8 ms·
How to create a startup country
- afshin 16y agoThe best discoveries of these startups, like in any industry, will be copied by the market leaders — the countries of today. That seems to be patently false. If better ways of governance really were infectious, governments would be roughly converging in their policies. At the very least, for example, similar governments (let's say western democracies) might all have universal healthcare.
- il 16y agoWith the exception of the US, don't they?
- afshin 16y agoYes, they do. But that's quite an exception.
- glenra 16y agoWhy assume universal healthcare is a clearly better way of governance? Leaving aside the question of whether it's "better", I'm also not sure it qualifies as a "way of governance". It's a feature some countries choose to implement in part due to their "way of governance". Arguing over whether some country should implement a feature like "universal health care" is arguing at the policy level; Seasteading is operating at one or two meta-levels higher than that.
- nihilocrat 16y agoLet’s think of government as an industry, where countries are firms and citizens are customers. People should be thinking of governments/countries/cultures this way anyhow. Vote with your feet.
- nivertech 16y agoBuilding next Singapore on high seas?
- Kilimanjaro 16y agoCorruption is the disease of all societies. It will be present in seasteading societies too. Fight and cure corruption here on terra firma first. That's the real utopia and exactly there is where money should be spent.
- patrickaljord 16y agoTo get rid of corruption you'd need to get rid of humans first.
- angdis 16y agoProbably much better to offer "Ayn Rand" cruise-ship packages. For libertarians, it would be a "nice place to visit" but NOBODY would ever want to live there.
- gfodor 16y agoIf your startup fails, some investors lose money and you have to go get a job. If your country fails, people will probably suffer and/or die. Am I missing something?
- DaniFong 16y agoIf your startup succeeds people will suffer and die. That's life. Your spirit of adventure should be kindled by a consideration of the baseline risks of life.
- gfodor 16y agoUh, the risks are certainly a lot higher with starting a country than starting a startup. The two are barely even comparable in terms of real risk.
- true_religion 16y agoNo you're not missing anything, but its worth noting that people are willing to risk death for financial reward. For example: colonists.
- rwhitman 16y agoI read an article a while back about an academic paper in which a new system of experimental government could be formed by a sort of international charter company on property leased from existing nations. Instead of building ridiculously complicated, expensive structures in the middle of the ocean, to experiment with a new government it would be substantially easier to carve out a small chunk of territory in a place where land is cheap. I think seasteading has its merits in terms of vacation resorts and perhaps fisheries or mining, but beyond that who wants to live out in the middle of the friggin ocean, especially if its going to cost as much as it would to live in a condo in san francisco?
- iwwr 16y agoHomesteading is the default means of expansion into a previously uninhabited territory. The question is if that would be allowed to happen on the high seas before space. This woman, Kristina Gjerde, was giving a talk at TED about the UN landgrab (called "making law on the sea"). http://www.ted.com/talks/kristina_gjerde_making_law_on_the_high_seas.html http://www.ted.com/talks/kristina_gjerde_making_law_on_the_h... It's fascinating to watch this sort of mind at work; the consternation that political authority does not extend everywhere yet, and how to work to accomplish it. If humanity is to become more civilized, there has to be a space for alternative political systems to develop.
- guelo 16y agoThis idea is just stupid, not even considering the ridiculous technical challenges. There are about 200 countries in the world, so there are many experiments going on, and many of the experiments are very successful, from the socialist northern European states to more conservative ones like Singapore. Even the USA with it's many flaws is one of humanity's greatest achievements in terms of producing wealth and welfare for its citizens. Rich people like Thiel can pretty much choose whichever of these countries they want to live in but that is not good enough for him, he has this weird obsession with creating a Libertarian utopia out at sea.
- anateus 16y agoThe reason you're wrong is right in the title. There are plenty of countries already, with plenty of different systems. There's great variation from one extreme to the other, but otherwise there are smooth clusters around particular areas. The point of this project is to create a startup country, a place where greater risk--in terms of the system used, not necessarily within the system--can mean greater reward. Yes, Thiel is a libertarian, but TSI quite explicitly concentrates on enabling anyone to partake of their output. This isn't Galt's Gulch in the Water, nor is it intended to (maybe in Thiel's private dreams, but definitely not in the way TSI is run). I'd love to find out if the common modes of living we're used to are local maxima, or if we'll find that the various experiments converge again towards familiar clusters. To be content with what's out there is the same as saying "well, pick one of the many companies out there and join as an employee. What's the point of starting your own company?"
- olalonde 16y ago> To be content with what's out there is the same as saying "well, pick one of the many companies out there and join as an employee. What's the point of starting your own company?" Not only that but you don't even get to pick your company. (unless you consider immigration but well, it's not as easy as switching job)
- kkowalczyk 16y agoThe only argument you give for why this is such a stupid idea is that everything is just fine with existing countries/governments. I beg to disagree. Just in recent days we read on HN about cops assaulting 15 year old and throwing in jail 17 year old who filmed that on tape. We've been assaulted with Assange/WikiLeaks stories, where government officials are calling for assassinations, scramble to find existing/create new laws to prevent their dirty laundry being known to public. US is waging two unjust, unprovoked wars, started under made up pretenses (and that only few years after Vietnam disaster). Health care costs are spiraling out of control in US, while at the same time the quality of service is bad. Broadband in US is worse than in South Korea. Law making process is out of control, with mega-bills stuffed with unrelated rules bought by lobbying. War on drugs, terrorizing war on terror, prisons population out of control (compared to other countries). I could go on (and no, other countries are no better in that regard). What I like about that talk is that it talks about governments serving the people. On paper that's what it is but in practice the government is the master and it behaves like one. The government has all the power and the way it feels is that it is on a relentless drive to get even more power and it's a rare act of short lived triumph where some of its power is stripped away and sanity restored. The examples of power grab abound (expanding search and seizure at borders and in the airports, trying to silence whistle-blowers by e.g. bullying private sector, criminalizing behavior like recording police at work (so that they can abuse their power more freely), unconditionally accepting content industry propaganda about terrible losses from piracy and enacting censorship legislations that try to go around due process). So no, things are far from being good and I for one would welcome a government that tries to serve its people in reality, not just on paper.
- jdp23 16y ago"Every year, our phones get smarter, our cars safer, and our medical treatments more advanced. We all benefit from startups and established companies competing through constant innovation. So why is it that in one of the most advanced countries in the world, we’re still using the legal technology … of 1787?" Oh that pesky constitution, getting in the way of startups ...
- iwwr 16y agoThe modern world is using largely the legal technology that came out of the French Revolution, a combination of: nationalism, democracy (on the surface) and oligarchy (below the surface). Regarding the American Revolution, it is interesting to note that tax rates immediately after were higher than during British rule. Even George Washington part-took in the centralization of the American state afterwards: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion . (The Whiskey Rebellion demonstrated that the new national government had the willingness and ability to suppress violent resistance to its laws.) Of course, the idea of a centralized state (with imperial ambitions if it has enough power) is thousands of years old.
- kloncks 16y agoI don't understand why we can't apply what he seems to suggest (treating governments and politics in a smart efficient manner) without navigating the high seas and creating new land. That's just giving up on all the land we already have. That, for a starter, seems pretty defeating. edit: We keep on forgetting that our government (the US) was created on purpose to be very slow but ultimately fair. That's the inefficiency, yet it's still a great place for startups. That, coupled with our 300m citizens, makes something like this harder to do in a country like this. That's why we haven't been too successful in creating startup communities outside of 2 or 3 places in the entire United States. Yet, this can work in a lot of places. Or, rather, we can try to start applying it in a lot of places. Smaller places that have seen similar successes. I'm thinking Dubai, Israel, etc.
- olalonde 16y agoI think you missed the point of the article. The ultimate goal is not to create startup communities but to create governments that are ran as startups.
- arethuza 16y agoMost startups fail - when a company fails people pick themselves up and go and do other things, generally a bit wiser for the experience. History suggests that when countries fail, or at least when the machinery of civil society fails, things can get very unpleasant.
- stcredzero 16y agoI suspect that this may be merely a problem of granularity. Countries have been located on a permanent continuum, not on many discrete little movable platforms. If a seasteading nation failed, the pieces would just get sold off and towed away to simplest that is civilized.
- gbhn 16y agoJust like Yugoslavia? It isn't that simple. Guns come out when sovereignty gets threatened in this way, especially if things have deteriorated to the point that lots of people want to leave.
- piramida 16y agoThe problem here is that as soon as you build a platform in the sea and declare yourself independent from any country, you have to be able to protect it, too. Because nothing would stop someone from taking over your highly intelligent platform with a help of a banal machine gun. The world outside of developed countries is still a very unhappy place to live. Many micronation island projects failed badly in a few years being taken over by pirates.
- danenania 16y agoI think defending against pirates would be economically feasible through private security. The more serious problem would be defending against aggressive states. Real political progress would entail policies like legalized drugs, freedom of information and ideas, physical currency, etc. that would likely raise the ire of powerful states. Like the article says, these kinds of political experiments have the potential to act as competition toward established nations. Sadly, I think that nations would realize this and attempt to preempt the challenge through force if they could, this being their main advantage.
- tedesign 16y agoThis idea is based on the false assumption that there are no pre-existing laws for seas. There is a UN treaty and there are maritime laws and unwritten seamen laws. And the latest date way back in history. Pretending that seas are virgin territories as regards laws is a misconception.
- gimpf 16y agoThe people are much more pragmatic than the project sounds; they are thinking about how much autonomy is even possible, realistically. Maritime laws are seemingly one of the simplest issues out there.
- danenania 16y agoI don't think the idea is based on that assumption. It's okay if there are international maritime laws, as long as they don't prohibit this sort of activity (I have no idea whether they do or don't). These sorts of laws could even conceivably offer some protection to such a venture.
- billswift 16y agoThe most fundamental law, and one that effectively negates all floating "new country" ventures, is that any vessel that is not "flagged" by a real country is classified as a pirate vessel and will be taken over by any country, on the high seas most likely by the US Coast Guard which is the most widespread and aggressive enforcement presence on the high seas. If your vessel is flagged, then this isn't a problem, but you must abide by the laws of the flagging nation. And, in international water, you are still vulnerable to random searches by the Coast Guard if for any reason they get their back up.
- stcredzero 16y agoI just see another business opportunity for small nations who want the money from granting flags but have no agenda otherwise.
- SudarshanP 16y agoThe seasteading institute hopes for an exploration of possibilities. Not implementing one particular agenda. And exploring the solution space could lead to unforeseen rewards. For eg. the open source movement hacked the legal system to come up with an awesome solution. It was different from capitalism, which assumes that innovation happens only if people see financial reward. In a communist system, you are "expected" to innovate by an order from the top. But these systems never thought that people could do stuff like writing things like Operating systems, Compilers, browsers, databases... medicine... electronics, architecture, movies, novels and even ads "just for the sake of doing it." Our current systems are tied to labor as a critical cog for the economics to work out. In the future automation will significantly reduce the need for labor in manufacturing and services. This will be a disruptive change. Right now the labor that gets outsourced to cheaper countries will finally be outsourced to machines. A lot of services like mechanical turk will even take up skilled jobs like even that of doctors. Right now though machines do most of our manufacturing, we have invented absurdly complex services to keep 6 billion people busy. But at some point we can stop and ask... is this the best way to let 6 billion people have what they want/need. Right now we technically have driverless cars. It is not inconceivable we will automate most of humanity's grunt work. The rest is FUN to do "just for the sake of it". So it will be a time to ask whether capitalism+voter elected oligarchy is the best way to live in such a world. Watching this video from the venusproject was a real eyeopener: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3932487043163636261# http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3932487043163636261# http://www.thevenusproject.com/ http://www.thevenusproject.com/ Another interesting take on the effect of automation on the way we live is this short story at http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm Carl Marx codified communism, The French revolution gave us the modern democratic framework, Stallman and others gave us the skeleton for open source. It just shows radical changes are possible. Maybe we will invent something totally different from what we currently have. Maybe not. But why ridicule a guy like Thiel who wants to sail west to reach the east. Maybe he will end up doing something very different from what he set out to do.
- arvinjoar 16y agoThe problem with the Venus project is that its leading proponents do not understand basic economic principles and how they apply to scarcity. Peter Thiel and Patri Friedman are not part of the Venus project, they are libertarian transhumanists. Full disclosure, I am a libertarian too, and if you're interested in the economic aspects of why I don't think the Venus project is a good thing, read this article, http://mises.org/daily/4636 http://mises.org/daily/4636. This is HN, so I won't get into any political debates, but I do think that the information I've provided is relevant.
- stcredzero 16y agoAwhile back, there was an article here about minimum-communication distance nodes located between major trading centers. If there'd is a company that specializes in trading on the New York and London exchanges, then the minimum lightspeed lag for both exchanges is somewhere in the Atlantic. I can envision financial seasteads arising from server farms and their infrastructure.
- rwhitman 16y agoIts called Iceland
- stcredzero 16y agoIf you had floating platforms, you could do better on one end.