3 ms·
Imagine if California just had proper trains ? Sydney, Australia has driverless trains now.
by bamboozled 7y ago
Imagine if California just had proper trains ? Sydney, Australia has driverless trains now.
- jedberg 7y agoWe have driverless trains too, they're called BART. To be fair, there is a person in front who watches what it's doing, but when they launched in the 60s, they didn't have anyone up front, and people got freaked out, so they added "drivers" who don't actually do anything but tell it when to close the doors.
- tjohns 7y agoMy understanding was that the drivers were originally added partly in response to the "Fremont Flyer" incident, where a test train under autonomous control drove itself off the end of the track: https://www.flickr.com/photos/walkingsf/8143196966 https://www.flickr.com/photos/walkingsf/8143196966 Even today, the automation on BART is far from perfect, and the drivers are more involved than most people realize. The trains still like to over-shoot the end of stations, requiring the driver to quickly initiate a manual stop. (The stop signal is RF based, and apparently sometimes the train misses it.) On top of that, they often need to drop down to manual control for certain sections of track, for various reasons.
- quickthrower2 7y agoSydney is not the shining beacon for public transport. London is far superior.
- tialaramex 7y agoPolitics means that London only has one GoA 3 system (the Docklands Light Railway, a grade-separated system where each train has a human operator who closes the doors and interacts with passengers) and no GoA 4 systems (which don't have any staff, humans are merely passengers). Even in the longer term London has no specific plans for GoA 4, although some London Underground lines which are below ground for their entire run will likely become GoA 3 and several are already GoA 2 (meaning a driver sits at the front but they don't make most routine operating decisions they just close the doors and watch the track ahead) Sydney has a GoA 4 system already.
- quickthrower2 7y agoBut in basic terms of getting from A to B without a car, for most A and B it is a lot more practical in London. I've been thinking about this and to be fair London has a much higher daily influx population than Sydney, from much further distances. The sheer volume of commuters will be funding all this transport, way in excess of the population of London itself.
- bamboozled 7y agoKind of my point, even Sydney has an autonomous train system now, California had absolutely hopeless rail.