3 ms·
Indeed, Massachusetts has the oldest constitution still in force in North America (older than the US federal constitution). People mostly felt loyalty to their
by gumby 7y ago
Indeed, Massachusetts has the oldest constitution still in force in North America (older than the US federal constitution). People mostly felt loyalty to their own state and that was one reason for opposition to the v2 national constitution, even when it was clear the v1 articles were inadequate.
Even so, they are united States (as opposed to, say, Australia where the so-called "states" are for all intents and purposes merely administrative subdivisions of the continent, and could be remade by passing a law in the federal parliament)
Source: Massachusetts high school education in a school 150 years older than the MA constitution.
- frenchyatwork 7y ago> Even so, they are united States Are you sure? I'm pretty sure that argument was resolved in 1865.
- gumby 7y agoMostly only the "united" part, and amendment 10 still says that stuff not in the constitution (e.g. amendment 13 or 16) ain't in the federal purview. Hence weird contortions like stretching the interstate commerce clause, tying drinking age to highways funding, and the like. And just look at the presidents who got the job without winning the vote. I think things would have been better if things had ended up less federal as a result of 1865, but things ended up the way they are now.
- bigger_cheese 7y ago>Even so, they are united States (as opposed to, say, Australia where the so-called "states" are for all intents and purposes merely administrative subdivisions of the continent, and could be remade by passing a law in the federal parliament) I don't think this is accurate. Prior to federation there were no Australian states, there were 6 independent colonies. The status of the states are part of the Australian Constitution to make changes (such as creating a new state) would require amending the constitution and thus a referendum. The Australian States have quite a bit of power its one of the "challenges" we have here because of the way our constitution is written in order for a referendum to pass it requires a double majority you need an overall majority as well as a majority in a majority of states (i.e 4 out of 6 states must also have majority support) this is one of the reasons constitutional amendments are so difficult and rarely pass here. Similar thing with our senate (Upper house) each state has equal representation in the senate so both Tasmania and New South Wales have 12 Senators despite much smaller population in Tas. This is in contrast to House of Representatives (our lower house) is not equal (there are 5 seats in Tasmania vs 47 in NSW) this has a lot of implications in our political process. As far as people not feeling loyalty to their state that's mostly true but there is still a lot of friendly (or not so friendly rivalry) especially in sporting events.
- gumby 7y agoI actually learned this when visiting Parliament House last year (though it was part of an off-the-tour side discussion +). Having lived in both countries I think the independence of the US states is radically and fundamentally stronger than that of the Australian states, especially since (and because) income tax was federalised 75 years ago. The only place I know that even comes close to the US independence of the states is Germany. + I was visiting a friend who works there; later went out to dinner with him and a colleague who is a constitutional lawyer and who was quite familiar with the American system as well.
- ajdlinux 7y ago> I actually learned this when visiting Parliament House last year (though it was part of an off-the-tour side discussion). Having lived in both countries I think the independence of the US states is radically and fundamentally stronger than that of the Australian states, especially since (and because) income tax was federalised 75 years ago. It's a mixture of factors, but vertical fiscal imbalance enabled by the First Uniform Tax Case is certainly part of it. As I'm sure you're aware Australians generally have fewer objections to centralised government. Culturally Australia has historically been significantly more homogeneous across the different states than the US, even our accents are more similar between different states. > The only place I know that even comes close to the US independence of the states is Germany. Switzerland?
- bigger_cheese 7y agoI know nothing about US system so I can't really compare the two. The only reason I know anything about our own constitution is I had to do a school project on Sir Henry Parkes way back in high school. Personally I kind of have opposite view about the states I do think there needs to be a trade off between federal and state power our current system is flawed but probably strikes a good balance. I'm sympathetic to fact that someone living in say Regional QLD has different needs to Melbourne or Sydney and I don't want a system where power is consolidated in the big population centers and no one else's vote really matters but at the same time I'd like voting power to be more proportional as it stands someones vote in Tasmania holds a lot more weight federally then voters from many of the other states due to equal (rather than proportional representation) of the states.
- caf 7y agoEven so, they are united States (as opposed to, say, Australia where the so-called "states" are for all intents and purposes merely administrative subdivisions of the continent, and could be remade by passing a law in the federal parliament) This isn't really true. The fundamental setup of the Constitution of Australia is that the separate States retain their existing power to make laws and enforce laws on essentially any matter (with some very specific carve-outs, like the states may not coin money, raise armed forces or try to impose a tax on the Federal government). The Federal Parliament is granted the power to make laws only with respect to an enumerated set of heads of power. This is, for example, why the Federal Government was able to overrule voluntary euthanasia legislation in both the Territories, but cannot in the case of the State of Victoria. The vertical fiscal imbalance mentioned elsewhere certainly is an issue, where the State Governments are responsible for most service delivery but the practical revenue-raising ability of the Federal Government is significantly greater. This results in the Federal Government using 'tied grants' to influence State policy, but it is my understanding that a similar thing happens in the US as well (for example in the case of raising the drinking age to 21). In terms of remaking the States, the Constitution specifically disallows altering the limits of a State without the consent of that State's Parliament and passing a referendum of that State's voters.