5 ms·
> The Liberal Democrats are still actively fighting against the historic Leave vote which means they cannot be trusted as they don't respect the people's will.
by dijit 7y ago
> The Liberal Democrats are still actively fighting against the historic Leave vote which means they cannot be trusted as they don't respect the people's will.
They're the only party that are, instead of 48% of the population being left behind they're actually supporting them. Regardless of your stance on brexit being a good thing or a bad thing there are certain facts that are being ignored. One of which is that "brexit" is a nebulous concept which keeps changing depending on the direction of the wind. I distinctly remember all prominent leave politicians saying we could stay part of the single market. Now they say that was never the plan. This is treating the UK population as intellectually bankrupt.
I'm not saying there's no reasons to _not_ back the lib dems, they've never truly held the chalice so we can't necessarily trust everything they say, it's easy to make such promises when you have no chance of actually winning or have dealt with the realities of ruling.
But perpetuating the "will of the people" meme is incorrigible considering that even the referendum that took us into the EU was followed up with a confirmatory referrendum 2 years after.
- davesmith1983 7y agoNo I am sorry they aren't trying to help the 48%. They want to remain. That isn't trying to help the 48% that is trying to overturn the vote. You are playing around with words. They WANT TO REMAIN, the country VOTED TO LEAVE. That is undemocratic. They have democrat in the name, yet do not support the largest exercise of democracy in the UK ever. > One of which is that "brexit" is a nebulous concept which keeps changing depending on the direction of the wind. I distinctly remember all prominent leave politicians saying we could stay part of the single market. Now they say that was never the plan. This is treating the UK population as intellectually bankrupt. On the ticket "Leave the European Union". That means Leaving the EU, if the single market is part of that we leave it. Now just because some politicians want to confuse and conflate things and pretend "Leave" means things other than what most people would think "Leave" means that is doesn't mean Leaving the European Union is a nebulous concept. > But perpetuating the "will of the people" meme is incorrigible considering that even the referendum that took us into the EU was followed up with a confirmatory referrendum 2 years after. We aren't joining the EU, we were joining EEC. This is nothing like the EU of today. Some might argue we never voted to join.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar. This comment is a noticeable step in that direction. Also, the site guidelines ask you not to use allcaps for emphasis. Would you mind reviewing them? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- microcolonel 7y agoThere's a high premium here placed on civility, even if sometimes enforcement can seem... not exactly equal. Nonetheless, you'll have a better time on Hacker News with less accusatory and loud tone. Your points lower down in this reply are spot on, but because of the "ASCII YELLING" and accusatory tone, it'll probably remain flagged (only visible to people who specifically turn on a feature to view flagged replies).
- microcolonel 7y ago> But perpetuating the "will of the people" meme is incorrigible considering that even the referendum that took us into the EU was followed up with a confirmatory referrendum 2 years after. That was the EEC, a dramatically less powerful and important collaboration which has morphed gradually into something that would be unrecognizable to those who voted in the affirmative to join the EEC. Furthermore, that was some decades ago; there has since been born a whole generation of people who are now legal adults, and a similar number of people have since passed away. A referendum of that vintage, on the topic of a substantially different organization, is surely less relevant than a recent referendum with a clear morally (even if not legally) binding result, on the current organization. P.S. maybe it's not great to paint people as “perpetuating the ‘will of the people’ meme” rather than simply being of the opinion that the referendum represents the will of the people.
- dijit 7y agoMy point wasn't about what the previous referendum was regarding, just that it was necessary to have a confirmatory referendum back then and it's somehow the worst thing ever when a confirmatory referendum is insinuated now. I believe a minority of people (even up to 40% potentially) feel like they'll be robbed of a "win" if the vote is put to the people now. And thus are incredibly defensive of anyone being allowed to vote again. It's also a tangially related point but the referendum was organised when glastonbury was happening and since the demographics state that young people tend towards remain, and they were essentially denied a vote. Since 34% of all people didn't vote, and it's such a slim majority I don't buy the argument that it's "the will of the people", it's the will of some people, and it has polarised the country. The fact is that people didn't actually know what they were voting for, everyone had a different version of brexit in mind, most were absolute fantasy. There are a lot of people who are anti-EU due to decades of defamation by ruling parties and our mass media. Regarding my last point the EU had to set up a site to defend itself, but, as you likely know: disinformation is hard to counteract. https://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/euromyths-a-z-index/ https://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/euromyths-a-z-index/ My statement about "will of the people" being a meme follows directly the definition of memetics: > Memetics describes how an idea can propagate successfully, but doesn't necessarily imply a concept is factual People are always saying it's the will of the people but they're unwilling to possibly have another referendum, they're unwilling to accept that people have been lied to, and they're unwilling to accept that brexit as described has changed. Here's all the prominent leavers saying we would stay in the single market if people voted leave: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xGt3QmRSZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xGt3QmRSZY So it's not fact, but it's a soundbite that gets repeated ad infinitum.