3 ms·
As tombert mentioned, ddrescue to generate an iso is probably fine for DVDs. Note that you will need to use something to initialize the DVD or many drives will
by aidenn0 7y ago
As tombert mentioned, ddrescue to generate an iso is probably fine for DVDs. Note that you will need to use something to initialize the DVD or many drives will just refuse to read out encrypted sectors; something like "dvdbackup -I" will work fine.
As a note, do not use slim dvd or bluray drives for this; I went through several and found that they would have many read errors for DVDs that play fine in actual players and full-height drives.
I am not aware of a good way of getting the full menu experience on bluray discs. For many discs, stripping the menus saves 1-4 minutes of time when watching the movie though, so I haven't worried about it too much.
[edit]
Also, if your DVDs have any dust on them, clean them with a microfiber cloth and spray for cleaning glasses before inserting. ddrescue will usually complete eventually, but it can literally be days with a dirty or scratched disc.
For everyone else: if you don't care about menus &c. makemkv is great. It's not libre software, but the linux version is perpetually in beta so it's free-as-in-beer (though I purchase a license because it's just so darn useful).
- tombert 7y agoI think MakeMKV is slightly better than "free as in beer", because you do have the source to audit, you just can't distribute it willy-nilly like with something with a true FLOSS license. I too actually bought a license, because it's one of my favorite pieces of software that perpetually "just works".
- aidenn0 7y agoI thought the bulk of makemkv was closed source, with only a porting layer that is built and linked as part of the install process? [edit] I looked at a recent download and a lot more of it delivered as source than I thought (even under a GPL or LGPL in many cases). makemkvcon is shipped as binary only though.