14 ms·
Not likely. Cancer only gets serious after most of reproduction and child rearing and nurturing has been done. Whereas cold is pretty serious for infants for ex
by pas 7y ago
Not likely. Cancer only gets serious after most of reproduction and child rearing and nurturing has been done. Whereas cold is pretty serious for infants for example.
- dllthomas 7y agoDo note that you're doing that analysis in a setting where kids get a whole lot of colds.
- pas 7y agoDo note that evolution started to optimize when the conditions were a lot harsher. (Warm clean rooms with food and clean water, clean clothes, NSAIDs, etc.)
- dllthomas 7y agoMy point wasn't that a cold can't be dangerous. My point was that if getting a cold made a significant difference in the likelihood of some cancer then you may be substantially undercounting the risk of that cancer to children in the counterfactual where there is no susceptibility to colds. (To be clear, I don't think the parent's speculation is likely accurate. I do think it's interesting.)
- gbrown 7y agoWell said.
- pas 7y agoThat's a very important point, and you are of course right. (Your original comment wasn't very clear and I misinterpreted it, sorry.) Do kids (and people in general) get substantially less colds in warmer climates? Because then we can check cancer rates there. (And spend a lot of effort on controlling for other differences.) I wonder if anyone did this kind of data fishing.
- dllthomas 7y ago> Your original comment wasn't very clear and I misinterpreted it, sorry. Yeah, there's some tension between risk of being seen as condescending and making sure everything is sufficiently clear. In a low-stakes context like this (and outside of clarifications or responses to ELI5 requests) I try not to fill in all the gaps - when it goes well it leaves us all feeling a little smarter and when it goes wrong it occasionally leads somewhere interesting. The increased risk of misinterpretation was made even worse here by the priming of several other people making the point I wasn't.
- xky 7y agoYour parent was not being snarky. The parroting is snarky and doesn’t assist your point.
- pas 7y agoI haven't interpreted that comment as snakry, and I had no intention to be snarky, though I see why it came off like that.
- arkades 7y agoColds are not the flu. Children tolerate colds just fine.
- balabaster 7y agoIn my experience of being around a lot of kids, my own included, kids tend to tolerate colds a whole lot better than adults do.
- lloydde 7y agoColds are dangerous to new borns just as the parent comment says.
- Flott 7y agoPretty much anything is dangerous for a new born. I have to admit that I'd be much more scared from the flu on a new born than a cold.
- lloydde 7y agoSure, my comment is generally obvious, except I felt it needed to be said as arkades's comment seemed dismissive of the risks to infants with his response of "Colds are not the flu. Children tolerate colds just fine." Flu are truly scary causing deaths throughout childhood with increased survival around two years and then again around five years. My youngest turns five this month. Before she was two she was hospitalized with croup and she has had a rougher ride with illness than my other kids along the way too.
- arkades 7y agoNewborns are in danger from just about anything. Other special populations of children include those with AIDS, CF, DM, and any other immunocompromising condition or respiratory anomaly. Having addressed the special populations that are implicitly not the targets of broad comments: Typical children tolerate colds just fine. It’s not the flu. (Croup is also not a cold.)
- empath75 7y agomy kids get a cold every month, it seems like.. I don't think it's that serious.
- lloydde 7y agoColds are dangerous to new borns just as the parent comment says.
- pas 7y agoSure, because we have fire, shelter, insulation, clothes, a virtually endless supply of food, medicine, safe/clean potable water, etc. Evolution started without any of those.
- dllthomas 7y agoEvolution started without DNA, so that's not quite the right focus.
- dredmorbius 7y ago200k - 2m years of human / protohuman development, vs ~100 years under vaguely modern conditions, is a big difference. Your reply fails to acknowledge it.
- dllthomas 7y agoMy reply was narrowly addressing a mistake repeated across a couple comments. It was not intended to undermine the argument as a whole. Your comment seems, by implication, to make a similar mistake: it doesn't matter much how long we were in a different situation - what matters is whether we've had enough of a chance to adapt to the new one. It doesn't take (k)X years to "undo" adaptations that took X years to find. And yes, the 100 years you give are clearly not enough generations to do much adapting. Some of the items mentioned in the earlier comment (clothes, fire, shelter) are things humans have had for substantially longer than 100 years. But I don't know enough about the relevant time scales for anything to be clear to me about how much we've probably adapted to having them, which is why I didn't speak to that.
- everdev 7y agoSure, but communities with healthy parents and elders probably successfully raise more children.
- rjurney 7y agoWell, hold on there: natural selection is not always so simple. Older adults take care of their own as well as the extended family's offspring, providing a mechanism for selection.
- londons_explore 7y agoIt's also negative natural selection if Aunt Anna is very old, can barely walk, is losing her mind, yet still eats all the food the children grow ...
- rjurney 7y agoFor a short time but caring for the sick has benefits overall and granny had years of productivity after fertility.