for "enemy combatants" during the Bush administration.) The duties and obligations of a soldier don't change just because he's become a cause celebre on the internet in the course of allegedly violating his duties. Interestingly, nearly every service member I've heard discuss the subject would prefer to be tried by a court-martial than by a civilian court.
- jrockway 16y agoHow many of these service members are openly gay?
- pyre 16y agoGays in the military have nothing to do with Manning's case (unless he is openly gay, then I digress).
- Natsu 16y agoAccounts I've read indicate that Manning was in fact gay and that DADT was part of his motive. I do not know if it's true or not, though, as I have no way of corroborating that information.
- bugsy 16y agoMy understanding is that everyone knew Manning was gay. I doubt that has much to do with the case though. Their primary evidence is that someone claiming to be Manning confessed to some other dude via internet chat. It seems to me that anything confessed over (non-video non-voice text only) internet chat should be completely inadmissible as there really is no way to know who you are talking to.
- billswift 16y agoI remember in one of H Beam Piper's novels, I think it was Little Fuzzy, a character mentions that he had heard, "If you were innocent you are better off being tried by a military court, and if guilty by a civilian one." (not an accurate quote, but close).
- lucasjung 16y agoActually, I'd reverse that, at least for the U.S. military. There are several types of military courts, in a spectrum ranging from "lower burden of proof of guilt but tighter restrictions on punishments" to "higher burden of proof of guilt but fewer restrictions on punishments." For the rest of this post I will arbitrarily refer to the latter as the "lower" end of the spectrum and the former as the "higher." Non-judicial punishment (NJP), which isn't actually a court-martial, anchors the lower end of the spectrum: the commanding officer (CO) can consider more or less any evidence he chooses, and gets to decide guilt or innocence based upon a preponderance of evidence (as opposed to "reasonable doubt"), but the maximum punishments he can hand out are severely limited (still shitty if you get them, but not even in the same ballpark as hard time). At the high end of the spectrum are general courts-martial, which are comparable to civilian courts in terms of burden of proof, rules on evidence, and maximum sentences. Generally, the type of court-martial chosen is a function of how certain the authorities are that the defendant is guilty, and how bad they want to hammer the defendant. For example, if they're very confident that the defendant is guilty, but don't feel a need for very harsh punishment, they might use a summary court-martial (the "lowest" type of court-martial, with only NJP being lower on the spectrum). If they are not that confident of guilt, or if they really want to go for the maximum punishment, they will use a general court-martial. If you're guilty, you want to be towards the lower end of the spectrum because your punishment will be minimized. If you're not guilty, you want the general court-martial because anything less gives you a higher chance of being wrongfully convicted. Fortunately, in most circumstances, defendants have the right to demand proceedings which are higher on the spectrum. Typically, however, defendants who know that they are guilty have the good sense to accept the lower-end proceeding. There are other things which separate courts-martial from civilian courts, such as article 31 rights, and the composition of the jury.
- patrickaljord 16y agoRead that http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/12/23/manning http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/12/23... tl;dr Many experts say that his punishment is torture and the US has denounced such treatment as torture not too long ago when it was done by others.