3 ms·
I agree that this is a widespread problem in many areas but I do think there’s a strong argument that bots are worth singling out in the context of social netwo
by acdha 7y ago
I agree that this is a widespread problem in many areas but I do think there’s a strong argument that bots are worth singling out in the context of social networking, where the bots are often used to steer public opinion in non-obvious ways with no clear ownership. It’s one thing if Samsung’s support chat-bot is misleading but that at least is obviously linked to the company in question whereas, say, the fake Twitter accounts complaining about Nike using photo stolen from real people aren’t easily associated with whoever is pushing that campaign and the intention is clearly to shift public opinion. There are good arguments for preserving anonymity but banning misrepresentation seems more defensible.
(I mentioned the Nike thing not because this is limited to conservatives but because that was the most recent example which came to mind: there were a bunch of well-promoted tweets from accounts using profile pictures of attractive young women which a quick tineye search showed were long-running Instagram users under different names)
- ethbro 7y agoThe other issue with bots is whether a company's support is bot-only or human. Free choice and all, but without disclosure (pre-purchase) a company shouldn't be able to "cost manage" their support function by using an algorithm fronted by chatbots.
- sokoloff 7y agoShould they have to disclose that their phone system has an IVR before every purchase as well? That they use a third-party logistics provider to handle returns?
- ethbro 7y agoUtilizing algorithmic-only customer support seems far more impactful than those technologies, from a customer standpoint. As Google and PayPal have shown, it's generally a cluster$&#* (at best), even with state of the art technologies. Furthermore, it provides a fundamental shift in the power dynamic by removing the possibility of whistleblowers and ethical counterpressure. You literally have management as the sole arbiter of algorithmic settings, with (currently) no legal disclosure requirements as to any internals. That seems pretty screwed up from a free-market, transparency perspective.
- acdha 7y agoOnly if they pretend that you're interacting with real people. An IVR is often bad customer service but it's clear what you're dealing with.
- jjoonathan 7y agoNah, those with an IVR should be summarily shot. Kidding, of course. Mostly. Disclosing IVRs before purchase would be a good start. Preferably with a legally mandated recognizable logo that customers can quickly learn to associate with terrible support.
- acdha 7y agoYeah, I'd also back laws banning a lot of the no-recourse situations companies cost-minimize you into but that'd also want to account for, say, having you talk to people who are under strict instructions not to help you or tell you why. (Once Verizon tried to charge me an ETF despite being a couple of years out of contract. The phone support was horrible and I thought it might have just been an English fluency issue but then I called the executive office and the person who fixed my bill just casually volunteered that the people in the first-tier call centers cannot in any way reverse charges or escalate to people who can, and aren't allowed to say that. They understood the question but their jobs were literally on the line if they told you that they couldn't help.)