63 ms·
Missing from all of the discussions about this is the fact that almost all of the electricity is purchased with the mining reward, which is temporary. It is cut
by modeless 7y ago
Missing from all of the discussions about this is the fact that almost all of the electricity is purchased with the mining reward, which is temporary. It is cut in half every 4 years, and will eventually dwindle to nothing. The amount of electricity Bitcoin miners can afford to buy therefore will fall.
Of course, until now that effect has been more than compensated by the increase in the Bitcoin price. But that certainly can't continue forever either, and so the electricity usage and carbon footprint of Bitcoin will inevitably fall in the future.
- nikanj 7y agoNo it doesn’t, assuming the mining tech improves via FPGA and ASIC, leading to more hashes per KWh. It’s very hard to predict the future ratio between hash rates and mining rewards.
- modeless 7y agoImprovements in mining tech do not change the total amount of Bitcoin earned by mining, and thus the budget miners collectively have to buy electricity. Efficiency of mining is irrelevant because the difficulty adjusts to keep the mining rate stable, and the total number of Bitcoins available to mine is fixed and unchangeable.
- gerikson 7y agoMining rewards will be replaced by transaction fees. There will still be an economic incentive to keep the hardware running.
- modeless 7y agoBut at that point the cost of the electricity consumption of Bitcoin will be borne entirely by Bitcoin's users, who will not pay more than the value they derive from use of the network. That would only fund a small fraction of today's Bitcoin mining electricity consumption.
- gerikson 7y ago> But at that point the cost of the electricity consumption of Bitcoin will be borne entirely by Bitcoin's users I'm not sure what you mean by this. If a certain percentage of energy is used by PoW, less is available for other purposes, and thus prices will rise for all energy users.
- modeless 7y agoMy point is that Bitcoin users will not pay transaction fees that are anything close to the current mining reward that is subsidized by inflation of the Bitcoin money supply. Therefore when the subsidy inevitably falls, so will the total income of all Bitcoin miners. And in the long term Bitcoin miners collectively cannot afford to buy more electricity than their total income, therefore their electricity consumption will also fall.
- gerikson 7y agoThanks for clarifying! Fees are denominated in satoshis though, and even today the average USD amount of fees is around $8,000 per block[1] (around 6% of the total reward). A 10x increase of the BTC price will make that amount around the same as the current total reward. [1] https://fork.lol/reward/fees https://fork.lol/reward/fees
- modeless 7y agoFees may be denominated in satoshis but unlike the block reward they are not fixed. Users choose their fees at every transaction, and they will not pay more than the value they derive from making transactions. The total value of all fees paid is determined by the actual usage of the network, not the Bitcoin price. Of course today usage of the network is somewhat correlated with price, but it's not directly proportional and the correlation will weaken in the future.