7 ms·
It took a decade for the Declaration of Independence to matter in American life
- smacktoward 7y ago> Rarely during the late 1770s and 1780s was the Declaration publicly read or celebrated. Instead, most Americans celebrated their state constitutions and the promise of liberty contained within them. Or they celebrated their local declarations from 1776. Only during the 1790s was the Declaration revived... It seems relevant here that the late 1770s and 1780s was also the same period when the United States was governed under the Articles of Confederation, rather than the Constitution we have today (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederation_Period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederation_Period). The Articles of Confederation established a much weaker central government than the later Constitution would. So it would make sense, in a regime where the several states were still regarded as near-sovereign entities, that people would look to the founding documents of their state as the guarantors of their liberty. And it also makes sense that, when the weak central government proved unable to meet the challenges of the time and people started thinking about replacing it with a stronger one, new attention would be drawn to documents like the Declaration that spoke from a national perspective.
- burfog 7y agoIt was like the EU.
- n4r9 7y agoIn the sense of being somewhat federalised, maybe, but > had little authority, and could not accomplish anything independent of the states. It had no chief executive, and no court system. Congress lacked the power to levy taxes, regulate foreign or interstate commerce, or effectively negotiate with foreign powers. sounds nothing like the EU!
- tialaramex 7y agoInterestingly the EU also doesn't levy taxes. Unlike the US under the Articles of Confederation though, EU member states actually value central government, and so they do actually pay to run it (all EU governments pay in, but EU schemes have the effect that the poorer states get back more than they paid in various forms). That Congress wasn't able to get anything done because in practice the States didn't allow it to get anything done. A lot of the same thinking that's today popular on the US West Coast brought down that government. "Oh, I'd definitely _voluntarily_ pay for a central government, I just don't want mandatory taxes". "Oh did I say I'd definitely pay? I'm short right now, hit me up next month." "Actually I decided I don't want to contribute to anything I'm not totally in favour of, I need veto over all decisions or else I won't be paying". "Huh, funny, why did the government fail?" And that's why the modern US government has tax raising powers. Just as the UK can rightly say it tried not having kings, hated it, so got a new king but now very clearly at the whim of the people; the US can say it has tried not having mandatory taxation and that didn't work so yes it now has taxes (with or without representation) and that won't be changing.
- FigBug 7y agoI'm not an American, how does this compare to current US West Coast?
- smacktoward 7y agoThe Californian ideology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Californian_Ideology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Californian_Ideology
- wahern 7y agoI grew up in Florida (Rep. Joe Scarborough's district, back when he was a rabid conservative and a leader in the Republican revolution) and Alabama, worked as an intern at a neoconservative K Street think tank in the late 1990s/early 2000s, and went to law school in Virginia in the late 2000s. I've lived and worked on and off in the Bay Area for nearly 15 of the last 20 years, and have plenty of family in Southern California (including a sister and cousin who are active politically, one progressive the other more a Californian conservative), so understand the vibe down there. The sentiments of the techno-utopians on the west coast and the settlers before them shouldn't be equivocated to the anti-civic sentiments of Southern conservatism and the national conservative movement that emerged principally from the Bible belt and Sunbelt states in the 1990s. Keep making that mistake and we'll have decades more of civic and political nihilism. Even the most starry-eyed Silicon Valley billionaires dreaming about basic incomes and robo-basilisks still seek to engage with government and the state. Gingrich, perhaps more than any other politician (he did lead the Republican Revolution, after all), is a walking incarnation of the modern Republican ideology, and he's an avowed nihilist when it comes to government. Similar all-or-nothing, bitter attitudes are creeping into the political left and it will likewise lead to political decay. It's not healthy. People should feel to disagree with and criticize Benihoff, Mayer, Musk, Zuckerberg, etc; but step back and compare them to people like Carla Fioroni. Who's politics should you really be afraid of?
- phkahler 7y agoFrom the article "Rarely during the late 1770s and 1780s was the Declaration publicly read or celebrated. Instead, most Americans celebrated their state constitutions and the promise of liberty contained within them. Or they celebrated their local declarations from 1776." Though it doesn't say when those state constitutions were enacted, it sounds like the states were already separate things. That would explain the lack of interest in the declaration of independence at the time. "But Wilson thought its significance lay elsewhere: in confirming that the United States was born a nation rather than a series of independent states." If there were state constitutions prior to that, I'd say who cares what Wilson thought - facts are facts. Besides, how can you have someone sign from every state if those states are not already meaningful entities? I think a better stance is to say the nation was formed over a period of time, based on a set of principles and ideas (most importantly "we are separate from the old world"). Documents only served to formalize what was happening and agree on how to settle some differences.
- Qwertystop 7y ago> Besides, how can you have someone sign from every state if those states are not already meaningful entities? The states were meaningful entities as distinct colonies before they declared independence, regardless of the manner in which that independence was declared.
- gumby 7y agoIndeed, Massachusetts has the oldest constitution still in force in North America (older than the US federal constitution). People mostly felt loyalty to their own state and that was one reason for opposition to the v2 national constitution, even when it was clear the v1 articles were inadequate. Even so, they are united States (as opposed to, say, Australia where the so-called "states" are for all intents and purposes merely administrative subdivisions of the continent, and could be remade by passing a law in the federal parliament) Source: Massachusetts high school education in a school 150 years older than the MA constitution.
- frenchyatwork 7y ago> Even so, they are united States Are you sure? I'm pretty sure that argument was resolved in 1865.
- chrisco255 7y agoThe U.S. was still at war until 1783. The declaration wouldn't have meant anything if the U.S. had lost. Jefferson was the original author, although it did undergo edits at the behest of Congress. It's also pretty well established that the document was complete by July 2nd (so the mention about Jefferson going shopping on the 4th is sort of weird) and most of the Congress had signed it then, but not all...so it went into effect July 4th. The declaration was read in town squares all over the country. It wasn't forgotten about while people were dodging musket fire by red coats. It's sort of a ridiculous assertion. It's just: war is messy. And the business of laying the foundations for a country afterwards is fraught with risk and uncertainty.
- garmaine 7y agoJefferson was the assigned leader of the committee that wrote the declaration. It's really more accurate to say he was the editor. It's not universal opinion, but it's very likely that most of the declaration, especially the most-quoted parts ("inalienable rights", "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", etc.) were written by Thomas Paine. However as a very recent immigrant from England, crediting Paine would have been politically unthinkable.
- wahern 7y ago"[R]econstruction of Thomas Jefferson's 'original Rough draught' of the Declaration of Independence before it was revised by the other members of the Committee of Five and by Congress": https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/declara/ruffdrft.html https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/declara/ruffdrft.html It already contains all of those. If anything, Jefferson was cribbing from George Mason. But all of these men were well read (e.g. in the works of John Locke), and they presumably were well read in each others' publications considering their political and social associations.
- garmaine 7y agoThere was a book about it in 1947 that was never really refuted. But basically, the famous writing style of the declaration doesn't match any of Thomas Jefferson's pre-1776 writings at all. Nor anyone else on the committee of 5. And the "original draft" of Jefferson's contains copy errors indicating itself was copied from another source. There's also the fact that the content--very anti-slavery, and very anti-monarchy--doesn't much resemble Thomas Jeferson's contemporary philosophy either. There is one thing it does resemble, very closely: Common Sense, written by Thomas Paine and released in the same year. Here you can read them side-by-side: https://richardmasta.liberty.me/wp-content/uploads/sites/582/2016/07/001.jpg https://richardmasta.liberty.me/wp-content/uploads/sites/582... One of the other reasons we know the "original rough draft" of Jefferson's that you mention was a copy of another document is that John Adams also made a copy of the original draft, and his is different. Notably his draft includes a lot of weird (by American standards of the day) punctuation, spelling, and word choice which is typical of Paine's writing but was edited out of Jefferson's "rough draft." In any case I did point out that this is not a universal belief. But I will be bold enough to say that we can divide historians into two groups: the vast majority who were taught that Jefferson wrote it and believe it, and the few who have actually looked at the evidence and concluded that someone else did, quite probably Thomas Paine. The evidence is that compelling. (Thomas Jefferson never in his life claimed that he write the declaration. He in fact played down his involvement numerous times. It was, however, necessary in the sphere of global politics that the declaration be perceived to have been written by the continental congress, which Jefferson was a member of, and not a dirt poor recent immigrant who was the editor of a failing newspaper that and happened to be friends with Jefferson, Adams and Franklin.)
- zcid 7y agoAs a side note, his home town, Charlottesville, canceled the holiday celebrating Thomas Jefferson's birthday[0][1]. It seems to me that our society is too focused on condemning historical persons for their flaws than celebrating them for their noteworthy deeds. [0]https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/jul/2/charlottesville-drops-thomas-jeffersons-birthday-h/ https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/jul/2/charlottesvi... [1]https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/07/03/as-trump-predicted-charlottesville-cancels-thomas-jeffersons-birthday/ https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/07/03/as-trump-predi...
- bgilroy26 7y ago" Add to these, flowing hair, a more elegant symmetry of form, their own judgment in favour of the whites, declared by their preference of them, as uniformly as is the preference of the Oran-utan [orangutan] for the black women over those of his own species. The circumstance of superior beauty, is thought worthy attention in the propagation of our horses, dogs, and other domestic animals; why not in that of man?" -- Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia[1] He was a disgusting person who should be relegated to the annals of history, not celebrated with a birthday party like a blood relative. [1] https://www.stolaf.edu//people/fitz/COURSES/Jefferson--Notes.htm https://www.stolaf.edu//people/fitz/COURSES/Jefferson--Notes...
- plurinshael 7y agoWell, yes. It was unmitigated praise for men like Jefferson for a lot of years, which sent the message that those flaws you mentioned were nonexistent or unimportant. Now our society is attempting to demonstrate to people of color that those flaws as you say, which constitute extremely egregious crimes against humanity no matter how commonplace they were amongst the aristocracy of the time, were in fact real and were in fact important. The country remains rather divided on the subject but it sounds like these city officials are trying to say that black lives do, in fact, matter.
- chrisco255 7y agoThe country fought a bloody war 160 years ago to settle that dispute and it was pretty resoundly settled. Not only that but there isn't a country on the planet that doesn't have equally horrific past. But that's horrific to us only because Jefferson and the colonists won. And their philosophy won. There's nothing inevitable about the destruction of monarchy. We might have been ruled by Kings and lords for another 2000 years. Who the hell knows? The people aggravating other people for celebrating American heritage have sick aims. No amount of time or human sacrifice will be enough until all pride in U.S. is snuffed out. And then, what are we left with?
- eaguyhn 7y agoA more interesting story is how the Constitution came about, and how the Confederation nearly split apart during ratification.
- lkrubner 7y agoJoseph J. Ellis, in his book "Founding Brothers: The Revolutionary Generation", makes the case that it wasn't till the 1810s and 1820s that Americans began to argue about the origins of the country, and increasingly settle upon July 4th, 1776, as the starting point of the country. It's an unusual decision, because most countries base their holidays around when the first battles occur. The French celebrate Bastille Day, which is July 14th. But in the USA there are no celebrations on April 19th, which is a bit surprising. The heroism shown at the battles of Lexington and Concord are forgotten, whereas a bunch of men signing a document is raised to the level of something epic. And it is said that the USA began in 1776, instead of 1775. If the French followed such reasoning, they would say that the French Revolution began on September 20th, 1792, because of the Battle of Valmy. To suggest that the USA begins on July 4th of 1776 represents a victory for Thomas Jefferson, and for the factions associated with him. The key thing is that Jefferson's factions were very popular during the 1810s and 1820s, when Americans were making up their minds about how they should understand the origin of the country. https://www.amazon.com/Founding-Brothers-Revolutionary-Joseph-Ellis/dp/0375705244/ref=sr_1_2?crid=2ZBS7D3LOFWUF&keywords=revolutionary+brothers&qid=1562183943&s=books&sprefix=revolutionary+brother%2Cstripbooks%2C186&sr=1-2 https://www.amazon.com/Founding-Brothers-Revolutionary-Josep...
- jt2190 7y ago> But in the USA there are no celebrations on April 19th, which is a bit surprising. The heroism shown at the battles of Lexington and Concord are forgotten... While not national holidays, there is certainly remembrance and celebration. https://www.nps.gov/mima/patriots-day.htm https://www.nps.gov/mima/patriots-day.htm And for the kids: https://youtu.be/rZMmPWTwTHc https://youtu.be/rZMmPWTwTHc
- jpindar 7y ago> But in the USA there are no celebrations on April 19th There certainly are in New England! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriots%27_Day https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriots%27_Day
- WalterBright 7y ago> The heroism shown at the battles of Lexington and Concord are forgotten, whereas a bunch of men signing a document is raised to the level of something epic. The signers were heroes, too, because signing the DoI was a hanging offense. If the Revolution had failed, they would have all hung and they knew it. They were all prominent men, and their families would have been likely ruined as well.
- tomohawk 7y agoThe war did not end until 1783. The document had an immediate and huge impact in that defined just how real the breach was with the mother country. When news reached New York City, there was actually a riot. Many of the signers paid a steep price, and certainly many who rallied to the cause did as well.
- peterwwillis 7y agoOh man, I'm so glad this reminded me of "What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?" by Frederick Douglass. It's a thrilling, masterful speech.