3 ms·
Better idea: pay people on Mechanical Turk 10¢ each to bash your idea. You'll get 200 people's feedback instead of 5 from the Starbucks. If even only 1 out of
by colanderman 16y ago
Better idea: pay people on Mechanical Turk 10¢ each to bash your idea. You'll get 200 people's feedback instead of 5 from the Starbucks. If even only 1 out of every 30 takes the job seriously, you'll get a better bang for your buck.
- nobody_nowhere 16y agoInteresting -- have you done this successfully?
- colanderman 16y agoNo, but this person has: http://harperlindsey.com/2010/09/01/how-i-used-amazons-mechanical-turk-to-validate-my-startup-idea/ http://harperlindsey.com/2010/09/01/how-i-used-amazons-mecha...
- nobody_nowhere 16y agocool, thanks!
- rhizome 16y agoThis is an excellent idea! There couldn't be a more random assortment of internet users and if the rest of the internet is any indication they'll be more than happy to be describe using a website. The way they phrase their descriptions will tell you a lot about what they find significant, annoying, or simply what they don't even mention, e.g. not clicking on a link to a page that you spent 30hrs on. Call it a learning experience. :) I think a lot of people are, like us, commonly frustrated by UX decisions and would love to have some input on the subject, even if it's for a nobody. The number of $20-iTunes-card focus group ads on Craigslist seems to support this. Part and parcel to this (and MT) is that anybody can be successful On The Internet, so random strangers will give you the benefit of the doubt that you could indeed be the next Zappos guy (don't say you're the next Zappos guy), optimistically speaking.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoRecent post: Mechanical Turk is broken. Feedback is no better than random. People are gaming it, so no value left.
- daleharvey 16y agoI have used a mechanical turk tool to do usability testing, this type of qualitative feedback would probably not do very well on there. People doing mechanical turk have one goal, to complete your task as fast as humanly possible, even when laid out fairly concrete steps you end up with a lot of feedback that isnt necessarily useful, either because they purposefully skipped it or there was communication issues or they just decided it wasnt time efficient. I know mechanical turk has a feedback mechanism, but there is so much signal to noise that we found it much more useful to go and meet real people.