6 ms·
The actual report[1] is very interesting to read. I was surprised that there were zero App Store takedown requests from governments in North America, South Ame
by reaperducer 7y ago
The actual report[1] is very interesting to read.
I was surprised that there were zero App Store takedown requests from governments in North America, South America, and Australia.
All of the takedown requests came from China, Vietnam, and Europe; including Norway and Switzerland.
[1] https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/pdf/requests-2018-H2-en.pdf https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/pdf/requests-2018-H...
- elliekelly 7y agoTo my knowledge, the US government (or at least the FBI) “negotiates” a takedown of a problematic app with the developer directly.
- twodayslate 7y agoSource?
- elliekelly 7y agoPersonal knowledge/professional experience. While it certainly isn’t my area of expertise I have no reason to believe law enforcement handled this particular situation differently than they would any other. I will say that I didn’t think the government had much of a leg to stand on from a legal perspective (so perhaps that could have necessitated their “negotiation” approach) but the stress of the ordeal provided quite a lot of leverage to get the developer to take it down.
- chatmasta 7y agoAll the EU countries (Norway, Switzerland and Netherlands) include the footnote "All or vast majority of requests relate to illegal gambling investigations."
- Biganon 7y agoSwitzerland is not part of the EU.
- adsche 7y agoAnd neither is Norway.
- derefr 7y agoSometimes people type "EU" when they mean "Europe." Like people type "America" when they mean "The United States of America."
- Retric 7y agoThough they are part of Schengen which abolishes border control with the EU and makes things confusing for visitors.
- ollie87 7y agoTrue, but they are part of the single market.
- Communitivity 7y agoAlso, a National Security Letter may require that the takedown not be publicized in any way. This is in part what led to the concept of warrant/NSL canaries: a statement in a legal doc such as terms, etc. that says there have been no warrants or takedowns orders received. If the canary is removed from the doc then it is not publicizing the NSL, but the canary's absence is supposedly required by law (IANAL) because keeping it in there would be a falsehood in a legal document, and so the absence indicates the NSL/takedown occurred.
- Communitivity 7y agoJust to add to this, Apple did have a warrant canary. It disappeared in 2014 [1], suggesting that they have been receiving warrants and possibly takedowns for the last 5 years. [1] https://gigaom.com/2014/09/18/apples-warrant-canary-disappears-suggesting-new-patriot-act-demands/ https://gigaom.com/2014/09/18/apples-warrant-canary-disappea...
- ls612 7y agoAn NSL can only be used to subpoena metadata from a provider without the provider being allowed to inform anyone. It can’t be used to compel a company or person to do much else.
- Zenst 7y agoWell, thank you (sarcasm at play here obviously) Germany for pushing Europe towards the top with 67% of all the requests based upon the total given for Europe, Middle East, India, Africa Total. Why they bundle those into one total is equally odd, though maybe some telco regional grouping legacy aspect at play perhaps - thinking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurasia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurasia I'd work out the Europe total, but that would only depress me further. Why does Germany stick out compared to other countries in Europe - some Stazi hangover mentality! Who knows, but some serious questions need to be asked as clearly some major disparity amongst EU countries at play here. But I'm sure they will get their shrills to bury that question, hmmmm. Germany 12,343 requests Europe, Middle East, India,Africa Total 18,205