5 ms·
It can actually be better than this still. Cattle can be part of a solution to helping restore arid land where the soil has been destroyed by intensive farming
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
It can actually be better than this still. Cattle can be part of a solution to helping restore arid land where the soil has been destroyed by intensive farming and erosion. Healthy soil stores enormous amounts of biomass (aka carbon). Intensive farming has destroyed enormous amounts of land world-wide and turned it into desert, releasing lots of CO2 into the atmosphere.
This is a reversible process and catlle is part of the solution: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/jul/22/cows-climate-change https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/jul/22/cows-cli...
So, using large herds of cattle to refertilize bits of land that are currently not usable for agriculture would capture enormous amounts of carbon in the soil, restore the water retention capability of arid land, put a stop to large scale erosion of remaining soil, and restore it to productive land that may be used for growing food. Alternatively, once restored, you can sit back and watch the land reforest itself or use planned grazing to keep it as grassland. There's no actual need to manually plant trees; though it does probably speed up the process.
Finally, using cattle to fix land produces lots of nice organic/free range meat in a sustainable way as a side effects. And yes, cow farts have a green house effect but it is offset by the captured CO2 in the restored soil. Healthy soil has lots of biomass.
- cgh 7y agoYou are correct. Here's another link in support of what I think is highly counter-intuitive to people here: http://www.dasnr.okstate.edu/Members/donald-stotts-40okstate.edu/carbon-sequestration-a-positive-aspect-of-beef-cattle-grazing-grasslands http://www.dasnr.okstate.edu/Members/donald-stotts-40okstate...
- senorjazz 7y agoIs this actually validated? Living in an area heavily deforested for cattle grazing, the cattle grazed land does not look like a healthy land. The cattle keep all plant life cut right back. Hot sun can easily access the soil drying it out, then when heavy rains come, the top soil all runs off the land. Land that is left without cattle fares better, land that is actively reforested and trees helped to get established looks infinitely more healthy.
- wlib 7y agoI'm on my phone in the country side with slow internet so I cant look up a link, but if I remember correctly, you should search "Alan Savory TED Talk" on youtube for an introduction to the use of livestock to reclaim land. Essentially, the issue with most livestock grazing is that it does not mimic natural grazing, which is a seasonal, high volume, high density event where the herd moves on and allows the grazed area time to recover.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> Alan Savory TED Talk I'm no expert, but I would approach this with extreme caution. There are a lot of replies that he is "misleading", "wrong", "dead wrong" etc.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThere are also quite a few projects where this has been shown to get results in the real world. Enough that it's probably worth trying to replicate the results. Worst case it fails and you hopefully learn something.
- barry-cotter 7y agoThe effects of having cattle/area constant over time are very different from having it change a lot cyclically. Flora, fauna and soil health will all be a lot better if you rotate a large herd over a large area, as a herd, than if they just roam freely the whole time. With a lot of cattle in a small area for a short time the ground will get chewed up and manure will be quite thoroughly mixed in. Leaving long periods in between this treatment means there’s a strong root system though so if the land isn’t grazed again for a long time it recovers well. The closer you approximate hordes of buffalo, aurochs or wildebeest thundering over the plains the closer you’re going to get to savannah/prairie/tundra. http://www.econtalk.org/moises-velasquez-manoff-on-cows-carbon-farming-and-climate-change/ http://www.econtalk.org/moises-velasquez-manoff-on-cows-carb... > Journalist and author Moises Velasquez-Manoff talks about the role of dirt in fighting climate change with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. Velasquez-Manoff explains how changes in farming can allow dirt and plants to absorb carbon and potentially reduce climate change.
- gdubs 7y agoHealthy grazed pasture can sequester carbon, but ultimately we need to let a lot of land go back into natural forest to address the scale of th problem. Source: “The Carbon Farming Solution”
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt can actually be better than this still. Urban forestry is also a thing, so we don't actually have to exclude urban environments. We can increase the number of trees within city limits as well. Some resources: https://www.fs.fed.us/managing-land/urban-forests/ucf https://www.fs.fed.us/managing-land/urban-forests/ucf https://www.americanforests.org/magazine/article/vibrant-cities-lab/ https://www.americanforests.org/magazine/article/vibrant-cit...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m_mueller 7y agoDoes this offset the methane produced by cattle?
- marak830 7y agoI'm sorry I don't have a link I'm on mobile, but there have been some studies recently that showed putting seaweed into their diet reduced the methan production by a lot (80% iirc). How you would manage that with the above plan is beyond me though :-)
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYes; don't have a reference available but healthy soil mostly consists of biomass compared to arid land which is mostly sand. The process of returning arid land back to healthy soil involves a lot of carbon capture in the form of dead plants, bacteria, root systems, fungi, etc. I've heard numbers suggestion this can be 70-80% of the mass and it builds up over time to form deep layers. Another issue is that N2O forms when urine and manure are mixed; which is common with intensive cattle farming. This happens a lot less when cattle is roaming around and instead this helps fertilize the land and stimulates growth; it's actually good for the land. So, compared to growing cattle indoors and feeding them with the wrong food that is typically also produced using intensive farming, there's a big difference.