5 ms·
Doesn't seem like a big deal, because: > In Wednesday’s opinion, Circuit Judge Jane Richards Roth, writing for a 2-1 majority of a three-judge panel, said Amaz
by crazygringo 7y ago
Doesn't seem like a big deal, because:
> In Wednesday’s opinion, Circuit Judge Jane Richards Roth, writing for a 2-1 majority of a three-judge panel, said Amazon may be liable in part because its business model “enables third-party vendors to conceal themselves from the customer, leaving customers injured by defective products with no direct recourse to the third-party vendor.”
Seems like Amazon can just force third-party vendors to reveal their full legal identity to the customer then?
I don't care who's liable as long as someone's liable and it's fully enforceable within the US court system.
- ryanhuff 7y agoIANAL, but what happens when the third party vendor is in China, effectively out of reach from a US consumer? Would Amazon be the defacto responsible party.
- onemoresoop 7y agoThey can be banned from amazon at least
- bdcravens 7y agoI think the issue is more than just exposing full legal identity. The shopping experience on Amazon is an abstraction. When looking at Product X, on different days, different sellers may be in the "buy box". From the customer's perspective, they are buying from Amazon, not the vendor.
- jammygit 7y agoAnd this is deliberately misleading
- paxys 7y agoIt is still a big deal, because customers are going to be a LOT more hesitant to buy stuff if they realize it's sold by a random Chinese dude and not Amazon.
- sin7 7y agoAnd they should be.
- empath75 7y agoNot really. Amazon’s entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhy do you think that refutes sin7's point? And, if Amazon's entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits, all the more reason why Amazon should 1) reveal who the seller really is, or 2) be liable for the counterfeits.
- derefr 7y agoYou misread the comment you're replying to, I think. empath75's claim "Amazon’s entire supply chain is filled with counterfeits" is intended to mean that parties other than the seller—such as warehouse employees, delivery companies, importers, etc.—are also inserting counterfeits into Amazon's supply chain, such that even products "sold by Amazon" in the strictest legal sense, can potentially still be counterfeits. Given this, customers should already have been wary of purchasing from Amazon, enough that finding out that they're often purchasing from third-parties shouldn't further affect their opinion (i.e. they should already have as low an opinion of Amazon as if they had already known that, because of the other supply-chain problems.)
- nitrogen 7y agoHow much of that is supply chain issues and how much is commingling inventory with third party sellers?
- munk-a 7y agoMost people don't have that opinion though - things brought through Amazon are viewed as being vetted and high quality when compared to items through eBay or Wish - Amazon has made no effort to disabuse people of this conception and I personally think they've worked actively to downplay the role the third party plays in product delivery. I've also always been a bit curious if amazon might be liable for defective products shipped through their warehouse by virtue of the transfer of custody alone. This sort of business model is quite new (it's worlds different from a flea market) and there are several interesting commercial responsibility questions around it.
- kd5bjo 7y agoInventory commingling could also be a problem here— the vendor you’re ostensibly buying from isn’t actually providing the product you receive, and there’s no way to find out who did provide it.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Seems like Amazon can just force third-party vendors to reveal their full legal identity to the customer then? Minimizing the prominence of seller identity and maximizing that of the Amazon brand has been a key Amazon business strategy; they very much want sellers not to matter. I suspect, though, that even were that problem cured, their commingling practice would leave them liable unless they also allowed buyers access to the identity of and the ability to reject transactions based on the original product source (which may not be the seller, due to commingling) with FBA products.
- joyjoyjoy 7y ago" Seems like Amazon can just force third-party vendors to reveal their full legal identity to the customer then?" I bought a defective sever power supply from a 3rd party seller at Amazon in Europe. Amazon claims they don't know the identity/address/email of this seller. Wrote it off as a loss. Edit: I mean, Amazon must have given this guy my money. They must have something from him. Bank account, Email etc.
- stevenjohns 7y agoAgreed. If that's the case, then this is completely fair. If Amazon wants to conceal information about the seller, then they have to deal with the things that the seller would usually deal with.
- floatingatoll 7y agoAmazon could end up being required to declare the seller’s information to the buyer (at time of purchase!), and required to validate that information using expensive non-trivial practices such as business license lookups and tax form SSN/EIN checks. This court decision implies that liability defaults to Amazon under their current practices, and shifting that liability would need to involve disclosure prior to sale. These are all absolutely market-destroying things - and when you apply them to eBay, which does not provide seller contact information or perform tax validation before the sale occurs, it only worsens in potential impact for businesses profiting off of their enforcement-free approach today.
- duncan-donuts 7y agoSounds like a good thing to protect consumers. Would this be problematic for most people?
- jammygit 7y agoI was researching creating a 2 sided marketplace for selling certain electronics this week. This is a bad omen maybe
- floatingatoll 7y ago"I'm going to compete with eBay in a market visibly riddled with fraud and malicious actors" is probably a bad omen regardless of the third-party problem. But. If you arrange the transaction between the two sellers and hold payment+device in escrow, then that's clearly "arranged between two sellers" and wouldn't be the target of this ruling. (Escrow insurance isn't cheap, though. And without escrow, you have nothing but risk.)
- harimau777 7y agoThat would require Amazon to stop co-mingling real and counterfeit products which would in turn dramatically help the problem. It probably wouldn't fix everything but being able to make an informed decision would help.
- bitL 7y ago> Seems like Amazon can just force third-party vendors to reveal their full legal identity to the customer then They already do. You have their data on invoice.
- joyjoyjoy 7y agoBullocks. For example, try to track down this seller (Amazon Germany) https://www.amazon.de/sp?asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&seller=A38EK8GC5Z9E9B&tab=&vasStoreID= https://www.amazon.de/sp?asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&sel...
- bitL 7y agoOK, I am not that familiar with Amazon DE's operation, I only ran companies that acted as 3rd party sellers on Amazon US, including writing MWS software, and they had certain requirements.
- crazygringo 7y agoOn invoice? What invoice? When I order from a third-party seller, there's no guarantee there's any invoice? If they ship directly, sometimes it comes with a kind of paper receipt, sometimes it doesn't. If they fulfill via Amazon, it definitely doesn't. I don't think I've gotten a receipt/invoice with any Amazon package in years... (I remember it used to come with them.) And I click through my online order and click on the name of the seller, it just has tabs with things like generic shipping and return policies. I can't find any legal or contact info whatsoever beyond the name.