3 ms·
There have been many times, over student, young professional, research staff, and startup years, that I would've killed for what was effectively a clean, safe,
by neilv 7y ago
There have been many times, over student, young professional, research staff, and startup years, that I would've killed for what was effectively a clean, safe, peaceful, stable hotel room-sized place of my own.
Living in a high cost of living city (where the opportunity is), when you can't actually afford basic minimum housing, but manage to swing something anyway, often means a lot of sacrifices of what should be basics. And your finances are probably still getting strained, despite the sacrifices.
There've been times that converting a van or class B RV, and shifting it to a new city parking spot every night, seemed safer and more stable than bottom-end city apartment situations. I sympathize with and admire the Bay Area dotcom workers who managed to do something like that, in a recent HN post.
That said, we're seeing things here like new micro-apartment developments being pitched to relatively affluent new grads, at ridiculously high prices for what you get, with some lifestyle story. That seems more an investment ROI solution for the developer, not a housing and social justice solution.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ido 7y agoWhy not share an apartment? I had great (and bad, but also great) experiences with roommates between ages 19 and 28 (when my then girlfriend, now wife, moved in with me). I could (and intermittently have) afford to live in my own but the social benefits of roommates were worth it.
- yakshaving_jgt 7y agoNever met an introvert?
- puranjay 7y agoI had bad experiences with roommates early on and swore off sharing a house with anyone when I was in my early 20s. This meant that often a big part of my income would just go to housing. In a way, it helped since it pushed me to pick up side projects and learn new, marketable skills. But man, if I had access to a clean, affordable room + kitchen, I would have had a far happier and more social time in my 20s.
- tempguy9999 7y agoNever shared a room but problems with flatmates, I recall a few. One offering to stab you? Yup! Another nearly burning the place down by forgetting a chip pan? BTDT (and then he did that a 2nd time!). On a lesser scale people who don't seem to understand what washing up means, or that loud noises travel. It's not nice but - stabbies and fires aside, that was unusual - dealing with difficult people is part of life and you learn some useful skills. The other side is you do meet really, really good people. That IMO outweighs the bad.
- agent008t 7y agoIt is amazing to me that slums can even exist in a high cost of living city, where land is so expensive. You would have thought that given how scarce (expensive) the land is, it would be used most efficiently, with all buildings tending to be in top-notch condition and everywhere being fairly tidy and safe. Basically, if you are the owner of a slum, it seems like it should make economic sense to sell the land to someone else as the value of the land would be higher than the value of the slum. Why is the market not resulting in what I described?
- jvln 7y agoAs I see it - the land is owned by the city and city is lobbied by other landlords to keep all the crimes in a closed teritory. If you dismantle slums the people will spread all over the city and the crimes will follow.
- 0815test 7y agoSlums are due to insecure property rights, basically. You can't sell the land if you don't have anything approaching formal title to it, and for the same reason you aren't going to invest in high-quality housing or amenities. (Note that "property rights" need not be understood in a conventional sense! Indeed, long-term leases are far preferable to simple property in land, precisely because they do get rid of some residual uncertainty and market friction.)
- austhrow743 7y agoThere's the financial appeal but also when you're a busy young person, the value of a lot of space just isn't very high. At least for me anyway. I house sat for some friends in my early twenties for a year. Two story house, pool, big yard. I never once used the yard or pool. My relationship to them were that they were maintenance expenses. Most rooms in the house went completely unused. Hell, the rooms I did use were inconveniently large, increased the area I needed to clean. The only thing I preferred about it over my previous and current places of living was lack of housemates. Unfortunately the premium you pay, at least here, to go from 1 to 0 housemates is doubling your rent. In fact last time I was looking, there were more two/three bedroom houses than studio apartments within the "as cheap as I can get while still living alone" criteria I was searching. I'd love for cheap micro-apartments to become widespread.