7 ms·
It is still a big deal, because customers are going to be a LOT more hesitant to buy stuff if they realize it's sold by a random Chinese dude and not Amazon.
by paxys 7y ago
It is still a big deal, because customers are going to be a LOT more hesitant to buy stuff if they realize it's sold by a random Chinese dude and not Amazon.
- sin7 7y agoAnd they should be.
- empath75 7y agoNot really. Amazon’s entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhy do you think that refutes sin7's point? And, if Amazon's entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits, all the more reason why Amazon should 1) reveal who the seller really is, or 2) be liable for the counterfeits.
- derefr 7y agoYou misread the comment you're replying to, I think. empath75's claim "Amazon’s entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits" is intended to mean that parties other than the seller—such as warehouse employees, delivery companies, importers, etc.—are also inserting counterfeits into Amazon's supply chain, such that even products "sold by Amazon" in the strictest legal sense, can potentially still be counterfeits. Given this, customers should already have been wary of purchasing from Amazon, enough that finding out that they're often purchasing from third-parties shouldn't further affect their opinion (i.e. they should already have as low an opinion of Amazon as if they had already known that, because of the other supply-chain problems.)
- nitrogen 7y agoHow much of that is supply chain issues and how much is commingling inventory with third party sellers?
- munk-a 7y agoMost people don't have that opinion though - things brought through Amazon are viewed as being vetted and high quality when compared to items through eBay or Wish - Amazon has made no effort to disabuse people of this conception and I personally think they've worked actively to downplay the role the third party plays in product delivery. I've also always been a bit curious if amazon might be liable for defective products shipped through their warehouse by virtue of the transfer of custody alone. This sort of business model is quite new (it's worlds different from a flea market) and there are several interesting commercial responsibility questions around it.
- OrgNet 7y agoI think that this article means the opposite... and that Amazon could be liable for stuff that you buy from random Chinese dudes. So it should become less risky.
- sidlls 7y agoThe GP means (I think) that this decision effectively forces Amazon to make a decision: either stop permitting third-party sellers or else require third-party sellers to identify themselves (and, implicitly, provide bona fide contact information). The result of the second option is that many third-party sellers on Amazon will be exposed as Chinese sellers who in practice cannot be held accountable. In both cases, Amazon loses business.
- pfisch 7y agoAmazon will just play games where you have to dig through a bunch of menus to figure it out.
- paxys 7y agoThey already do this today, and clearly the judge isn't letting it slide.
- crazygringo 7y agoGP here: And not just contact information, but a legitimate US legal and financial presence. If you're selling in the US, I need to be able to effectively sue you and win in the US if you sell harmful or illegal products, full stop. So you should have to put up some kind of financial bond and a law firm to represent you. Because mom and pop businesses can't do this themselves, this should be provided as a kind of insurance policy that's just part of the cost of doing business. Heck, Amazon can be that insurance policy if they want. But right -- if I can't sue you, you should under no circumstances be allowed to sell within the US on a US platform.
- sidlls 7y ago
- trentnix 7y agoAnd it allows manufacturers to see which sellers are skirting their reseller agreements and tighten up their distribution if they so choose.
- ryanlol 7y agoWhy would it be a random Chinese dude instead of a random American company?
- ryanlol 7y agoSo uh, what is supposed to keep the Chinese dude from paying $100 to start a LLC in the US to sell through? What exactly am I missing here?