6 ms·
I just realised that these 'influencers' sound a lot like professional beggars. They're successful at something, right? There's no need for them to beg like tha
by mcv 7y ago
I just realised that these 'influencers' sound a lot like professional beggars. They're successful at something, right? There's no need for them to beg like that, and they're presenting it as if they're doing you a favour while they do it.
- oblio 7y agoThere is a certain irony related to the "Support the Guardian" bit at the end of the article.
- ptah 7y agoThey are peculiar as they are owned by a trust, not a corporation so not profit driven
- coldtea 7y agoAre the journalists working there "profit driven"? Do they work for a salary, often lucrative, or do they write for free?
- mcv 7y agoAnd do they put in actual work and need to pay for food and rent?
- coldtea 7y agoWhat's "actual work"? How is writing more "actual" than shooting videos and doing photo shoots (which can be lots of hard work out in the field every day)? Influencers have built an audience, and are paid for ads and promotional deals. This sounds like professional work to me, especially since some are making 6+ figures. And of course they also need to pay for "food and rent". If it was about "actual" work, then those journalists in need of "support" could go do a job that actually pays, in a non declining industry.
- throwaway8879 7y agoI like your question about actual work. I suppose anything that helps pay the bills should count. So I definitely agree that bring a social media influencer should count as real or actual work. It's just that there's a "bad taste" element to the profession, similar to how people may react to selling MLM beauty products or Herbalife. I suppose Herbalife should count as actual work too, at least to the people who get sucked into selling the products. But I also see why restaurants/hotels and food vendors might react negatively to influencers who try to get free service in exchange for exposure that may or may not exist.
- mcv 7y agoI find this rather sad, as good journalism is vital for a healthy, free democracy. And yet we don't seem to have a good way to pay for it. In a capitalist system, entertainment is more profitable than news.
- coldtea 7y agoOn the other hand journalism has also been a weapon for controlling mass opinion, propaganda, and promoting particular interests, from the days of Hearst at least, to the WMD and all kinds of more subtle manipulation. I'd rather have a vibrant scene like the blogging of yore, with good voices rising to the top (or not), than large press interests and gatekeepers.
- t0astbread 7y agoBut blogs and entertainment can also be used as propaganda?
- coldtea 7y agoSure. But tv/press had an unfair advantage of being a gatekeeper, not offering a way for the public to respond (except for "letters to the editor" and such), having unique access to power figures, and so on. Blogs did away with most of that.
- 7y ago
- jpmoral 7y agoYou're conflating profit motive and working for money.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoMost Journalists salaries are a pittance.
- coldtea 7y agoCompared to programmers, maybe. Still much better than most available middle class gigs, and the "sky is the limit" once they have connections to power and influence.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoNot as much as you would think - I recall an ex Journalist who went into PR telling me that the deputy editor of the Scotsman was receiving income support (the benefit that toped up your income if you had a low family income)
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThe Guardian Might Not be but GMG is and the new editor is trying improved the Guardians Finances so it breaks even.
- benj111 7y agoIrony like the Alanis Morrisette song? (ie not ironic at all). The Guardian are asking the readership to support the articles, you'll note they paid for their own icecream.'Influencers' are asking the subjects to fund the articles. One is advertising, one is journalism. I'll backtrack slightly on that last sentence, advertising/sponsorship can work for certain things, in general though its a big conflict of interest.
- mcv 7y agoNo need to backtrack. If the person/company/brand you're writing about is also the one paying you to write about them, that is exactly advertising. It's not news.
- benj111 7y agoI backtracked because of all the possible exceptions. If a gaming magazine reviews a game they didn't pay for, or what about car reviewers buying cars they didn't pay for. These are generally referred to as journalism. Then there's sponsorship, what if 'green' company sponsors green content, or a vegan company sponsors an article about the bad things about industrial meat production. So I not sure its completely black and white.
- ptah 7y agokind of like "come and play guitar at my bar without pay for the exposure"
- coldtea 7y agoOnly in this case, it actually works, as there are firms (even international brands) paying influencers top dollars for mentioning their products. So more like "come play at Max's Kansas City without pay for the exposure" -- tons of bands would have jumped at the chance. It's just that not all influencers have equal reach (and not all businesses need the extra promotion. Nike can always sell more shoes, but an ice cream stand might have to push people away if they have too many customers, as there's so many a person can serve).
- hjk05 7y agoActually it’s the other way around. “If you let me, I’ll play at your bar for free beer”. The influencers are selling advertisement for cheap. And it’s the same deal as with musicians, it’s a good deal which is mutually beneficiary if the talent is there, if not, we’ll then you laugh at the offer and try to publicly humiliate the person trying to establish a place for themselves. “Can you believe this guy wanted to play at my bar, AND expected free beer? What a joke”.
- jacobush 7y agoWhen you have a bunch every day, who can barely hold the guitar or sing a tune, posing like they are Led Zeppelin if they can just have a free beer... yeah I might snap too after a while.
- robjan 7y agoAre the advertisements cheap though? Half of the influencers who have approached my businesses have obviously paid for most of their followers and their "advert" would be unlikely to result in any conversions.
- traderjane 7y agoThat’s on the business to judge of course, as are all deals. Isn’t it on the business to model marketing effectiveness?
- coldtea 7y ago>They're successful at something, right? There's no need for them to beg like that, and they're presenting it as if they're doing you a favour while they do it. Isn't that the very thing they're successful at? Getting deals and stuff for free in exchange of their pretty little faces promoting it to their fans.
- thecatspaw 7y agoYes, and if they are good enough, they result in a net gain for the other party as well.
- mnky9800n 7y agothey are the instagram version of those backpackers with shitty cardboard signs begging for money so they can keep up their "spiritual journey across different cultures" or whatever nonsense they claim to pursue.
- me_me_me 7y agoNo they are not, 'backpackers' wants to go on a journey and will thank you for your money. They don't promises nor demand anything from you.
- tedmiston 7y agoIf they are successful, then their posts are worth more than $4 so they wouldn't be eager to trade one for an ice cream cone.
- bradleyjg 7y agoI don't think it's quite the same. The influencers are at least purporting to offer a trade value for value. Maybe they aren't actually offering value, maybe some of them are even knowingly not providing value, but that's fraud not begging. A beggar says give me something because I want it without even a pretense of offering anything in exchange.