4 ms·
Ask HN: Human replacement rate be adjusted to 1/2 surviving progeny/person
Should we adjust our replacement rate from 2.2 to 0.5 surviving child per person?
Setting aside emotional reactions, wouldn’t we all survive as a species if we have a manageable population.
If we continue to compete with each other for gene pool domination, isn’t it folly as none of us will survive and it is akin to species suicide?
A request: Please don’t downvote or flag this post if it offends you. My comments get downvoted when I suggest population reduction and that’s ok.
But I would like to discuss this without the topic being considered taboo or untouchable.
It would be nice to explore different scenarios where we would be at 1..2..3 billion total population or a time progression of population growth at 50..100..150..200 years at various replacement rate levels. How does one project this?
- aphextim 7y agoI think that in the end having so few humans on the planet would not be able to sustain our current economic model where companies want as many consumers as possible to maximize their profits. Eventually with automation many menials jobs could be replaced and have been replaced slowly over the past century or so. I think with the advent of A.I. systems many tasks will be automated freeing up humans to be the maintainers of such systems and we eventually would not need as many humans to produce for the needs of everyone. This allows a world population of 1,2,3 billion to be able to maintain/produce enough to sustain everyone efficiently though automated systems. Getting to that population would take many generations of educating people that aren't privileged in the 1st world to learn to cull their habits. This needs to be done willingly and not forcefully otherwise you just have a genocide similar to another person who wanted one perfect society.... This could be done through incentives where if a country shows it is lowering the overall impact of it's population and is consolidating itself to be better for all, to be rewarded with economic incentives, better trade deals and other means. Countries who fail to reduce themselves would be missing out and even if the elected leaders would prefer it that way eventually the citizenry would ideally get itself a leader who would represent the interest of the population. Sadly, representation doesn't happen in many places on this planet and trying to do this peacefully without war/violence against those who refuse would be the hardest challenge. Other countries may need to 'wait' them out for a generation or two. Refusing to trade/help them and let them self destruct with over consumption until their population is small enough that they are willing to rebuild. However, when it comes to getting everyone on the planet to work in step with each other for the benefit of all and not a self-serving interest.....good luck. Just my 2 cents on this 'taboo topic'
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoThanks for a well thought out reply. If we incentivize people to procreate responsibly rather than reward all procreations(tax break, better quality of life, UBI) rather than create punitive measures, then we will be able to hasten meaningful change.. I would like to see robotics and automation in farming. I think this would move us away from chemical warfare on environment. With more automation and hedonistic lifestyles, UBI etc..plus anti-aging/life extension and ways to clone/preserve our best genetic material(and combinations/permutations thereof), why should there even be a desire for biological procreation. There will be no more clock ticking.
- gus_massa 7y ago> isn’t it folly as none of us will survive and it is akin to species suicide? Do you have a link to a credible source that predict human extinction? Someone serious like the IPCC. Most model predict huge problems and catastrophes. If the hot and low level part of the word become more difficult to inhabit, there may be huge migrations and perhaps wars. Imagine something like: Everyone moves from the south of India to Siberia, and that makes India and Russia unhappy. But in most models the change is slow, so perhaps something like this can be done peacefully. (I guess not 100% peacefully, but I hope with a small amount of problems.) What are the predictions for the increase of the sea level and temperature in 2119?
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoWe are in the middle of sixth extinction or holecene extinction..as a global super predator..and apex predator, we can’t survive past mid way of an extinction event as we depend on other species and terrestrial/marine resources for our existence. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sixth_Extinction:_An_Unnatural_History https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sixth_Extinction:_An_Unn...
- gus_massa 7y agoFrom the fist link: > Possible scenarios [for human extinction] > Population decline through a preference for fewer children. If developing world demographics are assumed to become developed world demographics, and if the latter are extrapolated, data suggest an extinction before 3000 AD. John A. Leslie estimates that if the reproduction rate drops to the German level or Japanese level the extinction date will be 2400. However, evolutionary biology suggests the demographic transition may reverse itself. The second link is about a huge problem, but it's not clear that it will hit us (I can't find anything specific about human extinction in the link.) It's more dangerous for overspecialized apex predator like whales that only can eat krill. Even if we drop animal farming, we can choose from a dozen of common cereal the one that is better for the new climate. Perhaps bananas that like hot weather and are used as staple food in many countries. The third link is very similar. I can't find anything specific about human extinction in the link. Also remember that in a book the author can cherrypick the parts to get a better story and sell more books. Try to look in the IPCC report to have a scientific source.