4 ms·
I don't think it's okay to test big powerful robots on public roads. Just because a robot looks like a car and has people sitting inside it doesn't make it oka
by carapace 7y ago
I don't think it's okay to test big powerful robots on public roads.
Just because a robot looks like a car and has people sitting inside it doesn't make it okay to ignore common sense. These things have already killed at least one person.
I've said it before: we could build self-driving light-weight "nerf" golf carts that would be useful without being deadly. Trying to jump immediately to self-driving cars is a techno-fetish.
- - - -
Edit to add: "People kill people so robots should be allowed to kill people too." is a rotten argument, eh?
- AOsborn 7y agoIn isolation, you're right. Why on earth should giant robots be tested on public roads, especially when they can kill people? When we actually look at safety on public roads, you know what kills more people? Other people. We don't need the robots to be perfect to get them on the road. We just need them to be safer than human drivers. That is a much lower bar to meet.
- carapace 7y ago> We don't need the robots to be perfect to get them on the road. We just need them to be safer than human drivers. > That is a much lower bar to meet. First, maybe. I don't doubt that auto-autos will be able to handle anything that's "in the book", and that, if we set it up right, "the book" will be constantly expanding and becoming more comprehensive as each machine in the fleet shares its history in near-realtime and offline processors integrate the data into new stimulus-response patterns or whatever. Etc. Handwave. But I also suspect that driving safely IRL requires GAI. (After all, we evolved GAI to deal with the world, eh? If the world were simpler we would be dumber, no?) Anyhow, let's grant the point for the sake of discussion: > We just need them to be safer than human drivers. Okay, fine... How do you know when they pass that point? Until we are sure that's the case, don't test them on the public roads with moms and dads and kids and old people and cats and dogs, eh? eh? - - - - And what about the nerf golf cart? I would love to have a machine into which I could confidently place my mother, who is suffering from dementia and can no longer drive or even ride the bus by herself, and have it transport her safely to and from, say, an appointment with her doctor. That machine doesn't have to travel more than 5-10 kph. One of the basic principles of safe auto-autos is that they should never travel faster than they can stop. Meaning, whatever the conditions, the aa should be 100% "confident" that it could stop before a collision, even if that means traveling at a walking pace. (If this isn't the case then you have built a killer robot whatever else it is. And it won't even protect you from the Terrible Secret of Space.) That's what I mean about self-driving cars being a techno-fetish. We could build something tomorrow that wouldn't be able to kill people and sell it, but we're obsessed with speed and don't even realize it. We're blinded by visions of driving Knight Industries Two Thousand.
- kalenx 7y agoIf we are still at test stage, I agree with you. However, my understanding is that the Waymo technology has been tested. It's entirely different than the Uber case, where engineers were literally deactivating emergency brake system because it was malfunctioning... Also, I don't get the "These things have already killed at least one person.". Sure, a car (autonomous or not) can kill. Yet, is the fact that human operated cars "have already killed at least one person" a good reason to disallow them on public roads?
- colechristensen 7y agoI'm starting to re-think riding my bike sharing the roads with robots. Robots are scary because they're still really really stupid. Driving 1,000,000 miles up and down the SF peninsula doesn't make you smart.
- puranjay 7y agoI don't mind being an early adopter for a revolutionary new phone or smartwatch. But an early adopter for something that could kill me? Umm...I'll just wait for the tech to mature.
- rdsubhas 7y ago> Edit to add: "People kill people so robots should be allowed to kill people too." is a rotten argument, eh? No, that's not the argument. The argument is – humans have killed other humans, so should we allow humans to still drive on the road? If yes, why? If not, why?
- carapace 7y agoI was going for rhetorical effect, but your question is a fair one. I wish we asked it of ourselves more often and in earnest. In my considered opinion, yes, cars are an insane method of mass transport† which have killed and maimed more people than war. I call our traffic systems the "Mayhem Lottery". > Road traffic accidents are the largest cause of injury-related deaths worldwide. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car#Safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car#Safety We did it to ourselves, deliberately: > The very word jaywalk is an interesting—and not historically neutral—one. Originally an insult against bumptious “jays” from the country who ineptly gamboled on city sidewalks, it was taken up by a coalition of pro-automobile interests in the 1920s, notes historian Peter D. Norton in his book Fighting Traffic. “Before the American city could be physically reconstructed to accommodate automobiles, its streets had to be socially reconstructed as places where cars belong,” he writes. “Until then, streets were regarded as public spaces, where practices that endangered or obstructed others (including pedestrians) were disreputable. Motorists’ claim to street space was therefore fragile, subject to restrictions that threatened to negate the advantages of car ownership.” And so, where newspapers like the New York Times once condemned the “slaughter of pedestrians” by cars and defended the right to midblock crossings—and where cities like Cincinnati weighed imposing speed “governors” for cars—after a few decades, the focus of attention had shifted from marauding motorists onto the reckless “jaywalker.” https://slate.com/human-interest/2009/11/a-defense-of-jaywalking.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2009/11/a-defense-of-jaywal... So yeah, it doesn't make sense to let people pilot massive (often a ton or more) powerful (as a team of N horses) deadly machines down every freakin street (and can we talk about the paving of the world?) just to get from point A to point B at M mph. Not in a world that includes bikes and buses! Here's the sick punchline: for all that death and mayhem, and all the other costs and externalities of car transport, you don't gain anything, you just break even. In "Energy and Civilization A History" by Vaclav Smil he points out that, once you factor in all the time spent working to pay for the car you're doing no better than if you just walked everywhere. Cars literally are no better than walking, economically. (†Although I really like the machines themselves.)
- Ensorceled 7y agoIn North America, people kill 33000 people a year in vehicle accidents. Your edit is so wide of the mark, bad driving by humans is a major cause of death. Self-driving cars don't have to be perfect, they just have to be better than bad human drivers.