6 ms·
Anybody can do a little bit to help insects. It ranges from planting a pot of some flowers, to building an insect hotel, to switching to a more natural lawn or
by adrianN 7y ago
Anybody can do a little bit to help insects. It ranges from planting a pot of some flowers, to building an insect hotel, to switching to a more natural lawn or talking to your city council to replace parts of the lawns in parks with more insect friendly meadows.
However, I don't see how I as consumer can choose agricultural products that are friendlier to insects. Organic agriculture also uses pesticides and monocultures. Reducing one's meat intake is always a good idea, but other than that how can I judge the impact my food choices have on biodiversity?
- arethuza 7y agoLocal councils in England are reducing the amount of grass cutting they do on verges of roads - so more flowers (presumably good for insects) and cheaper! https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-48772448 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-48772448
- ahje 7y ago> Reducing one's meat intake is always a good idea Actually, areas used for grazing usually have more diversity, more flowers and thereby more insects, compared to something like a similarly sized wheat field.
- perfunctory 7y agoUnfortunately most meat does not come from grazing animals. And if we were to convert the whole meat industry into grazing we wouldn't be able to produce meat in the same quantity, which would mean exactly reduced meat intake for everyone.
- ahje 7y agoThat's definitely true. Factory farming is definitely an issue, and in more ways than one. My point is that we need grazing cattle too, since we (as a species) took the liberty of wiping out most of the naturally occurring grazers and thereby wrecked the balance. The "easy" way would be to limit the spread of humanity in order to reduce the load on the ecosystem, but that would result in numerous demographic issues instead. Fun times ahead!
- adrianN 7y agoBuying meat from animals that actually saw the sun before they were killed is usually a good way of drastically reducing your meat intake because it's much more expensive that what you usually find at your local supermarket.
- q3k 7y agoIt's not that difficult or expensive in Germany (and most of Europe), though.
- plufz 7y agoWouldn’t consuming dairy products still be a better choice than meat in that case? (atleast if we are talking about cows and sheep, since I don’t think more climate friendly meat like chickens and pigs adds that much to biodiversity)
- uoylj 7y agoMeat from grazing animals has a lot of additional positive effects re. biodiversity, and preventing desertification. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpTHi7O66pI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpTHi7O66pI (How to green the world's deserts and reverse climate change | Allan Savory)
- usrusr 7y agoBut how much meat comes from grazing? Factory farming livestock is a major consumer of monoculture crops.
- pletnes 7y agoA lot. Large parts of the world’s «farm area» is land used for grazing and may not be suitable for monoculture farming. I don’t know if this applies to the meat found in your particular neighbourhood, though.
- ab71e5 7y agoThat just means a high percentage of the area is used for grazing, but I believe OP was asking how much of the total meat produced (by weight?) comes from grazing.
- esarbe 7y agoYou can feed ten times as many people with the wheat that grows on a similarly sized wheat field. Or keep feeding just one person and turn the rest into a meadow with flowers, bushes, hedges and trees. Imagine that.
- _Microft 7y agoFor the ones interested, here's something in Wikipedia about this topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophic_level https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophic_level https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_efficiency#Ten_percent_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_efficiency#Ten_perc...
- dTal 7y agoYou can't, because "man cannot live off bread alone". Wheat lacks many basic nutrients that meat contains. Calories are not fungible - you can live off meat essentially indefinitely (especially if you eat the organ meat), but you'll rapidly a nasty case of iron deficiency and scurvy if you try to live off wheat. I feel this fact is often omitted from naive assessments of food efficiency. It's not nitpicking, it's a fundamental law - bioaccumulating reasonable levels of nutrient density will always take more energy that just building up raw calories. Vegans need to eat fatty, nutrient-dense plants like nuts and avocados to survive - these foods invariably have a much worse environmental footprint to wheat. I'd be interested to see comparative estimates of the impact of a "careless vegan" who eats exotic, problematic foods versus a "conscientious meat eater", who only eats locally sourced pasture-raised livestock.
- adrianN 7y agoGiven that chicken is reasonably good from a CO2/calorie viewpoint, my guess is that avocados flown in from the other side of the world are worse, but I'd also be interested in sources.
- esarbe 7y agoI'm very sorry to disagree, in my opinion this is nitpicking. Yes, you cannot live from wheat alone, insofar you are correct. But that was not the point of my reply. The point of my reply - to flesh it out - was that you need only use about 10 percent of the area required for cattle if we instead consume these calories directly. That doesn't have to be wheat, it can be peas, beans, nuts, beets, potatoes, celery and on and on. If you are concerned about nutrients, there's always chickens. Chickens are so vastly more efficient when it comes to land use than cattle, it's not even funny anymore. I hope that we soon have some reasonable supply chain of non-vertebrate protein (i.e. insects) at an affordable price. Thanks for your reply! Edit: I'm not a vegan, by the way. Not even a vegetarian. I enjoy the taste of meat and especially beef. But I'm convinced that the amount of resources we spend on meat - especially on beef - cannot be justified by anyone in good conscience.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoDepends where you are. What organic allows varies a fair bit around the world. UK's Soil Association is still stricter than the EU. I think US has one of the loosest. Not certain of how they all differ though. I know Soil Assoc try to promote interculture (two crops at once), field margins and what not, but have know way to know how that translates to reality or just pretty words on a website entirely ignored by the farmers, though I can probably guess. Pesticide use does come with limits on what and how often so they can legally keep saying low pesticides. I think that's about as low impact as it gets unless you have a decent sized garden as just about nowhere does it the old way any more. Beyond that I just don't know, which is frustrating for all shopping - we're given no idea of the impact of choices so have to basically guess. It needs to be on labels, but producers would fight that tooth and nail.
- afpx 7y agoThe USDA publishes their list of approved chemicals. https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=9874504b6f1025eb0e6b67cadf9d3b40&rgn=div6&view=text&node=7:3.1.1.9.32.7&idno=7#_top https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=9874504b6f1...
- consumer451 7y agoI am fortunate in that I have a few acres in a tiny town in Central Europe and I don't need a financial return from the land. I now keep the back lot as a meadow garden instead of the giant cut lawn that it used to be. I made sure that the surrounding farmers were cool with it as I was worried they would hate a "pest farm" on my land, but they understand. I own an additional 6 acres of farmland which I currently let a neighbor grow wheat on, but they spray all the normal ag-chems. I am looking at options for what to do with that as far as co2 mitigation and pro-bug land. My brother suggested that he could buy trees to plant as a carbon offset for every flight he takes out here. Maybe I could put the land in a trust, and open the tree purchasing to other folks that are looking for carbon offsets? A large meadow and growing the forest seem like the best options at this point. I would love to hear any other suggestions.
- tomxor 7y ago> buy trees to plant as a carbon offset I know you mean well, but unless you mean planting saplings - isn't buying trees just pushing around carbon offsets to change local figures while worsening global figures due to the cost of moving them?
- consumer451 7y agoYes, sorry, that’s more or less what I mean. I was thinking of getting a few dozen 4-6 foot tall trees to start. But I really need to do a lot of research here and consult some people who are educated in this domain.
- sgt101 7y agoTry to create some wetland - a pond, or if there is a stream dam it and flood some of the land.
- consumer451 7y agoUnfortunately I don't think that's too much of an option. This is all on a decent grade and pretty dry.
- scottlocklin 7y ago>...how can I judge the impact my food choices have on biodiversity? You can't, and neither you nor anyone else in this thread has any idea what to do about the insect apocalypse. Seems like insecticides, but we really don't know! Has insecticide use really increased that much since the 80s across the west? Doesn't seem likely. Maybe it is one specific insecticide used in growing X? Maybe some other chemical? Could be monoculture, disease, something that's already in the environment we can do nothing about; maybe it's solar panels and windmills (seriously -it's possible, and it would be ironic), maybe it's a change in drainage patterns, suburbanization, some chemical now commonly used in housing (or for all we know, skincare), changes in automotive shapes (maybe streamlined cars are more lethal to bugs somehow), or maybe insects are all "eff you, stupid apes, we're leaving before the Vogon constructor fleet gets here." As for individual choice; as difficult as it may be for people to believe after a century of "do your bit" propaganda starting from the first world war; your actions may have no bearing on the matter. Telling people what to do when you don't know doesn't help, and acts as a sort of psychological purity ritual. Like the recycling that ends up shipped to Indonesia and dumped into the ocean; you may be making things worse. FWIIW this kind of crap was often used to give people something to do and distract them from real problems: most of the WW-2 "scrap" campaigns for the war effort were useless. FWIIW I'm pretty sure the insect apocalypse isn't happening in northern Spain. The last time I was driving around there, the number of bugs on my windshield reminded me of when I learned to drive in the 80s. It is anecdata, but it was striking enough to be worth looking into.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> Seems like insecticides, but we really don't know! Has insecticide use really increased that much since the 80s across the west? The amount of insecticides used doesn't need to increase, to cause a mass extinction. A constant dose is enough, if it kills more insects in a given period, than are born in the same period. Over time, this will cause the number of insects to decrease steadily.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI don't understand how reducing meat intake benefits insects. Is there a connection?