6 ms·
That will be a fun one to interpret. So if I use autocorrect, am I a bot? What if the device makes next word suggestions and I use them? What if the device sugg
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
That will be a fun one to interpret. So if I use autocorrect, am I a bot? What if the device makes next word suggestions and I use them? What if the device suggests the entire post, but I manually approve it? What if it suggests five separate posts and I approve them all at once?
- asutekku 7y agoI wouldn’t classify that as a bot as there’s still human interaction required.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSo a bot farm is fine as long as you have a human intern there rubber stamping whatever content it generates?
- freefolks 7y agoAs long as it is fully disclosed that your bots are bots.
- spiznnx 7y agoI think this is generally how election texting campaigns work, in terms of human interaction required when I once tried it, due to laws against robocampains. A real human has to press a button for each text sent and then receive any replies. Probably for online, similarly one post would be allowed for each individual human approval, unless you ad the bot disclaimer.
- croon 7y agoAm I missing something or wouldn't you need one real human per bot for rubberstamping? I'm sure this is targetting bots pretending to be humans that do not exist. If you want to be personally responsible with your real face and name for everything your singular bot writes, that would still solve nearly all current bot problems.
- wccrawford 7y agoI'm pretty sure I could hit at least 2 keys repeatedly without any problems. I would probably hit keys on 4 actual keyboards without too much trouble. If I made custom keyboards with just a few choices each, I think I could probably handle half a dozen without any problems. And if I'm literally just always telling the bot "okay, go" with 1 button, I think I could handle dozens.
- croon 7y agoI think you completely missed my point. I'm not talking about practical ability, but liability. Who would those bots be? wccrawford1, wccrawford2, wccrawford3? That would not pretend to be anything other than bots or clone accounts. If on the other hand your bots would be "Brock Samson", "Joey America" and "Chip Dipsby", etc. That would clearly be non-humans pretending to be humans, regardless of you tripping the first/last domino piece.
- wccrawford 7y agoSo if every one of my bots was named Brock Samson, even though that's not my name, that would be okay? If I had live people answering, but their names were randomized, would that not be okay? I honestly don't see any real difference between naming the bots like that. Yes, some people will be less likely to think they're bots if they're all named differently. But the vast majority of people will not notice if they get contacted by several different employees/bots all named Brock Samson. Most people won't even talk to more than 1 employee in a short timeframe to even have a chance to know there was a difference.
- bengotow 7y agoReminds me of those election SMS messages. /Technically/ a human presses send on every single message so it doesn't meet the definition of SMS spam, but for all practical purposes it is.
- afiori 7y agoA nice test to implement would be that if the function of the human operator can be replaced by a dumb bot, then it is functionally a bot.
- pixl97 7y agoHeh, I'm afraid that might reclassify a large portion of the workforce that falls under the saying "I can replace you with a simple shell script"
- floatingatoll 7y ago1) No, proofreading is not authorship. 2,3,4) A judge could reasonably find that you were attempting to circumvent the law and declare all of these as “bot”. The judicial system will not specify in writing complete coverage for every loophole. Judges can, regardless, find you guilty.
- spiznnx 7y agoRelated: The TCPA[0] disallows automated text messages, but using software[1] to help you text individual people more rapidly is legal[2]. [0] https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-tcpa-protection-against-robo-calls-prerecorded-calls.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-tcpa-protection-... [1] https://www.hustle.com/ https://www.hustle.com/ [2] https://abc7news.com/politics/campaigns-are-texting-voters-out-of-the-blue----and-its-perfectly-legal/3457119/ https://abc7news.com/politics/campaigns-are-texting-voters-o...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> 1) No, proofreading is not authorship. It is when the substitution is both context-aware and not what you intended to write. > 2,3,4) A judge could reasonably find that you were attempting to circumvent the law and declare all of these as “bot”. Wait, so if someone sends you a question and the suggestions can detect from the context your answer, you're a bot because you chose the suggestion instead of typing out words with the same meaning? Then aren't most people texting going to have to declare themselves bots? > The judicial system will not specify in writing complete coverage for every loophole. Judges can, regardless, find you guilty. "Judges will decide something" is no help to you when you're trying to predict what they will decide ahead of time. Finding out after the fact does a fat lot of good after you've already engaged in the behavior in question and an unfavorable ruling puts you in jail.
- floatingatoll 7y agoAssistive texting is covered in a separate reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20360152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20360152 The law clearly targets automated content creation that is not declared as such, not assistive writing technologies, and this will be considered by the judicial system when evaluating your stated intentions and actual actions. If you are unable to predict with confidence the outcome of your intentions and actions as they may be interpreted by the judicial system, please seek legal counsel for further guidance.
- sushid 7y agoI'm not sure why you're being so facetious. In fact, I wonder why HN always has comments like these. Lawmakers are purposefully vague because judges can decipher what the spirit of the law is and fine corporations or condone specific use cases when they are brought up in court. You can't go into court to challenge a law with hypothetical cases for a good reason. Do you want lawmakers to arbitrarily impose constraints like only 10% of non article words can be suggested per message composition or only 2 posts per minute are allowed? It is a fact in life that technology changes and improves things beyond what we could have foreseen in just a few years. The degree of flexibility built into these laws is a huge plus. Not a flaw.
- dorgo 7y ago>I wonder why HN always has comments like these It's a work related disease. A coder must consider all corner cases in advance. There is no judge to decipher the spirit of a program.
- MrGilbert 7y agoslight-OT: Yes, it is. Which is frustrating in itself. In general, I've developed a strategy: Me: "So, what should the program do when XYZ occurs?" Marketing: "Uhm... Dunno, haven't thought about it. I'd decide by, you know, gut instinct. We haven't thought about that yet." Me: implements a virtual coin-flip using Random.Next() Once you've done that, it's easier.
- ryandrake 7y agoOr, file a bug for each corner case, mark it release-blocking, and assign to whoever is responsible for the requirements.
- CGamesPlay 7y agoIf you're interested in actually shipping, a more helpful approach is to choose the simplest behavior to implement, notify the requirements person that you've done that, and offer to create a release-blocking bug for the issue if that is unacceptable. Chances are, if the requirements person doesn't have an opinion on what the copy for the dialog should be if the customer is 65+ and it's a Tuesday in a month with 31 days, then it's because that choice doesn't really matter all that much.
- m1sta_ 7y agoI know this is going to sound disingenuous, but are you right-leaning politically?
- arendtio 7y agoHow do you come to that conclusion? Actually, he is just asking what the exact definition of a bot is (something every scientist should ask in this context).
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoHow about you try to comply with the spirit of the law?