7 ms·
Some feedback about the formula from a parent: The formula needs to account for the reality that with young children your "parental duties" expands to occupy a
by Waterluvian 7y ago
Some feedback about the formula from a parent:
The formula needs to account for the reality that with young children your "parental duties" expands to occupy all free time when kids are awake. And also shifts other chores into any free time slots when kids are asleep.
Kids are asleep. Time to clean the kitchen, do the dishes, switch the laundry, cut some veggies for tomorrow's dinner, and then find somewhere softer than last night to pass out.
- cortesoft 7y agoYeah, as a dad of 2 kids under 4, I ended up having negative free hours. I put 54 hours of parenting a week, because it is non stop on the weekends for about 12 hours a day, and 5 hours or so on weekdays (getting them up and ready for daycare in the morning, then playing, feeding and putting them down at night.) I do get some chores done during that time, which is probably how I am able to exist with what ends up being negative free time (doubled up on some of hours) Man I can't wait for them to get old enough to play on their own without requiring my full attention.
- mruts 7y agoI live in Tanzania and here any kid that is above the age of 2 has free rein to go wherever they want. Maybe it's not a better way (though I suspect it is), but it is certainly easier (assuming you don't have 8 children like most people here though).
- Waterluvian 7y agoI think it boils down to the trade off between convenience, cost, and safety. I'm convinced that kids in the developed world are so safe and so likely to see adulthood that in order to move the needle on safety even the slightest, we have to dump a huge amount of time and money into it. Okay so the infant mortality rate in Canada is at about 4 per 1000 (about 38 per 1000 in Tanzania). How do we improve that? Well let's dump an insane amount of stress and panic on parents about which way their children are facing when they sleep. That's one of thousands of examples I could come up with if pressed. We are way way way into diminishing returns here. We have so few problems that we are obsessing over error margins worth of added safety at the cost of exponential parenting efforts. I asked my dad how they let my brothers and I wander the suburb on our own as kids. Weren't they afraid we'd be kidnapped or hit by a car or drown in the river? My dad said they never knew they were supposed to be worried. It just didn't really register as a thing. It sure as hell was a far safer place to grow up than where they did. There's also another possible angle to consider. Imagine if I got all the parents in town together and said, "so we have concluded that a healthy childhood is one full of risk and freedom and adventure. We need everyone to take the proverbial training wheels off and let your kids be kids. However this will mean that some of your children aren't going to make it to adulthood. It's just the nature of this kind of upbringing."
- baxtr 7y agoThanks for this comment. I always react the same whenever someone proposes to do thing the old way, eg people saying we live in an overly protective society with people wearing helmets while skiing.
- dahart 7y ago> I asked my dad how they let my brothers and I wanted the suburb on our own as kids. When I was 6, my parents took us to Mexico and let me and my two younger siblings wander around on our own. They also barely registered any idea of possible danger. The closest they got was when my little brother was petting a horse from behind more than a mile from home and got lightly kicked in the head. They told us to be more careful and watch out for each other, and we were wandering around the next day. It could have gone bad, but it didn’t, we survived. Other memories of my childhood include things like bouncing around in the back seat of their Buick without seatbelts. My wife had a hard time letting our own two boys wander around on their own in safe middle class neighborhoods until they were both over 12. I was pushing for more autonomy, but I have to admit I’d never have given my kids as much autonomy as I got.
- cortesoft 7y ago> It could have gone bad, but it didn’t, we survived. I mean, this is literally survivorship bias. The kids that died being out on their own aren't posting about it
- dahart 7y agoIt’s just survivorship, without the bias. I’m pointing out that I was lucky, not concluding that my odds were any better than they were or better than anyone else’s. I literally said it could have gone bad, I’m aware childhood mortality rates were higher in the past.
- cortesoft 7y agoIt would be better in some ways, but it does lead to a higher infant mortality rate (as the other commenter pointed out). I don't think I am willing to make that trade off (even if I could... I would be arrested if I let my 3 year old wonder down the street alone)
- gambiting 7y agoI imagine there must be some middle ground. Yes, don't let your 3 year old wander around the street on their own, but also don't make them completely reliant on your attention - just let then play on their own. If they get bored then they get bored, it's not your problem(until you make it yours of course).
- cortesoft 7y agoWe try this. The amount of dangerous and destructive things a 3 year old can do is crazy
- phreeza 7y agoIn Zambia, and I suspect in Tanzania, too, four-year old siblings also already play a role in taking care of their smaller siblings.
- Waterluvian 7y agoWhich they're wholly not capable of doing. They just do it because there's little alternative available yet.
- baq 7y agoI’m sorry for a stupid question but do you have streets and cars there?
- pavel_lishin 7y agoI imagine the community dynamic is entirely different there, as well as the physical dangers. I cannot let my 3 year old run around Manhattan on her own; she'd get hit by a car or a bike, or get on a bus and disappear somewhere into Brooklyn, or fall into the subway tracks.
- jobigoud 7y agoParenting, except in the case of unwanted pregnancies, is a hobby. Culturally it has a sort of special status but in the end it's another hobby that one decides to commit to. It's a choice made that this is going to be your mostly exlusive hobby for the next several years.
- meheleventyone 7y agoYou don’t think it’s important for society and the future economy?
- welly 7y agoI don't think the world is particularly short of people. We've got lots of people. Some might say "too many". I've chosen not to take up the hobby (as GP fairly described) but for every one of me, there are ten others who participate. Not everyone needs to bear children.
- meheleventyone 7y agoRight but we do actually need some people to have kids and a declining population is pretty bad for the way society is currently organized. It's great you've decided not to have kids but denigrating others choices to have them by calling it a hobby is not cool.
- Waterluvian 7y agoIt's less a hobby and more of a deeply ingrained evolutionary trait. I don't think people who lack the trait can ever grok what it feels like. For me it's up there with eating and breathing.
- gewoonkris 7y agoI try to make it a point to do all the chores when the kids are awake. When they are asleep is time to relax; not do mundane tasks I don't feel it's my duty to entertain my kinds every waking hour, so if they have to settle with watching me fold the laundry or unload the dishwasher, so be it. This probably won't win me the father-of-the-year award, and it is parenting-style me and my girlfriend don't always agree about, but I refuse to sacrifice all my free time for my children.
- DanBC 7y agoHow would you feel about this choice if one of your children died of cancer? Would you still think you'd made the right choice, or would you regret prioritising laundry over your children?
- jclulow 7y agoLiterally nothing will prepare you for that. No amount of time is enough. Living your life in abject fear of that morbid possibility is crippling.
- DanBC 7y ago"spending time with my kids" is not "living in crippling fear of them dying".
- sokoloff 7y agoIt sounded like you were opposed to doing mundane daily chores or otherwise not giving 100% of your free time to them while they're awake for fear that you might regret that choice if they died young of cancer. That doesn't seem that far apart to this reader.
- scarejunba 7y agoHonestly, I think it depends on how it goes. As a young kid, I watched my dad write emails through Hotmail over HyperTerminal (I think) to other doctors discussing surgical procedures. Honestly, I quite enjoyed it. He just wrote the emails and I just sat there and read what he wrote and understood some tiny fraction. Thoroughly enjoyable.
- sn9 7y agoThat's not really inevitable. It's a cultural norm that can be changed. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/06/09/616928895/how-to-get-your-kids-to-do-chores-without-resenting-it https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/06/09/6169288... https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/09/01/641266260/how-to-get-kids-to-do-chores-does-the-maya-method-work https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/09/01/6412662...