2 ms·
Having listened to the 64bit comparisons of the audio on the page (that's a particularly cruel sample set; is it a common one?): Wow. The worst audio chunks o
by Groxx 16y ago
Having listened to the 64bit comparisons of the audio on the page (that's a particularly cruel sample set; is it a common one?):
Wow. The worst audio chunks on CELT are significantly better than the worst on the other codecs. Overall, I hear a bit of a loss on the low-end of wider sounds (the one that pops out to my ear is the entry starting at 0:37), but for such an incredible improvement in the high ranges that's a wonderful price to pay. Still a decent bit of that "anti-pre-echo", which I despise, but generally less than the others.
All in all: an epic improvement over the other samples, especially when taken across the board. All the other encoders had huge distortion on one or more of the sound bites (especially the third, 0:22); CELT had very little, even at its worst. Phenomenal work.
/listens to 32kbps. shall update!
edit: yep, it hurts most on that 0:37 entry. Unfortunately, I put it as noticeably worse than all but the AAC-LC (but that one's horrible in everything) at 32kbps. It does handle the voice at the end very well, though. That, with the latency, means it'd probably be great for voice use.
/tries 48; maybe it survives at the middle?
edit2: yeah, about middle. Almost catches up to the HE-AAC entries, maybe passes Vorbis.
Voice-only or required-low-latency aside (both important qualities), I think I'm not going to use or recommend this for sub-64kbps, though it could of course improve yet. Vorbis and HE-AACs beat it. At 64 though, maybe above, or for respectable quality telepresence, it sounds like a clear winner.
- nullc 16y agoFWIW, mono at32kbit/sec is fairly close to stereo at 64. (Of course, there is some joint coding gain from stereo— but stereo's wost case is just as bad as 2x mono and it's the often the worst cases that limit the quality). For example, mono speech at 32kbit/sec: https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.orig.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.orig.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.MP3.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.MP3.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.vorbis.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.vorbis.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.CELT.wav https://people.xiph.org/~greg/celt/spec.CELT.wav The SILK+CELT hybrid does better still, but even CELT alone is still fairly useful at lower rates.