3 ms·
> So, it seems instead of entering new markets during a time of favorable regulatory environment, companies chose to buy out competitors instead, lay off a bunc
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> So, it seems instead of entering new markets during a time of favorable regulatory environment, companies chose to buy out competitors instead, lay off a bunch of newly-redundant staff, and pocket the profit. Hmm.
You say favorable regulatory environment, but favorable to who? If you have a bunch of regulations that make it hard to start a new ISP and compete with the incumbents, but also get rid of the ones that prevent them from buying each other, it's hard to call that "deregulation" rather than regulatory capture.
- rayiner 7y ago> You say favorable regulatory environment, but favorable to who? If you have a bunch of regulations that make it hard to start a new ISP and compete with the incumbents, but also get rid of the ones that prevent them from buying each other, it's hard to call that "deregulation" rather than regulatory capture. Can you point to a non-hypothetical example of the former?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Can you point to a non-hypothetical example of the former? Build-out requirements that prevent small ISPs from forming to serve only a specific neighborhood.
- rayiner 7y agoFair enough, but an odd one to cite in the context of the point above regarding "favorable regulatory environment." I assumed you were talking about something in the federal law. State and municipal law has never been favorable to anything.
- eecc 7y agoHmm, what about the US prohibition for municipal utilities to provide network service and compete on the micro local level?
- rayiner 7y agoFirst, there are no such prohibitions at the U.S. (i.e. federal) level. Some states have such laws. Second, that is a poor example of regulations that "make it hard to start a new ISP and compete with the incumbents." Presumably, that's talking about upstart private competition. What you're saying is the opposite. Government entities or government-sanctioned monopolies (like the local power or water utility) don't in any sense "compete" with the private sector. They displace it. If you're a startup ISP, you can't hope to compete with say the local electric utility, which can make large capital investments in network service and recover from captive electricity rate payers. As an aside, the idea of government entities "competing" is a weird new brand of rhetoric (you also see it with the "public option"). I'm not sure where it comes from, but it makes no sense. If you're a New Deal liberal and believe government would do something better than the private sector, then own that. Don't pretend like private companies can meaningfully compete with an entity that doesn't have to turn a profit to stay in business.
- eecc 7y agoWell, I’m European... and especially with all the commotion about Ajit Pai, excuse me if I conflate the US federal institution with individual states... Second, in this case I remember reading of private monopolies arguing against municipalities threatening to roll out their own networks, exasperated by the poor service provided by the private sector. Over here, I enjoy the “Fruits of Socialism” (while they last) where private service providers have to co-own the infra and complain about regulators keeping a relatively open eye on them ;)
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoThe one that comes to mind is the airline deregulation of the 1970s. It phased out one regulatory body without institution of new powers upon the others. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_Deregulation_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_Deregulation_Act
- rayiner 7y agoI'm not sure what you're talking about. Airline deregulation didn't make it harder to start a new airline--to the contrary, lots of new airlines were started after deregulation.