4 ms·
Governments should have predatory practice towards shareholders in these cases. If company can't be allowed to fail (strategically important or government regu
by nabla9 7y ago
Governments should have predatory practice towards shareholders in these cases.
If company can't be allowed to fail (strategically important or government regulated sector like banking) there should be 'fluid bankruptcy' option. When they default or fail their obligations, the next day the government owns them without operations being disrupted. Shareholders lose everything overnight and any private debt would have standard 50% haircut (lenders would know this beforehand). Government would then sell the stocks back to the market within 10 years or so.
Bailouts are subsidies for risk.
- bradleyjg 7y agoThere is a third group of people whose incentives towards risk need to be taken into account -- employees. When the government takes over the employees should be moved to the GS or SES schedules.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat might guarantee that the company remains a money-loser, dependent on the government forever.
- pinkfoot 7y agoWhat you will discover is that you soon have no systemically-important high-tech companies. For example, the excessive litigation in the 1970s against general aviation just led to Cessna and co. making planes designed in the 1940s.
- fendy3002 7y agoGovernment in my country will use that to take the shares, then do corruption from inside and fattening their wallets. Im against shareholder is immune because of bailout, but I don't think government handling business can be better.
- grenoire 7y agoAgreed, as little trust as you might have in stockholders, hold not much more for your government.
- disordinary 7y agoThat's sad. If you can't trust your government who you elected and represent you who do you trust? I trust my government and in the controls around it, even when parties that I didn't vote for were in power.
- FigBug 7y agoIsn't that pretty much what happened with GM? The stocks and bonds were all wiped out. And then the new GM was owned by the government / union until they did an IPO a few years later?
- kazen44 7y agothe same basically happened with the ABN AMRO bank in the Netherlands. Goverment did a bailout and turned the bank into a state owned enterprise until recently.
- w1nst0nsm1th 7y agoWith Fortis, in Belgium, the government bought back the bad loans and handed the remaining of the whole bank to BNP Paribas for 1€... There have been some kind of "understanding" betweens the finance minister of that time and a big belgian investor having stakes in BNP Paribas. Yseterday the same minister was elected President of the european Council.
- nabla9 7y agoYes, eventually. First the auto industry asked and revived $25 billion in TARP money and $5 billion in loans for auto industry suppliers. That was not enough and they asked another $25 billion and this time the government refused. Only after that GM and Chrysler went bankrupt.
- a_wild_dandan 7y agoFreakonomics did a wonderful episode on the subject of government bailouts/investment, Is the Government More Entrepreneurial Than You Think? [1]. One relevant quote: > MAZZUCATO: What the U.S. government actually did with Tesla was the opposite of what they should do. They said, thinking they were quite wise, “If you fail to pay back the loan, we get three million shares in your company.” And you have to ask yourself why all these Goldman Sachs guys who were in Obama’s government didn’t actually come through when they were needed, because they should have said the opposite: “If you do pay back the loan, we get three million shares.” And the price per share, when the loan was taken out in 2009, was $9 a share. When it was paid back in 2013, it was $90 a share. That difference multiplied by three million would have more than paid back the Solyndra loss and the next round. Then the question becomes: how do you share not only the risks but also the rewards? So we don’t get what we get with the banks, which is that when things go bad the state has to bail them out, and when things go well, the banks take the profits. [1] http://freakonomics.com/podcast/mariana-mazzucato/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/mariana-mazzucato/