3 ms·
> “Quantum trajectory theory makes predictions that are impossible to make with the standard formulation,” Devoret said. That is bullshit. If it were true, th
by lisper 7y ago
> “Quantum trajectory theory makes predictions that are impossible to make with the standard formulation,” Devoret said.
That is bullshit. If it were true, the predictions made by QTT would be tested and if they came out as predicted it would be the biggest news in physics since the Aspect experiment.
What is "going on" during wave function "collapse" has been known for decades: entanglement and decoherence. That's all.
I am really getting sick and tired of these sensationalistic headlines.
(I'm also not entirely sober. It is the Fourth of July after all.)
- Misdicorl 7y agoHear hear. These articles and really entire subfield of 'physics' appears to be philosophy trying to masquerade as a real science
- dwaltrip 7y ago> What is "going on" during wave function "collapse" has been known for decades: entanglement and decoherence. That's all. Wasn't it a famous physicist who said "If you think you understand Quantum Mechanics then you don't understand Quantum Mechanics"? I'm not defending this article, but I was under the impression that the proper interpretation of quantum mechanics / QFT is far from a settled matter among physicists.
- MereInterest 7y agoIt's not so much that it is settled as everybody knows that it isn't a useful topic of conversation. All the various interpretations have the same math behind them, give the same prediction, and have the same observable behavior. Since there isn't anything to distinguish them, they are all equally valid. In practice, things tend to go with the "Shut up and calculate"[1] philosophy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics#shutup https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mec...
- dwaltrip 7y agoI've heard that idiom, and I'm sure it has its use. I don't think we should stop calculating, by any means. However, there are individuals in the field who think new insights are possible through continued attempts to improve our interpretations (in addition to continued development of the theory as expressed through robust math). I don't have a source handy, but I've heard the physicist Sean Carroll express this idea on his podcast, Mindscape. Numbers by themselves don't mean anything (for humans at least). The meaning is found in how the numbers relate to the concepts that we make use of.
- lisper 7y agoIt is legitimate to ask how our everyday perceptions can be so radically and fundamentally different from what the math appears to say about the nature of reality. "Shut up and calculate" is not a legitimate answer. (For the record, the phrase "Shut up and calculate" was coined by David Mermin as a pejorative characterization of the Copenhagen interpretation, which actually says simply that we cannot know anything more than what the math says, and that's just the way it is, and any attempt at further inquiry is doomed to fail and therefore should not be attempted. It's a deeply unscientific attitude.)
- charlieflowers 7y agoI read statements from Feynman that I interpreted as very similar. He said things like: the question "what is the underlying reality behind all this" probably "has no meaning." I never understood what he was trying to say.
- lisper 7y ago> Wasn't it a famous physicist who said "If you think you understand Quantum Mechanics then you don't understand Quantum Mechanics"? No. That's an apocryphal quote. Richard Feynman said in 1965, " I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics." It turns out it wasn't true even when Feynman said it, and it's certainly not true today. Feynman's problem is that he was committed to the idea that particles are real. They aren't [1]. There are a lot of arguments over the proper interpretation of QM but it turns out that when you get to the bottom of things they are all saying the same things using different terminology. [1] https://aapt.scitation.org/doi/10.1119/1.4789885 https://aapt.scitation.org/doi/10.1119/1.4789885 (also https://arxiv.org/pdf/1204.4616.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1204.4616.pdf)
- cygx 7y agoEntanglement and decoherence only solve the collapse problem if you subscribe to the many-worlds interpretation (or something equivalent).
- lisper 7y agoThat's kind of like saying that Maxwell's equations solve the luminiferous aether problem only if you subscribe to relativity (or something equivalent).
- cygx 7y agoMore like solving the hard problem of consciousness via appeals to a world soul: It requires commitment to certain unfalsifiable metaphysical assumptions.
- lisper 7y ago> It requires commitment to certain unfalsifiable metaphysical assumptions. Like what? "Multiple worlds" does not require a commitment to the reality of multiple worlds (the misleading rhetoric notwithstanding). (Everett never called it "multiple worlds", he called it "relative state", which is IMHO much less misleading.)
- cygx 7y agoEverett never called it "multiple worlds", he called it "relative state", which is IMHO much less misleading Also note that Everett's dissertation was titled The Theory of the Universal Wave Function, which puts a different emphasis on the thing as well. He did believe in quantum immortality, though, and assumed the alternate 'worlds' were real. That's the standard interpretation of MWI: While there's just a single wave function, it factors into 'branches' entangling measurement results and states of consciousness, with all the different versions of yourself coexisting in a realist sense. However, as these branches tend to no longer interact, that's an unfalsifiable claim.
- 7y ago
- DagAgren 7y agoSo, I am not quite up to date on the latest views on QM in general, but how do entanglement and decoherence explain, for instance, doing a double-slit experiment, sending a particle through, and getting a dot on the screen? What goes on there?
- lisper 7y agoStart here: http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf or, if you prefer a video, http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
- charlieflowers 7y agoBoth of those links are the same. Both PDF's, no video.
- lisper 7y agoSorry. Try https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc
- DagAgren 7y agoI was more hoping to have a discussion about it.