5 ms·
Before we had separate ports and cables for power, USB and Thunderbolt. There was no way to plug the wrong cable in the wrong port. With USB-C, we still have s
by pavlov 7y ago
Before we had separate ports and cables for power, USB and Thunderbolt. There was no way to plug the wrong cable in the wrong port.
With USB-C, we still have separate cables for these three types, but they all look confusingly the same. Not convinced this is an improvement.
- timw4mail 7y agoA fully-featured USB-C cable can be used for all of those functionalities, but the fact that there are lesser-featured cables is confusing, yes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- VBprogrammer 7y agoTo be fair, I've cut open pound store USB-B cables before only to discover that they contained literally 2 strands of copper (Or at least I hope it was copper). The idea that people are trying to sink 2 amps down that type of cable is a bit frightening. I guess the point I'm trying to make is, specs are great, but the reality is that there are infinitely many types of cable and the only thing which definitively defines the capabilities is physics.
- KirinDave 7y agoEven bad USB cables are gonna have total resistances below 150mΩ, and that's including contact resistance on both ends. Unless you're shorting the cable inside the contacts (you do short pins to make USB deliver power, but upstream ports gotta spec for shorts anyways), even bad cables are unlikely to be a severe risk. The nice part of DC is you get to use the entire cross section of the wire. So 2A at 5V isn't gonna start too many fires even on thin wire. Now hopefully we don't see too many folks start using USB-PD 3 with crappy but compliant cables, as my comfort with DC drops as we go up into 20V 5A territory.
- fortran77 7y agoThis isn’t quite right. High current at low voltages can start fires, too.
- KirinDave 7y agoThat's not really what anyone is talking about here. We're talking about if a USB cable itself could be an issue. For that to happen the cable would have to be shorted in a way that still coerced a USB upstream port to still deliver 2A. Even long and bad cables are going to have incredibly small resistances compared to any piece of electronics they're attached to that can make the USB port think that's okay. Which means that the majority of the energy dissipated in a USB short will likely be in the downstream electronics. You could probably use something besides copper and still have it be the minority of the resistance in a circuit that could get 2A. If a USB device gets more current than it's supposed to get, it difficult not to blame the upstream power port for providing so much under the conditions of a short or the downstream port for not being designed correctly. Furthermore, when people see USB cables with "only 2 strands of wire" these are power cables where the data pins are shorted with a resistor, which locks a USB port to a more modest 500mA. That's definitely fine.
- Filligree 7y agoIn fact, ohmic (i.e. reistance-based) heating is entirely independent of voltage; it depends only on amperage. Higher voltage is only dangerous inasmuch as it may increase the amperage.
- KirinDave 7y agoWhich is why I pointed out the resistance of the cable relative to the other components. It's not where you're going to get resistive heating unless it's a full short and that's the dominant resistor. You may know, but USB-PD has a pretty smart design here that makes it harder for such a condition to occur. I refers to the 5/20V fear only in terms of how safe I feel about handling such voltages.
- arghwhat 7y agoJust to be entirely clear: While a cheap cable may be wrong, good (i.e. fully featured) cables will always work in all combinations. Having gone all in on Type-C, I have only ever gotten a "bad" cable as a cheap charge cable, and have never had issues with cable incompatibilities.
- nemetroid 7y ago> Just to be entirely clear: While a cheap cable may be wrong, good (i.e. fully featured) cables will always work in all combinations. Per the spec, yes. But devices may have hardware design issues making this untrue, as in the article. As I understand it, the Pi 4 works correctly with cheaper cables, but not with more expensive ones: > When combined with more capable cables (handling SuperSpeed data, or 5A power) this configuration will cause compliant chargers to provide 0V instead of 5V to the Pi.
- arghwhat 7y ago> But devices may have hardware design issues making this untrue, as in the article. Yes, but defective devices do not really go into the USB-C complexity consideration. They go into the trash bin. We can't blame USB-C for people disregarding the spec, especially as this is not a hard part of it. We can only blame it for the fact that we do have different "classes" of devices, where the main way out is to only get the highest class. Having run all-USB-C (and not using Apple products) for a few years now, I have never myself bumped into a product that was defective. Everything always worked as advertised.
- 59nadir 7y agoUSB-C in general was a pointless evolution of something no one had an issue with, IMO. It's as if someone looked at the state of things and said "Where can I invent an issue and solve it?".
- tracker1 7y agoI disagree on this... USB-C the connector, is great... having more than 2 varieties of feature/cabling alignment is pretty ridiculous. I get the need/desire for a cheaper option... I even kind of get the cheapest by default... but with USBC the cables should have been limited to lowest and highest spec, with maybe a DOT for one or the other on the end next to the USB logo indicating as much.