3 ms·
This is ridiculous. The replacement fertility rate to maintain population before modern medicine could be closer to ten than two not so long ago. War, famine,
by colechristensen 7y ago
This is ridiculous.
The replacement fertility rate to maintain population before modern medicine could be closer to ten than two not so long ago.
War, famine, disease, accidents, and infant mortality made it so surviving until you were old enough to start having your own children was rare and women were often pregnant or nursing continuously as long as they were fertile.
The premise of heritable fertility driving population and reproduction rates in humans is really far off. We're not having litters of kittens.
If it were true fertility rates could not possibly have dropped so far in so few generations after modern medicine and the insane reduction in violent death rates seen in the last thousand years.
- barry-cotter 7y ago> The premise of heritable fertility driving population and reproduction rates in humans is really far off. Yes, until reliably accessible contraception fertility was driven by the desire to have sex. > If it were true fertility rates could not possibly have dropped so far in so few generations after modern medicine and the insane reduction in violent death rates seen in the last thousand years. This assumes no change in the environment, when it has manifestly changed. In this new environment in which desire to have children leads to having more children, on average, the desire to have more children will be selected for.
- ema 7y agoI agree, however this doesn't necessarily mean that average fertility will rise again. The environment could keep changing faster than the genes can adapt. Also "desire to have children" might be difficult to encode in DNA so genetic adaptation to the availability of contraceptives might be really slow.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 7y agoThis is the strongest (only?) counterargument I've seen. I don't believe it will happen soon though. Politicians only do something when doing something is less controversial than doing nothing and that's pretty far off.
- DissidentSci 7y agoYou do not understand evolution. Get yourself a copy of "Beak of the Finch".
- nudq 7y ago> You do not understand evolution Probably. But although it is almost tautological that fertility is heritable, it doesn't follow that the first world infertility trend will reverse. If whatever is causing first world infertility (1) actually profits from our infertility and (2) is some kind of evolving entity itself, we could find ourselves in an evolutionary arms race, and lose.
- dTal 7y agoAn insightful point. The tacit assumption here is that your "whatever" is some sort of meme, yes? But memes are also strongly heritable. So far, in all of human history, memes which promote celibacy and childlessness have a tendency to die out.