3 ms·
I said the other day that it's time to stop having conversations with climate denialists. By denialist, I mean someone whose goal is is the establishment of a
by anigbrowl 7y ago
I said the other day that it's time to stop having conversations with climate denialists.
By denialist, I mean someone whose goal is is the establishment of a counter-narrative to the mainstream view of the causes, risks, and imminence of global climate change. Some argue that such discrimination will hinder sincere skepticism and innocent inquiry, but neither scenario seems likely to me.
Sincere skepticism is easy: simply respect the standards of the discipline, by arguing 'I disbelieve [scope of disputed phenomenon] for [reasons], which I have detailed in article at [journal or preprint]' and exhibiting a baseline level of respect and the same sort of good faith assumptions about others that one hopes to receive for oneself.
Likewise, sincere inquiry can proceed along lines like 'I don't understand [phenomenon], can you explain as I were in [grade/ college/ graduate school]' and a similar baseline level of respect for others' time and knowledge in assisting.
Insincere disputation is often characterized by disrespect for others' time or intelligence. Temporal disrespect most commonly manifests as endless questions, especially naive or simplistic seeming ones that become more and more technical while critiquing unwanted replies as unsatisfactory - a simple but effective strategy for manipulating a conversation by faking superiority. The lazier version of this is to simply abuse people by deriding their claims as hoaxes. Attacking the claimant proceeds by discounting their intelligence, integrity, or sanity without any basis in fact.
Of course, such 'critiques' are rarely persuasive to the target person, or to other participants in the discussion. They are not meant to persuade, but are a performative display designed to swindle the gullible, cause despondency in the frustrated, and humiliate the target for the amusement of sadists. Negatives reactions are equated to negative evidence and most if not all of the argumentation involves drawing logical conclusions from an invalid major premises which are usually epistemological nitpicks.
tl;dr it's not that hard to express or detect genuine doubt, curiosity, or confusion - nor bad-faith efforts to derail discussion.
- letsgvgpvpwr 7y agoMy main concern is that global climate change will be the excuse the world governments need to increase their power over us. Governments the world over are responsible for the most horrific of crimes against humanity, it is time for us to find and exercise a new model of governance.
- not2b 7y agoThere's no alternative to control. If you don't have a government, you have a local band of thugs running things, or you have a good thing for a little while (as in the Spanish Republic) until it gets crushed by fascists on one side and Stalinists on the other. You can have limited government, but it can't be so limited that cannot achieve the goal of stabilizing the climate. Your new model has to get the job done; if not, then half the planet becomes uninhabitable and billions have to move, resulting in wars like we've never seen. Cooperative arrangements are great when they work, but too many human beings are assholes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- flukus 7y ago> Likewise, sincere inquiry can proceed along lines like 'I don't understand [phenomenon], can you explain as I were in [grade/ college/ graduate school]' and a similar baseline level of respect for others' time and knowledge in assisting. Sincere inquiry is fantastic, but "skeptics" pretty much always phrase there objections as inquiry, 90% of the time you hear something like "how do we know it's caused by the sun?" it's a leading question from a "skeptic" firmly in the denialist camp, online it will often be by paid astro turfers (which I suspect the only other reply to you is at the time of writing this, a new account created to comment on climate change). This ruins the discussion for any sincere skeptics.