6 ms·
The problem here is that "hacking techniques" to a black hat are also, equal-and-oppositely, legitimate security research and prevention -- to a white hat / sec
by peter_d_sherman 7y ago
The problem here is that "hacking techniques" to a black hat are also, equal-and-oppositely, legitimate security research and prevention -- to a white hat / security researcher / ethical hacker...
In other words, they're aspects of the same thing...
The idea that you're going to ban something because one aspect of it has a negative social purpose is philosophically unsound... We don't ban videos on electricity or electrical engineering because people can be electrocuted... We don't ban videos on chainsaws because they could be used to cut a person in half... We don't ban videos on cars because they could be used to run people over... Everything in the universe can be used for a positive or negative purpose, when you start banning things because some people use these things for negative purposes, you misunderstand that those effects are caused by the actor, not the information and/or the tool that's being used...
- username444 7y agoIronically, I tracked the real world identity of someone using stolen credit cards in my ecom site BECAUSE he posted a tutorial/how-to on YouTube showing the vulnerability tool (script kiddie), under his real name. SMH. This won't stop this information from being disseminated, but it may save some idiots from themselves.
- koheripbal 7y agoIt would be ironic if Youtube did this because they were tired of fulfilling warrants from governments over authors of these videos
- paulcole 7y ago> The idea that you're going to ban something because one aspect of it has a negative social purpose is philosophically unsound Uh, guns?
- rmellow 7y agoIf you meant to stay on topic (reads like a tangent), I believe firearm videos are still kosher on Youtube. Look up FPSRussia.
- girvo 7y agoIf by kosher, you mean "allowed, without monetisation, and under some arcane, opaque and onerous restrictions that mean you never know if this video will get you a strike or not", then yeah, they are
- scrollaway 7y agoWe're not banning knives though, are we? Guns are different, and they're banned for the same reasons that, say, carrying around a bioweapon is banned. - Their primary purpose is to inflict harm. - The harm caused is potentially / easily lethal. - Their existence escalates nearly all situations. - They're dangerous items that can very easily cause accidental harm.
- gambiting 7y ago"we"? In the UK you are not allowed to carry a knife with you, unless you just bought one and are bringing to home or are a certified chief who needs one for work, or are going camping.
- ololobus 7y agoHmm, how is it actually regulated? So, e.g. if I am going to my friends and carrying a bottle of wine altogether with pocket knife bundled with a corkscrew to be sure I will be able to open it, then I am in a grey zone or even illegal?
- Veedrac 7y agoAs long as it's a small, non-locking pocket knife, you're fine. If it's larger, you're fine as long as you have a good reason (eg. needed for work).
- MertsA 7y agoThat's dangerous advice in many areas of the United States. In NYC if a police officer finds any kind of folding knife, regardless of how harmless, if he wants to arrest you he probably can under NYPD's absurd perversion of the law by considering it possession of a drop knife. If the officer can open the knife by holding it and flicking it open via inertia then he can arrest the victim for possession of a drop knife. They usually don't hold the handle to try and flick it open either, they'll hold it from the tip of the blade as that makes it very easy to just arrest anyone with a pocket knife. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15372404 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15372404 The first man mentioned in that article was convicted and sentenced to 6 years in prison on the sole charge of possession of this knife. https://www.amazon.com/Sheffield-12113-One-Hand-Opening-Lock-Back/dp/B0001WBSK8 https://www.amazon.com/Sheffield-12113-One-Hand-Opening-Lock...
- whowhatwhy 7y agoBanning guns is philosophically unsound, for the exact reasons this guy just listed. Look at Britian where they are now having unprecedented amounts of stabbings and are actually confiscating things like pliers and forks.
- AQuantized 7y agoI'm uncertain about this idea that increase in knife crime means gun control is pointless. I'd much rather get stabbed than shot given the differential in mortality. Even if all gun crimes were replaced with knife crimes the per capita homicide will be lower.
- 2Ccltvcm 7y agoGuns are loud even with a silencer. Knife crimes are easier to conceal in urban ambush situations.
- grumdan 7y agoIf that were such a big factor, then allowing guns wouldn't make a difference, as criminal could still choose to carry a knife for this reason.
- g00s3_caLL_x2 7y agoLook at Chicago for an example: It's one of the most restrictive states in the union on 'gun control' yet has some of the highest murder rates and death by guns across the board. Seems to have worked GREAT there!
- jammygit 7y agoI read years ago in a book about gangs that knife wounds lead to death far more often than gunshot wounds
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoYeah, guns are another example.
- czr 7y agoPopular hacking-related YouTube channel LiveOverflow has a nice discussion of the ban that addresses this very concern at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIdZ2oPyB1Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIdZ2oPyB1Y
- heyoni 7y agoWhat’s the gist of it? I can’t watch videos without headphones, my speaker is busted :/
- czr 7y agoThe video is captioned if you want. But the TL;DW is that there's an ethical spectrum of security content; on one end is sketchy content that has little educational value - like, say, a tutorial on how to make a phishing page - and on the other end is educational content that could be applied maliciously but isn't intended that way - like a general web programming tutorial (or a DefCon talk). YouTube seems justified in demonetizing or removing the former type of content, but the difference between these two types is not always obvious if you don't have a security background, and so it's expected that there will be some false positives / negatives in YouTube's filtering. In practice, educational content (from LiveOverflow, for example, and from the other security channels he knows) hasn't been banned, and the few false-positive bans appear to have been reverted quickly, so it seems like this is largely a non-issue. If YouTube actually starts blocking educational security content, and not being responsive to appeals, then this would worth being upset about, but right now it seems like a non-issue. (Note that YouTube has plenty of other problems; I'm just summarizing LiveOverflow's take on this particular controversy)
- heyoni 7y agoOh man thank you so much for that. Totally makes sense and glad live overflow won’t be (hopefully) affected. Videos aren’t working at all because the speakers on my phone are busted. On an iPhone, they won’t load even if the volume is set to 0. It has to have an output :(
- hartator 7y ago> We don't ban videos on electricity or electrical engineering because people can be electrocuted... We don't ban videos on chainsaws because they could be used to cut a person in half... We don't ban videos on cars because they could be used to run people over... Don’t give to YouTube too many ideas.
- redwall_hp 7y agoI think the real problem is the obsession with a centralized video silo, when internet video hasn't been "hard" for nigh on a decade. Chuck a video on a host (hell, Cloudfront is just an SFTP transfer away), and drop an HTML video tag onto a web page and you're done. Everyone who wants to run some sort of "channel" can trivially use cheap hosting and open syndication tools.
- tpetry 7y agoCloudfront may only be a transfer away but bandwidth pricing is so expensive you can not afford it for video streaming.